On April 6, as Tharp prepared to read "It's Okay to Be a Unicorn!" to students the next day at an elementary school in the Buckeye Valley Local School District, north of Columbus, he got a call from the principal saying higher-ups didn't want him reading the book.
"I just straight up asked him, 'Does somebody think I made a gay book?' " Tharp said. "And he said, 'Yes. … The concern is that you're coming with an agenda to recruit kids to become gay.' "
Tharp, who lives in Powell, Ohio, about 10 miles south of the Buckeye Valley Local School District, was originally scheduled to visit Buckeye Valley West Elementary in 2020, but the event was postponed because of the pandemic. The school rescheduled the visit for April 7, and administrators ordered over 500 of his books for students in anticipation of the event, Tharp said. "It's Okay to Be a Unicorn!" follows Cornelius, a unicorn who hides his true identity because he lives among horses who don't like unicorns. At the end, he reveals his true self and is accepted by everyone.
But on the morning of April 6, the principal at Buckeye Valley West called him to say the plans had changed — the superintendent didn't want him to read the book.