• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Lothars

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
9,765
Bernie has a chance to rile up a base like Trump did.

Biden represents the status quo which does not bode well for voter turn out.

Trump will win again.
I don't think Bernie has a chance against trump and I feel even more that way after yesterday, I don't like Biden either but Biden seems like he much actually have what it takes to beat Trump.
 

Sunster

The Fallen
Oct 5, 2018
10,012
That all seems pretty understandable to me.

I think part of the mistake people are making (the ones who aren't just lashing out or being racist) is viewing the black vote as a monolith instead of something that is subject to the same kinds of internal demographic breakdown as anybody else. The youth vote has pretty similar preferences and turnout problems as everybody else, for instance.
I feel like this is kinda bound to happen to some extent when black people voting are "black voters" and latinos voting are "latino voters" but white people voting are "middle class whites" "college educated whites" "non-college educated whites" "rural whites" etc...
 
Nov 30, 2017
2,750

Poodlestrike

Smooth vs. Crunchy
Administrator
Oct 25, 2017
13,491
I feel like this is kinda bound to happen to some extent when black people voting are "black voters" and latinos voting are "latino voters" but white people voting are "middle class whites" "college educated whites" "non-college educated whites" "rural whites" etc...
I'd argue that the way that the white vote gets lavished with special descriptors and attention to each subgroup is a symptom, not a cause. The cause is just, well, racism. Supremacy's a pervasive thing.

The country wants to go back to status quo before trump. I think the increased turn out is testament to that.
I don't think Bernie has a chance against trump and I feel even more that way after yesterday, I don't like Biden either but Biden seems like he much actually have what it takes to beat Trump.
I disagree. Here is a breakdown of along the lines of my thought process.


He missed it. Twice.
Y'all, this is off-topic Primary OT discussion. Take it over there.
 

Lothars

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
9,765
I disagree. Here is a breakdown of along the lines of my thought process.


Nothing wrong with disagreeing. I'm just saying the same thing I've said over and over. Bernie doesn't have it heck I don't think he's ever had it now seeing the results of yesterday. I prefer Warren over all of them but it's looking like she's done.

Edit :sorry didn't realize it was off topic to this
 

Geode

Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,457
fivethirtyeight.com

Why So Many Black Voters Are Democrats, Even When They Aren’t Liberal

At first blush, black voters appear to be an almost monolithically Democratic bloc. In 2016, black Americans cast 24 percent of Democratic primary votes — the l…

I think this should be read too. I saw this a lot in my family growing up, they had slightly conservative viewpoints, but they weren't Republicans. Biden probably appeals more to some Black people because he is more conservative/moderate than Bernie.
 

Fat4all

Woke up, got a money tag, swears a lot
Member
Oct 25, 2017
92,685
here
all you have to do is watch Biden at the South Carolina town hall a bit back and you start to understand. He knows individual state bills, streets, businesses, people, etc. He's put a lot of work into interacting directly with communities, and remembering them and their issues, and addressing them directly.

the repertoire he's built up over time is impressive, that kind of support doesn't slip away super easily
 
Jan 3, 2018
3,404
If anyone is really wondering why voters would choose Biden (I haven't read the entire Primary thread), I imagine they're doing it in a dramatic, frustrated way. Being Obama's bro, being more "electable," and being a safe choice are the obvious top 3 reasons for voting for him.
 

Deleted member 18324

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
678
The country wants to go back to status quo before trump. I think the increased turn out is testament to that.

Returning to the conditions that spawned Trump in the first place seems like an awful idea

The idiots are the ones voting for Trump.

They beat their opposition and have achieved policy goals they sought - if they are dumb what does that make the Democratic base?

Many of Trump's base are unintelligent for sure but they have a better understanding of power than Democrats, in that they know they have minority views of abortion, minority rights or gun control but are savvy enough to use the political system ruthlessly to achieve their goals within it
 

JDSN

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
5,129
I'm glad someone said it, poli-era was revolting last month with prolific pósters defending that behavior just cos it was one of their own. Just went ahead and gave up on lurking it.

I don't need that "We ARE JuSt tAlKing StaTs" Ben Shapiro-tier bad faith argument, i'm not even black but fuck that shit.
 
Last edited:

someday

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,453
Returning to the conditions that spawned Trump in the first place seems like an awful idea



They beat their opposition and have achieved policy goals they sought - if they are dumb what does that make the Democratic base?

Many of Trump's base are unintelligent for sure but they have a better understanding of power than Democrats, in that they know they have minority views of abortion, minority rights or gun control but are savvy enough to use the political system ruthlessly to achieve their goals within it
My comments are trying to actually stay on topic. My original comment was basically saying to blame America if we end up with Trump again in November, fine, but don't blame black democrats for him. That's it. We didn't vote him in and we can't keep him out by ourselves.
 

TaySan

SayTan
Member
Dec 10, 2018
31,412
Tulsa, Oklahoma
Great post. I'm just as disappointed as everyone else as a Bernie supporter, but it is on Bernie to convince voters to vote for him and that is on him and only him.
 

AbsoluteZero0K

Alt Account
Banned
Dec 6, 2019
1,570
Best thread I've read on this website. Thanks Brawly Likes to Brawl

You neeeeeeeeeeed these black institutions like the black church and Bernie didn't make the moves necessary to win them over


Breaking down "the black vote" down to factions like the churched, unchurched, radical activist, conformists, young, old, marginalized within the marginalized, etc. is an advanced class.

Some folks have already demonstrated that they're having trouble digesting the precisely-written OP, even though it was broken down into bullet points.

FACTS

I encourage everyone to vote. However, I'm never perplexed when I see a young black women and man in dire situations NOT racing to the poll to vote for a middling status-quo political nominees.

The difference between Biden and Trump for some black people might as well be a (D) and (R).

I don't disagree. I'd even entertain arguments that Biden is what a republican used to look like during W.

How long those young black men and women think that The Notorious RGB gonna hold on to that SCOTUS seat? A non-vote now could mean perpetual peonage.

Just the strikedown alone in Affirmative Action has seen a substantial decrease in black enrollment at elite colleges.
 
Last edited:

Sanka

Banned
Feb 17, 2019
5,778
Why would people blame black people for biden's success? Were they the group that supported him the most and if so by how much? Well, even if that's the case it wouldn't be suprising because of the reasons you listed. There is a different sense of urgency to get that orange turd out of office.
 
OP
OP
Brawly Likes to Brawl
Oct 25, 2017
14,069
Ryohei Suzuki's bedroom
Wow, I wasn't expecting this thread to get so many responses! I mainly just wrote this out of frustration over a trend that was bothering me. I'm really glad to hear that some of you learned things that you didn't know before. I do hope that one day the democratic party at large demonstrates better appreciation for their most dedicated voting block.
 

Nerokis

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,563
this seems like a relevant tweet thread (the excerpts from Tasha Philpot's book are especially useful):



my takeaway from the OP, tweet threads like the above, etc. is that some of the goofier rhetoric we've been seeing around the fact of black voters driving Biden's comeback reflects a failure of empathy and imagination

"low information voter" talk, for example, just doesn't get to the core of it at all
 

Deleted member 48897

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 22, 2018
13,623
this seems like a relevant tweet thread (the excerpts from Tasha Philpot's book are especially useful):

This is also how you square the circle on LGBT community support from straight, cis black people. The white people who hate LGBT issues have a party that caters to them explicitly and exclusively, so they don't connect with the Dem party
 

FFNB

Associate Game Designer
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
6,092
Los Angeles, CA
I've come to understand that this is extremely common with white people in general and it's been a big topic of conversation this election cycle. I listened to Osita Nwanevu talk to Jane Coaston about this on a Vox podcast before Super Tuesday. I don't normally listen to the podcast but was recommended the episode just for perspective on this specifically.

White people are insulated by white supremacy and therefore do not have as much to lose by taking risks. White leftists in particular who may feel like they have nothing to lose due to their economic or medical situation are really aggressive about what they're willing to do. But even folks like this (of which I am one) are not at the same risk as black Americans should these plans fail. It's not fair to expect or demand black voters to take the same risks we are willing to take as white people when the consequences for them could be so much worse if it fails.

When white people's plans fail, it can be defeating or embarrassing but many have the luxury of going back to their normal lives. When black people's plans fail, their lives may never be the same.

So when black people are not willing to take the same risks to achieve the same goals, some white people just cannot understand this. Their inability to understand why a black person would not take the same risks as them causes them to say a lot of the things you outline here. It all boils down to believing black people don't know what's good for them.

Black people have experience with navigating racial inequality and surviving white supremacy so it seems pretty elementary to trust them when they say they're not willing to do things the same way white people want to - even if they have the same goals. I think white people on the Left struggle a lot with the fact that they are trying to help minorities and reduce racial disparity but without actually talking to or involving a lot of black people.

I can't fault black people for voting for Joe Biden, even though I didn't. Contrary to what a lot of white people think, black people are pretty good at knowing what's best for them to survive in this country.
So Super Tuesday is over and it's looking likely that Joe Biden will be the democratic nominee, in thanks largely to southern states, particularly black voters.

Before going into the topic of this thread, I'd like to make my perspective on what's been going on clear. I'm black and the son of Haitian immigrants. I identify as a socialist and decided to support Bernie this cycle (with Warren as a close second), and I would've voted for him yesterday had my state been a part of Super Tuesday.

To say that last night was disappointing for Sanders supporters is an understatement. Many are curious to know why Biden was able to gain such a massive amount of momentum. Now, I have no problem with people wondering why certain demographics choose to vote the way they do. Post-election analysis is a perfectly normal area of discussion and it's important to ask questions in order to gain a better perspective of things. However I believe that some people not just on here but other sites like Twitter have crossed a line and are not simply expressing curiosity.

Let me make one thing clear, black people who choose to vote for Biden as the nominee this year are not "low-information" voters, nor are they voting against their own interests, nor do they lack empathy. Black voters have access to the same media coverage and resources that every one else does. We know what Bernie's policies are, We know that Biden has a far from sterling reputation concerning black issues. I believe that people who are shocked by Bernie not being the clear front runner coming out of Super Tuesday have trouble reconciling Biden's strong black support and are quick to resort to dogwhistles as a reaction.

I'll try to explain the best that I can why Biden is performing so well among the black community, particularly with older black people.

1) HE'S THE VICE PRESIDENT TO BARACK OBAMA - It feels silly that I have to point this out, but Obama was the first black president of the united states. Older black voters like my mother thought that they would never live to actually see something like this happen. Before 2008, Black Presidents were something that you saw Hollywood movies flirt with but never thought would seriously happen. On top of that, Obama is extremely charismatic and his family is looked up to as role models in the black community. Being adjacent to someone like that is no small deal.

2) The black electorate is used to presidential candidates being either oblivious to, if not outright hostile to black issues - It is extremely rare that black voters have the luxury of choosing a candidate that is both viable and speaks to their unique issues. For many, Obama's run in '08 was the first time they truly saw themselves on presidential election stage. Being a black voter in America is a an exercise in harm reduction. We know that when Republicans gain power it's a guarantee that we're going to be hurt. Black voters, especially older ones that have witnessed multiple election deal with the lesser evil because the system rarely offers better viable choices

3) They don't trust Bernie's electability and ability to actuate his policies. - It's one thing to believe Bernie's policies will be better for you. It's another to believe he has a chance of winning. Black People don't not trust white people to choose socialism over trumpism. They see Bernie as a risk. They don't think the senate would allow his bills to pass. The top priority of older black voters is to get Trump out of the White House. These past four years have been traumatic as it is and another four would be such a disaster that naturally they want to go for a candidate that they consider safe. I personally think that Bernie's chances are better than the media give him credit for, but that doesn't mean that everyone else does.


4) Black Voters are tired. Just like everybody else. - We all want this shit to be over with. Everything about the Trump administration is exhausting. If Trump gets another four years, it's not going to be white who catch the brunt of the consequences. Black voters want things to be stable rather than worry about revolutions on top of making sure we don't get rolled again this year.


To finish this off, I like to speak about this terrible relationship that political media and commentators have with black people. Whenever we help bring a (usually white) candidate to victory, we get everything short of a ticker tape parade for a day or two but then get forgotten about. We're practically the backbone of the democratic party, yet that isn't reflected in policy decisions or coverage of what affects our communities. The minute that the black vote doesn't go exactly the way people expect we get shit on by armchair analysts asking what our damage is and continuing to ignore us. The whole country knows that we vote democratic because the alternative is worse, so why bother actually changing policy for us?

Meanwhile white people can vote in droves to install a blatantly corrupt and authoritarian president, but nobody would dare bad mouth the white electorate. They get article after article after article written about how they were these poor souls who got abandoned and we need to stop being mean to them!

You're allowed to be upset that Bernie isn't doing well. I'm not happy either. I want things in this country to meaningfully change for the better. But these shitty remarks about a group of people who are simply trying to keep their heads above water is completely out of pocket. Take a breath. Gain some perspective. Try something different next time.

The OP and this post are so spot on.

It's incredibly exhausting and frustrating to be talked down to and condescended to as a black voter. Aside from the fact that we aren't a monolith, we often don't have the luxury of taking risks with our well-being and quality of life. The goal is to get Trump and his ilk out of the White House by any means necessary.

I supported Warren and Sanders, but it really does seem like Biden has the best chance of beating Trump, so if he gets the nod, he gets my vote. Am I happy about it? No, but Trump has to go, and I can't risk fucking that up and inflicting another 4 years of him on the American people if I can help it.

In 2016, I got into many heated debates from "allies" that took their ball and went home because Sanders didn't get the nom, and they refused to vote for Hilary. I mean, I didn't want to vote for Hilary either, but...it was Donald Trump. It was a very eye-opening year, and I was disheartened that so many of my friends just didn't care about the affect a Trump presidency was going to have on people not living in a privileged bubble like them. Some side eyes were given, that's for sure. I had family and friends in Wisconsin that refused to vote, and when Trump got Wisconsin, and especially by such a slim margin, I was legitimately crushed.

That stubborn apathy caused so much damage to this country, so my only hope is that people learned their lesson, and we won't get a repeat of righteous indignation that kept people from voting because their precious "perfect candidate" didn't get the nomination. It must feel fine to have that luxury of standing by your principles and good conscience, but we don't have that luxury.
 

Big Baybee

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,775
I've been telling people for a while that black folks Just don't trust white folks to do the right thing.