1917 and Dunkirk are a close match, but 1917 edges it out I'd say. You can't go wrong with either.
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Which of these recent War "Epic" Films is worth the watch?
- Thread starter No Depth
- Start date
1917 and Dunkirk are both great films but I'm not sure how their gimmicks would hold up on second viewing (which obviously doesn't impact the first viewing).
I really like Fury, to be honest.
Fury > 1917 > Dunkirk
But in saying that, 1917 is the best 'movie' of the lot.
I really like Fury, to be honest.
Fury > 1917 > Dunkirk
But in saying that, 1917 is the best 'movie' of the lot.
Dunkirk is phenomenal. Incredible tension and pacing, easily my favorite of Nolan's. It bears all his strengths and none of his weaknesses. It's loud and practical and nonlinear and none of the characters talk very much.
1917 is a lovely theme park ride, though some of its wilder moments strain credibility. Still highly recommended.
1917 is a lovely theme park ride, though some of its wilder moments strain credibility. Still highly recommended.
OP
OP
I have an Atmos soundbar with rear speakers. It isn't quite as convincing with the vertical effect as a dedicated system offers(or a soundbar with better upfiring), but its impressive enough. But yea, mostly looking for a good film with great audio to enjoy.
I knew Midway was cheescake from impressions(and didn't expect much in the poll) but have seen mentioned the audio is astounding in it, so I included. Probably will rent it at some point.
Not to make this a thread about Tenet, but its the amalgamation of all of Nolan's worst tendencies. It's easily the worst film of his I have seen.
From that list? 1917, easy. Then Fury. Dunkirk, I suppose if you really want to subject yourself to it. I found it to be tedious, dull, and horribly over hyped.
In fact, skip Dunkirk, Hacksaw, and Midway entirely. Put in Blackhawk Down instead. And maybe Letters from Iwo Jima?
If you want something slightly different, but still a decent war movie that's in a similar vein as Blackhawk Down, check out Operation Red Sea.
Just be aware, Operation Red Sea does have some seriously blatant pro China propaganda at the very end.
In fact, skip Dunkirk, Hacksaw, and Midway entirely. Put in Blackhawk Down instead. And maybe Letters from Iwo Jima?
If you want something slightly different, but still a decent war movie that's in a similar vein as Blackhawk Down, check out Operation Red Sea.
Just be aware, Operation Red Sea does have some seriously blatant pro China propaganda at the very end.
Das Boot indeed towers over the rest of this list. Probably my favorite WWII movie bar none (haven't seen Come and See yet).
Found Dunkirk incredibly boring [really souring on Nolan these past few years, Tenet was abysmal].
1917 proved its worth as a film in a somewhat tired genre, like fully - incredible film.
1917 proved its worth as a film in a somewhat tired genre, like fully - incredible film.
1917 is the standout.
Of course, but OP was asking about recent movies.
Of course, but OP was asking about recent movies.
I haven't seen 1917 yet. Of the rest, Dunkirk is the best, though it's still flawed. Band of Brothers is better than all of them.
Also, you forgot They Shall Not Grow Old. That was fascinating.
Also, you forgot They Shall Not Grow Old. That was fascinating.
Midway was horrible holy shit
Dunkirk tried some very bold shits but not all paid off
Hacksaw Ridge is just gore fest
Dunkirk tried some very bold shits but not all paid off
Hacksaw Ridge is just gore fest
all of themAll of these films slipped through and I have been meaning to enjoy one or two with my Home Theater setup. Just curious on people's thoughts on each as they all seem beloved and praised.
my ranking
Hacksaw Ridge
Dunkirk
midway
1917
Fury
I watched Hacksaw Ridge and some of the action in it...is a bit over the top right? It felt almost comical lkke I was watching 30 minutes of the Predator shootout scene. I looked up reviews afterwards and I didn't see any standout comments about it so not sure if it was just me.
Also though
was a bit on ths nose especially with Gibson directing...totally missable I say.
Depends on your type of war movie, 1917 and Dunkirk I thought were fantastic. Fury was alright, more colourful and exciting I guess.
Also though
Him being lowered at the end, hanging with obvious comparison to Jesus
Depends on your type of war movie, 1917 and Dunkirk I thought were fantastic. Fury was alright, more colourful and exciting I guess.
OP
OP
I haven't seen 1917 yet. Of the rest, Dunkirk is the best, though it's still flawed. Band of Brothers is better than all of them.
Also, you forgot They Shall Not Grow Old. That was fascinating.
Have the Band of Brothers boxset! Never did see the documentary though, will watch!
Das Boot is absolutely insane lol. I watched the long version (mini series) of that last year in a day and it was a real journey.
Been wanting watch Lawrence of Arabia recently, just haven't made the time.
Vote: Fury
Caught it in theatres and I was pleasantly surprised. I wasn't expecting much, but I enjoyed it.
Last edited:
I knew about 1917 going in, and it still impressed the hell out of me.
Dunkirk was incredible in IMAX, too.
Dunkirk was incredible in IMAX, too.
Did you know there's a Das Boot series? On Hulu I think.
Das Boot | Rotten Tomatoes
A story of choices and survival that explores the emotional torment of life during World War II -- and the brutal reality of living within a senseless war.
www.rottentomatoes.com
Did you know there's a Das Boot series? On Hulu I think.
Das Boot | Rotten Tomatoes
A story of choices and survival that explores the emotional torment of life during World War II -- and the brutal reality of living within a senseless war.
Hmm, I did not. Interesting that it's a sequel according to wikipedia...
Dunkirk is a disservice to the actual event. The movie is such a tiny scale compared to real life that it's hard to enjoy what was there. Terrible war movie.
1917 on the other hand is the movie Dunkirk tried to be, definitely watch.
Fury has great visuals and atmosphere, you have to turn your brain off for the final act though.
Midway is egregious green screen and not a good movie to watch either. The action parts are pretty much "group of guys scream in front of green screen."
Hacksaw ridge is very good, wasn't expecting much with the casting but pleasantly surprised and it's based on a story that they had to tone down for the movie.
Greyhound is something you need to see though. Highly recommend for a war movie, very little fat and wonderfully tense during the whole movie.
1917 on the other hand is the movie Dunkirk tried to be, definitely watch.
Fury has great visuals and atmosphere, you have to turn your brain off for the final act though.
Midway is egregious green screen and not a good movie to watch either. The action parts are pretty much "group of guys scream in front of green screen."
Hacksaw ridge is very good, wasn't expecting much with the casting but pleasantly surprised and it's based on a story that they had to tone down for the movie.
Greyhound is something you need to see though. Highly recommend for a war movie, very little fat and wonderfully tense during the whole movie.
I haven't seen 1917 yet. Of the rest, Dunkirk is the best, though it's still flawed. Band of Brothers is better than all of them.
Also, you forgot They Shall Not Grow Old. That was fascinating.
Is They Shall Not Grow Old on any streaming services?
1917 and Fury are good, I thought Hacksaw Ridge was so bad that I could only get through half of it. Dunkirk was just kinda okay.
HBO. Or pay $2.99 elsewhere. And for future reference:
They Shall Not Grow Old streaming: watch online
They Shall Not Grow Old streaming? Find out where to watch online. 45+ services including Netflix, Hulu, Prime Video.
Last edited:
Nice. You'll have a good time with all of these from that perspective. Wasn't expecting anyone else to come in here and give an audio or home theater experience opinion on these. This forum in general doesn't seem to have many people who are into it or know much about it.
Spot on play for Miday. What I did was rent the blu ray (which has the Atmos mix) from a redbox at my local grocery store for like .99 back in February when it came out I think. Worth it that way
Edit: Fury could be the best of the bunch.
Honestly, Dunkirk.
This is despite the fact that I can't finish a second watching. 1917 is just pretty visuals but lifeless and logic defying. Hacksaw Ridge is enjoyable but is about hokey religion, lots of gore at the end, and is directed by Mel "Kill All The Jews" Gibson. Fury actually makes me upset with out inaccurate it is. And I never saw Midway.
This is despite the fact that I can't finish a second watching. 1917 is just pretty visuals but lifeless and logic defying. Hacksaw Ridge is enjoyable but is about hokey religion, lots of gore at the end, and is directed by Mel "Kill All The Jews" Gibson. Fury actually makes me upset with out inaccurate it is. And I never saw Midway.
"terrible" is a step too far for me, but yeah the small scale of what we actually see on screen compared to the real life scale, along with the level of hype the movie got, is very disappointing.
This movie was good, more of a drama than action though:
Thanks. I missed my chance to see it in theaters. My dad would be really interested in seeing it, too.HBO. Or pay $2.99 elsewhere. And for future reference:
They Shall Not Grow Old streaming: watch online
They Shall Not Grow Old streaming? Find out where to watch online. 45+ services including Netflix, Hulu, Prime Video.www.justwatch.com