Welp, I've got to leave this thread. Mario 64's soundtrack is one of the goats.
Sonic for this poll though
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Which game has the better music: Super Mario World, or Sonic the Hedgehog?
- Thread starter Phediuk
- Start date
Welp, I've got to leave this thread. Mario 64's soundtrack is one of the goats.
Sonic for this poll though
I voted "not sure", but now I'm just excited that Sonic has a chance of getting a W and I'm pulling for it.
The real battle would be Super Mario Bros. 2 (USA) vs Sonic the Hedgehog 2.
Now that's a fight.
This is not such a fight, Sonic wins.
Now that's a fight.
This is not such a fight, Sonic wins.
My immediate thought was that it's Sonic surely, I mean Super Mario World is the same one theme remixed over and over for the most part while Sonic 1 has Starlight and Green Hill Zones.
But then I remembered that Scrap Brain zone kinda grates on my ears and I'm indifferent towards Marble and Spring Yard.
And the less said about the Special Stages the better.
Digging deeper into SMW gets you a bunch of instantly memorable and punchy to the point map ditties, dat bonus room/switch palace theme, and the water, castle and athletic variants of the main overworld theme are tops with an HM to the echoey cave theme that also isn't just 1-2 yet again.
Both have solid boss themes and title screens, but SMW has a full blown credits number while Sonic goes for a lazy ass medley.
If this wasSonic 1 Master System Sonic 2 it'd be a handy stomp for Sonic but honestly Sonic 1 lacks the sauce for me, I'll go with SMW.
But then I remembered that Scrap Brain zone kinda grates on my ears and I'm indifferent towards Marble and Spring Yard.
And the less said about the Special Stages the better.
Digging deeper into SMW gets you a bunch of instantly memorable and punchy to the point map ditties, dat bonus room/switch palace theme, and the water, castle and athletic variants of the main overworld theme are tops with an HM to the echoey cave theme that also isn't just 1-2 yet again.
Both have solid boss themes and title screens, but SMW has a full blown credits number while Sonic goes for a lazy ass medley.
If this was
SMB2 overworld can't carry nearly that hard to win against the might of Sonic 2
Maybe the REAL fight is
Sonic 4 Episode 1 vs New Super Mario Bros
"owww my freakin' ears"
In fact, Sega doesn't even own the OST to Sonic 1 and Sonic 2, they are owned by Dreams Come True.
Sonic 2's ending was actually a hit single in japan. It was written for Sonic 2:
They even gave it an international release:
AKON remade it in 2006:
Like, watch that second video, how nuts is that? The Sonic 2 ending theme, being played to an entire stadium of cheering people. And it's not a video game concert.
In general, Sonic has better music than Mario, but in this instance, SMW has better music than Sonic 1.
imo it's sonic, one of the few areas where it seems completely better than smw.
smw music never really stood out that much to me - it's nice in a "this circus music vibe suits the upbeat tone of the game" way, and it has a lot of nostalgia for me these days, but sonic's early soundtracks were actively great, even separate from the games themselves.
sonic soundtrack just has a more cohesive vision and style, while the mario world soundtrack feels more generic to me. there's a reason why you'll hear people hear a certain 80's/90's synthy sound and describe it as sounding like a genesis sonic soundtrack, but you never really hear anyone refer to music as "sounding like super mario world" - at least, not referring specifically to the snes game.
smw's still the better game for sure, but the soundtrack doesn't stack up.
smw music never really stood out that much to me - it's nice in a "this circus music vibe suits the upbeat tone of the game" way, and it has a lot of nostalgia for me these days, but sonic's early soundtracks were actively great, even separate from the games themselves.
sonic soundtrack just has a more cohesive vision and style, while the mario world soundtrack feels more generic to me. there's a reason why you'll hear people hear a certain 80's/90's synthy sound and describe it as sounding like a genesis sonic soundtrack, but you never really hear anyone refer to music as "sounding like super mario world" - at least, not referring specifically to the snes game.
smw's still the better game for sure, but the soundtrack doesn't stack up.
Last edited:
ANY Mainline?
Didn't know you were such a fan of these dying duck synths
I wanted to single out a really bad NSMB DS track to post here but upon looking into it, I find it's more that the entire swathe of them are just so mediocre they send you into sheer apathy, not even fun to dunk on like the above, just resounding blandness.
Sonic 4 has much better compositions, but the instrumentation is just terrible.
So NSMB wins for at least not being annoying to listen to. And yes, I'm including the "bahs" when I say that.
Only Tee Lopes can save us now
You know, honestly even with Sonic 4's infamously shitty audio, I think I like a bunch of tracks way more than the first NSMB which has the overworld and castle as the only ones I'd admit to liking.
Basically someone give me non shitty sounding Mad Gear Zone
i mostly played sonic 4 episode 2 with a mod that replaced the entire soundtrack with music from panty & stocking and it was a tremendously better experience for it
Nah, I'm sorry, can't get behind any Sonic 4 music praise. It's shit
This is a bad joke against the real deal
This is a bad joke against the real deal
It sucks that when all the classic Mario games got new stage themes via Mario Maker 1 and 2, SMW still got swindled with its reliance on remixing that one theme, which is of course true to the source but even then the new forest, airship and snow themes were just a bit weak when compared to what SMB1 and 3 got.
That said, the Desert theme? hell yeah
That said, the Desert theme? hell yeah
the fact that this poll isn't an absolute fucking blowout honestly just proves how poisoned the sonic name is to some people
I like Hill Top Zone...
I wouldn't say Sonic 1's OST is weak in and of itself, but I definitely think the other Genesis games beat it (which I consider to have some of gaming's all time great soundtracks). But then I'm personally not a big fan of the Green Hill theme, my favorite themes are Starlight and Scrap Brain. (I voted Sonic in the poll.)
The actual demo tapes Masato Nakamura sent Sega from Dreams Come True for them to digitize into the Sonic soundtrack:
You know, when I first saw this question I immediately was going to say SMW. But I'm listening to the Sonic 1 OST now and good lord, these were bangers.
SMW's soundtrack is like 3 songs with variations, this one goes to Sonic and it's not even close, and that's even with Sonic 1 having the weakest OST of the Genesis/MD games.
Oh, are we recognizing this channel now? This guy has done some great stuff.
