-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Which trilogy is the best: Mass Effect 1-2-3, Dragon Age 1-2-3, Witcher 1-2-3, Fallout 3-NV-4, Elder Scrolls 3-4-5
- Thread starter Phediuk
- Start date
NV > All
I've never been a fan of Bethesda's internal output.
As far as trilogies go probably Mass Effect even though I can't seem to go back to them, maybe some day.
I've never been a fan of Bethesda's internal output.
As far as trilogies go probably Mass Effect even though I can't seem to go back to them, maybe some day.
Out of these, it's the Mass Effect trilogy by a mile (well, several miles) for me. I spent so, so, so many hours in that wonderful universe across all three games.
Prime 1 and 2 were amazing but 3 was the beginning of the end for the Metroid series.
Agreed.
i'm sure i'm not the only one but why is Metroid Prime GOAT Trilogy not included in this fantasy?
The answer is more likely Mass Effect since each game improved various elements from the previous and it tells 1 story so cohesively well.
I'm going to vote dragon age though, mostly because overall I spent more time in that world. The lore is impressive, the world interesting and rich and while it's not as cohesive or tight with a singular vision as Mass Effect, I enjoyed the variety it proposed.
So, Mass Effect is best trilogy while dragon age personally brought me the most enjoyment. (I loved Inquisition and Trespasser, had a stronger ending to me than ME3)
I'm going to vote dragon age though, mostly because overall I spent more time in that world. The lore is impressive, the world interesting and rich and while it's not as cohesive or tight with a singular vision as Mass Effect, I enjoyed the variety it proposed.
So, Mass Effect is best trilogy while dragon age personally brought me the most enjoyment. (I loved Inquisition and Trespasser, had a stronger ending to me than ME3)
Even with the ending of the third game, the ME trilogy definitely feels the most cohesive by far out of all the franchises listed. That isn't to say I don't adore the DA games, F:NV, and TW3, but yeah, easily the ME trilogy.
I agree with just about everything you said but I was specifically talking about the vote list there.
Most of those other ones either have really rough beginnings or a sharp decline in quality at the end.
Mass Effect for me. I didn't feel like Witcher 2 - 3 was all that connected but I did enjoy them both a lot.
I'd have to say The Witcher for me. Games and story get better as they go, characters are well done and we care about them and it ends in a very satisfying way, especially with the dlc in there.
I wish I could say Mass Effect, but I really hated almost everything that happened with that series after the first one. I know people love 2, but I was so let down by it ultimately and don't even start me on 3.
I wish I could say Mass Effect, but I really hated almost everything that happened with that series after the first one. I know people love 2, but I was so let down by it ultimately and don't even start me on 3.
You want a list war? I'll list war with you....
How has no one said Fallout 1 / Fallout 2 / Fallout New Vegas?
How has no one said Fallout 1 / Fallout 2 / Fallout New Vegas?
Despite the fact I'll NEVER fully get over the ending..mass is the best goddamn trilogy in gaming and I dont believe well ever see a AAA RPG attempt that kind of character identity ever again.
Out of the series I've played,
Fallout has a weak link with Fallout 3, while ES has a weak link with Oblivion.
The Witcher 1, from what I've played, isnt too hot either.
Halo is the best story-connected trilogy, while GTA 3D universe is the overall best.
Fallout has a weak link with Fallout 3, while ES has a weak link with Oblivion.
The Witcher 1, from what I've played, isnt too hot either.
Halo is the best story-connected trilogy, while GTA 3D universe is the overall best.
I'm really kind of shocked that Mass Effect is doing so well. There's maybe a game and a half of good content there - as much as I love that series it's with a lot of caveats. It's not THAT far ahead of Dragon Age, which I think is universally considered a mixed bag as a franchise.
Next to the Witcher - even with the raw jank of the first game - neither of them really compare. Even if, personally, I like Dragon Age the best of the three.
Next to the Witcher - even with the raw jank of the first game - neither of them really compare. Even if, personally, I like Dragon Age the best of the three.
Elder Scrolls for me. That is like 2200 hours of my life.
Mass Effect 2 pissed me off too much. Removed finding equipment and outfitting your part, skill tree cut in half, Wrex never to be a party member again
Mass Effect 2 pissed me off too much. Removed finding equipment and outfitting your part, skill tree cut in half, Wrex never to be a party member again
Last edited:
It's between Mass Effect and The Witcher.
But when it comes to popularity poll like this, the one franchise that's available in more platforms should win by default.
But when it comes to popularity poll like this, the one franchise that's available in more platforms should win by default.
Mass Effect for sure. Citadel alone is enough reason.
Although I hold Dragon Age dear to my heart as well. But Mass Effect takes the cake.
Although I hold Dragon Age dear to my heart as well. But Mass Effect takes the cake.
Out of those, Mass Effect, even if Witcher 3 and New Vegas are the strongest games listed there individually.
Of course, Metal Gear Solid 1-3 is actually the best trilogy though.
Of course, Metal Gear Solid 1-3 is actually the best trilogy though.
If we want to stretch what constitutes an RPG, then S.T.A.L.K.E.R. SoC/CS/CoP.
And even though it wouldn't get as many votes, Shadowrun Returns/Dragonfall/Hong Kong.
I'm still comfortable with ME. Although the STALKER games are my favs, they're less RPG than the other options on this list.
And if we want to go old school, Ultima VI/VII:BG/VII:SI
And even though it wouldn't get as many votes, Shadowrun Returns/Dragonfall/Hong Kong.
I'm still comfortable with ME. Although the STALKER games are my favs, they're less RPG than the other options on this list.
And if we want to go old school, Ultima VI/VII:BG/VII:SI
Mass Effect. Though if Witcher 1 weren't such a weak link I would maybe throw it the Witcher's way.
Yeah, Mass Efect, besides the last 30 min of 3, and 2 effectively being filler, they're all masterpieces.
Dragon age 2 was trash, Witcher 1 wasn't good, Fallout 4 is so bad writing wise, Arkham Knight is bad writing wise, Skyrim is pretty bleh.
GTA Ps2 trilogy would be one.
How about...
Ratchet & Clank
Ratchet & Clank: Going Commando
Ratchet & Clank: Up Your Arsenal
Dragon age 2 was trash, Witcher 1 wasn't good, Fallout 4 is so bad writing wise, Arkham Knight is bad writing wise, Skyrim is pretty bleh.
GTA Ps2 trilogy would be one.
How about...
Ratchet & Clank
Ratchet & Clank: Going Commando
Ratchet & Clank: Up Your Arsenal
The other series have individual games better than those in the Mass Effect series (ex. Fallout New Vegas, Witcher III), but taken as a whole Mass Effect Trilogy runs the table with the other choices.
Witcher 3 is basically a next level Mass Effect style game only much better in just about every way and easily the strongest of all the games imo. Witcher 2 was very very good but also kind of stand alone and I still haven't played Witcher 1. I gotta put it as incomplete for me atm.
So with that said my personal trilogy ranking would be:
1. Mass Effect - The series that I had the most connection to, loved just about everything about it. Sci-fi Space operas with cool aliens and diverse planets and cultures are definitely my wheelhouse. Plus it felt the most like it was made to be one big overarching story told in a trilogy of games.
2. Fallout - Another one in my wheelhouse with the 50s alternate future. Kind of in between Mass Effect and Elder Scrolls in that you get a little more memorable characters like the former and the living world of the latter.
3. Elder Scrolls - Kind of a love hate thing for me, the weakest when it comes to compelling hand crafted stories and memorable characters but the best for just fucking around and dynamic systems for getting immersed in a game and making your own stories.
4. Dragon Age - Really enjoyed them but just didn't stick with me like the others in the long run.
So with that said my personal trilogy ranking would be:
1. Mass Effect - The series that I had the most connection to, loved just about everything about it. Sci-fi Space operas with cool aliens and diverse planets and cultures are definitely my wheelhouse. Plus it felt the most like it was made to be one big overarching story told in a trilogy of games.
2. Fallout - Another one in my wheelhouse with the 50s alternate future. Kind of in between Mass Effect and Elder Scrolls in that you get a little more memorable characters like the former and the living world of the latter.
3. Elder Scrolls - Kind of a love hate thing for me, the weakest when it comes to compelling hand crafted stories and memorable characters but the best for just fucking around and dynamic systems for getting immersed in a game and making your own stories.
4. Dragon Age - Really enjoyed them but just didn't stick with me like the others in the long run.
