• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

kiaaa

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,848
This thread should have been about specific foods because calling any major city's food scene over or underrated is just ridiculous.

Also, I prefer stuffed, but Chicago deep dish is still great.
 

kvetcha

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
7,835
Chicago-style works a lot better if you think of it as a pizza casserole and not a proper pizza.
 

dingobingo

Banned
Dec 5, 2017
2,099
Underated = Cincinnati is not that bad

Overrated = Europe tourist trap zones, super expensive super mediocre
 

Sotha_Sil

Member
Nov 4, 2017
5,064
I spent a year in Abu Dhabi and was shocked at how many meals I enjoyed there. From the fine dining to the little hole in the wall places to Mina fish market, it was good food all over. The general lack of alcohol obviously puts some points against it, but that's just the name of the game over there.

I wouldn't recommend going there just for the food or anything like that, but if you ever go there for business know that you'll have some good options.
 

dingobingo

Banned
Dec 5, 2017
2,099
I spent a year in Abu Dhabi and was shocked at how many meals I enjoyed there. From the fine dining to the little hole in the wall places to Mina fish market, it was good food all over. The general lack of alcohol obviously puts some points against it, but that's just the name of the game over there.

I wouldn't recommend going there just for the food or anything like that, but if you ever go there for business know that you'll have some good options.

Dubai is better lol
 
OP
OP

Deleted member 23850

Oct 28, 2017
8,689
I was disappointed with Chicago Pizza. Detroit style is so much better, I'm sad Chicago Pizza in Chicago was on my bucket list of things I wanted to do in my life. My hometown Detroit had the far superior pizza and I took it for granted.

I only "took back what I said" because Austin, Texas.
 

Violence Jack

Drive-in Mutant
Member
Oct 25, 2017
41,744
Underrated: Denver
Overrated: San Francisco

Maybe it's because I didn't go to the right places, but I was really disappointed by the offerings in San Fran. It was merely OK, but I've had much better elsewhere. But everyone I've taken out for food in Denver has raved about it. I've yet to eat at a bad place here.
 

SwampBastard

The Fallen
Nov 1, 2017
11,028
The food scene here in Indy has been blowing up for the past few years. Here's a Forbes article from last year calling us America's most underrated city, with food being a major reason.

Food & Drink: Come for the big games, stay for the great food. Culinary site Thrillist named Indy one of the 7 Most Impressive American Cities of 2017 for food, the same year Food & Wine Magazine named it one of the Top 20 Food Cities in the U.S. From Midwestern comfort foods like tenderloin sandwiches to omakase from James Beard nominees, Indy is having its moment in the culinary sun. Another Beard nominee and Indy's food Queen, Martha Hoover, now has around ten eateries of very varied concepts, and her latest, Crispy Bird, serves insanely good fried chicken using a French-inspired heritage breed chicken she is having custom raised on an Indiana farm, making this the only place in the country you can eat it. Perhaps the richest classically trained chef on earth, Kimbal Musk, business partner of his famous Tesla and SpaceX brother, just expanded his burgeoning healthy restaurant empire here from Colorado with two new eateries. Famed race car driver AJ Foyt and his family recently opened a wine bar and tapas style tasting room cum racing museum directly across from the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, the famed "Brickyard." The Foyt Wine Vault brings the best of the award-winning Foyt Family Napa and Sonoma vineyards to the Midwest.

Things have only gotten better since then, and there should be a lot more happening in the next 12 months with some major developments in the downtown area, including the Bottleworks project that's turning an old Coca-Cola bottling plant into a mixed use site with some anticipated new restaurants. Granted, almost everything in Indiana outside of Indianapolis is shit, but the city is a great place to eat.

Not sure about overrated, but I'd say Asheville, NC is pretty underrated. Had me one of the best burgers there.
I love Asheville. I haven't been in forever and I had a lot less discretionary income available the last time I visited than I do now. Some great breweries, too.
 

MistaTwo

SNK Gaming Division Studio 1
Verified
Oct 24, 2017
2,456
I'll be there in a week. I'll compare both and get back to you! I did hear Osaka is the actual foodie city of the two though.

It's very hard to go wrong with any city in Japan, but Osaka is really where a lot of the roots of overall Japanese cuisine are which is why I feel like it should get more international acclaim!

Two of my favorite areas are the Tenroku shopping street (full station name is a mouthful--Tenjinbashi-suji rokuchome) which has a lot of street food and B-tier gourmet spots. I have had cheap sushi there that still rivals some of the best michelin star kaiseki in Tokyo, hands down.

And the Shin-sekai area with its abundance of Kushi-katsu places is easily one of my favorite spots to eat in the country. I always take visitors there.

People squabblin over Tokyo VS Osaka instead of talkin Sapporo smh

I have heard Sapporo is amazing, and everything I know about it is that it has a very different food culture to this day when compared to Honshu.
It's still the one destination inside the country I haven't visited...
The Kanto region just lacks that distinct culture in comparison.
Monjayaki vs.Okonomiyaki is not even a fair fight...

You could walk around with a bucket on your head in any city in Japan and find restaurants through echolocation alone - and STILL only eat exquisite food except for the odd Goemon Spaghetti accident. But the number one rule I tell people visiting big cities in Japan on food is: Don't assume the good stuff is on the ground floor. Floors are arbitrary in Japan. And the "mall food court" is not Hot Dog on a Stick it is a wonderland of sometimes incredible gourmet treasures. The tonkatsu place in Takashmaya in Shinjuku is the best fried thing on earth, for example. Gimme that cabbage salad too.

Yeah, the high rise kaiseki places in Tokyo are great and all but the true strength of Japan
is just that the average quality in any city is just outrageously good. I make it a habit of just wandering into unknown places
and even after more than a decade of living here I can count the number of 'bad' experiences I have had on one hand.
 
Last edited:

Pickman

Member
Nov 20, 2017
2,266
Huntington, WV
Buffalo is overrated. Their sandwiches suck. The fuck is a beef on weck anyways? Just a stale ass Arby's sandwich.

St. Pete, FL has a really good little food scene. Lots of good restaurants, awesome cuban and island food, and surprisingly competitive local pho shops that are multi-generational. You get real cow foot in your soup there.
 

Stinkles

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
20,459
It's very hard to go wrong with any city in Japan, but Osaka is really where a lot of the roots of overall Japanese cuisine are which is why I feel like it should get more international acclaim!

Two of my favorite areas are the Tenroku shopping street (full station name is a mouthful--Tenjinbashi-suji rokuchome) which has a lot of street food and B-tier gourmet spots. I have had cheap sushi there that still rivals some of the best michelin star kaiseki in Tokyo, hands down.

And the Shin-sekai area with its abundance of Kushi-katsu places is easily one of my favorite spots to eat in the country. I always take visitors there.



I have heard Sapporo is amazing, and everything I know about it is that it has a very different food culture to this day when compared to Honshu.
It's still the one destination inside the country I haven't visited...
The Kanto region just lacks that distinct culture in comparison.
Monjayaki vs.Okonomiyaki is not even a fair fight...



Yeah, the high rise kaiseki places in Tokyo are great and all but the true strength of Japan
is just that the average quality in any city is just outrageously good. I make it a habit of just wandering into unknown places
and even after more than a decade of living here I can count the number of 'bad' experiences I have had on one hand.

Yeah I feel guilty for going back to my favorites because that 99% guarantees I missed an amazing new place. I'm not kidding when I say in some neighborhoods you could pick a spectacular restaurant by playing spin the bottle
 

Book One

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,819
Houston had been underrated for a while, but the last few years have started to get the attention for its food that it deserves.
 

thesoapster

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,909
MD, USA
The food scene in Baltimore is hella underrated. It's actually pretty diverse (new American, Mexican, El Salvadorean, Korean, Indian, etc)


These places are bomb
-Clavel
-Mi and Yu Ramen Bar
-Woodberry
-Cingale
-Brown Rice
-Jong Kak
-The Bun Shop

Clavel on my list for the mezcal.
Cocina Luchadoras wound up on my radar based on the story of them putting up the Ilegal Mezcal poster against Trump, and some fucking redneck threatening the life of the owner.
I went to that corner shop hole in the wall (only a few blocks from Max's) and got one of their tortas. Fuck. Me.
 

Bumrush

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,770
The posts that say "I spent 2 days in NY and the food is overrated" are killing me. There are over 20K places to eat in NYC
 

Camp1nCarl

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,135
Eh, I find it hard to call any decent sized city overrated considering the amount of options each has and me probably not being there long enough to try many different places.

Regarding underrated, I find a lot of the US midwestern cities (Madison, Minneapolis, Detroit, etc.) have great food scenes but don't have the allure of a city like Chicago, hence the lack of coverage/awareness.

Speaking internationally underrated (as an American), I was really surprised by Seoul. Besides Korean BBQ, I think Korean food is pretty underrated in general and the Korean food there was fantastic.
 
Oct 28, 2017
1,969
It's funny to see people listing Chicago. I went there for the first time recently and the food selection and quality was phenomenal.

Though maybe I'm only saying that because I'm from Seattle and our food scene suuuuuuuuucks.
 

Cation

The Fallen
Oct 28, 2017
3,603
I'll be there in a week. I'll compare both and get back to you! I did hear Osaka is the actual foodie city of the two though.

For me, I always rep Pittsburgh, especially in threads by Andrew Korenchkin
Our food scene has erupted over the last decade with unique gastropubs, street food, and fine dining popping up all over the place. Breweries and distilleries gaining national attention. Very underrated food city.

From Richard DeSchantz, James Beard nominee for Restaurateur
http://takopgh.com/ Korean/Mexican fusion
https://www.meatandpotatoespgh.com/ the kickstarter of our gastropubs, with an amazing brunch

From Justin Severino, 4 time James Beard nominee for best chef:
http://www.morcillapittsburgh.com/ Spanish cuisine with a family-style menu

My personal favorite, wood fired Argentinian meats walk-up counter:

Most awarded-craft distillery in the US:

Nation's first "chef incubator". A Cafeteria-style dining hall where chefs get their start by opening a small stand. They get a short term lease to build capital and a following so they can open their own brick-and-mortar place

And that's not to leave out the mom-n-pop shops and dive bars with great food dotted all over the city.
Was just about to say Pittsburgh, seems like you did a great job
 

bazzi

Member
Dec 19, 2017
676
Boston is good but nobody comes here for the food. Good, stay out of my restaurants, I'll just quietly enjoy the fact we have the best Italian food in the American continent, also some criminally under appreciated Caribbean and Vietnamese communities


This is not an unpopular opinion, it's some new York supremacist bullshit that borders on pizza nationalism. How many times have people reposted the idiotic Jon Stewart rant that is undoubtedly his lowest moment? Pizza gatekeeping is the ugliest look, it's a big tent food and should reflect the culture and place where it's made. All pizza is beautiful


Street scene??? Basically no city in the US has a street food scene aside from food trucks and maybe a hot dog cart here or there, no idea why you'd expect more in Chicago
Can u recommend some places in Boston for me pls, I live here and am always looking for more restaurants
 

Gaf Zombie

The Fallen
Dec 13, 2017
2,239
Underrated? Philadelphia. They have way more out there than cheese steaks.

Overrated? NY. Though that is to be expected given its large population.
 

Deleted member 5359

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
11,326
Vegas has some amazing food from around the world. It's under appreciated because people mostly think of stuff like casino buffets.
 

Rad

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,068
Finland. I present to you, Karelian pies. These fuckers are delicious. Slab a whole heap of butter on these and go to town.
0IMG_6140.jpg

I'm from Finland and our food generally sucks. But you aren't wrong about the Karelian pies. They are amazing. But to find the really good ones you actually need to go to North Karelia (east Finland) and eat them straight out of oven. Then they become top tier food.
 

nullref

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,052

I've been thinking about Seattle in the context of this thread (given that's where I live). My impression is it mostly seems properly rated—not really hyped as a top-tier food destination, but fairly well-regarded. Which I think is fair.

Portland and Vancouver seem to get a lot more heat in that regard—which honestly, I don't really get. (I get why they're well-regarded in general. I understand less why they'd be considered significantly better than Seattle. I'd be happy to have anyone enlighten me.) I'm sure I'm biased toward Seattle just by virtue of being much more familiar with it, but I've spent time in both Portland and Vancouver, and they just felt comparable rather than having some major advantage. Though, I do imagine Vancouver would have a significant advantage in Indian and Chinese food, specifically. But, more than enough great options in all three cities, unless you're focused on a specific cuisine.

I probably just need to spend more time exploring both cities. (I plan to.) It's tough to have a real opinion of a city's food scene without having actually lived there.
 
Last edited:

iareharSon

Member
Oct 30, 2017
8,940
Overrated: Pittsburgh

My fellow #412 citizens are highly ignorant when it comes to the quality of food. They think they're cheesesteaks match up with Philly and that they have the best pizza in the world. They also think cole slaw and fries go well with everything. There are some good spots here but absolutely overrated. Primanti Bros. is a Pittsburgh institution but wouldn't crack my 100 favorite restaurants in Los Angeles or New York.

Underrated: Philadelphia

Philadelphia's food scene has picked up a ton over the last five years alone. I'm stunned that they have some of the best Asian cuisine I ever had. The best cheesesteaks (not the touristy Pat's or Geno's) are still top tier and they have lots of great pizza joints.

In the middle for me: Los Angeles. They have the best Mexican food I've ever had in my life but their Asian cuisine overall has disappointed me. I still love the city though.

Ignore list.

I'm in the Bay Area now, but I miss that shit dearly.