I like the channel so far, they just need to figure out their formatting. I think a channel like Easy Allies do similar stuff with their weekly podcast and other shows, they don't put everything in 1 podcast. Perhaps they need to separate stuff like chatting about game previews in a different podcast, and news in another one. Doing it daily and with a new guest, every time is going to burn people out.
I wonder if they'll do analyses stuff like what they (at least Derrick) used to do at Gamexplain. Personally, I liked those for the most part. But sometimes they were just reading out stuff that was officially published, and it stopped being an analysis at that point.
I'm not familiar with Tim Rogers but i noticed in the comments that people who are really liked him, but people who aren't didn't. To me he sounded like someone who really likes to talk about himself, his big TV and powerful PC.
So far I like the guests, although the Nintendo power couple probably weren't the greatest fit at PS5 launch day. Jon of course was probably the best guest so far but yesterday's guest was great as well
People who don't know Tim might be turned off by that stuff, but he's not serious. It's part of his character, he's known for going off-topic a lot and talking about himself in ways that seems very random. But it's in a lighthearted way (sorry, I'm really bad at explaining this since English is not my language).
His recent review of Pac-man is a good example of him going way off-topic and talking about himself or his experiences, but it's in an awesome way.
He's also known for his ridiculously long Dragon Quest XI and Final Fantasy VII reviews, which I loved. I recommend watching at least one of these if you don't mind sitting hours watching a review that's nothing that you expect to see out of a review.
In short, you really just need to watch his content to 'get' him, I personally loved to see him on GVG, it's just that you need way more than an hour if you have him on your show because he's going to talk the entire hour if you don't stop him lol. And it shows since the other guys are too kind to interrupt him or tell him to stop talking haha.