- posts long faux-intellectual tirade about the dangers of radical politics that affect material conditions in a positive way
- "I look forward to being branded as a neolib!"
What a brave poster whose Very Important Long-form Opinions will prevent all kinds of suffering and injustice while avoiding any challenge to their utterly naive worldview. Thank you for your service in the Posting Corps.
If you believe it to be faux-intellectual please debate. Instead you chose a reductive non-response. I'm sorry that my form of general discourse and pointing out some basic facts strikes you as trying to feign intellectual superiority though.
And the branding as a neolib comes not from the post including neoliberal philosophy, but instead from people who claim the right to define progress not being able to understand the concept.
I'm not saying there is a danger to radical politics. I'm saying that no matter your policies change needs to be shoved down the throats of 50-60% of this country if that change is anything other than lowering taxes. The ACA was a straight slam dunk for 99% of Americans and led to a red wave in the very next mid-term. Now rural republicans are up in arms over losing those benefits while still decrying Obamacare.
No one, including Sanders, is going to organize the apathetic 2/5ths of this country who can't even be bothered to vote, let alone actually take some of the pain needed to effect meaningful change.
If you want that change it needs to be forced down from above. Much like how the impeachment issue with Trump was a tenuous polling item, yet once Pelosi had one of her fam attacked by Trump's impeachable offenses we've seen the public opinion shift rapidly.
Here, I'll lay out my post in reference to a long held axiom:
1. Existing truth: You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink.
2. Obvious assumption: If you never lead a horse to water, it definitely can't drink.
3. If you want to make sure the horse too stupid to drink when its dying of thirst drinks the goddamn water shove a hose down its throat and pour.
Now, take an objective assessment of the American people via all the sources that we have and tell me if you think they would:
A. Elect a more progressive path when politely presented to them (continually run back to GOP politicians after Dems clean up the economic messes of Lassiez-faire capitalism)
B. Find organization on their own (more right to work states than ever before, fewer unions, eroding union support)
C. Take for granted progressive entitlements only when forced upon them and only with the benefits of time benefiting from those entitlements (how even GOP boomers love their Social Security, Medicare, etc.)
If you still don't get what I was saying I'm sorry, I can't de-faux-intellectual it any more than this. Though I like how you assume I'm all for SUFFERING and INJUSTICE to protect my "naive worldview" when you contribute not a single real critique.
Shit like this (speaking with absolute superiority and conviction in a condescending fashion to the worldview of others you have zero frame of reference towards) should be a bannable offense if this board was interested in political discourse that went beyond shitposting competitions.
I rally wonder who these policy wonks are who have time to post multi-pages policy analysis that basically boils down to "sanders can't do shit" on a *checks notes*
video game message board
Someone who is good enough at the capitalist game to make my own schedule.
Someone who has done enough labor, supervised enough labor, and been involved in the real production side of our economy long enough to tell you the following facts:
1. The average union member in this country is a rural white racist who either voted for Trump or abstained because they wanted to vote for Trump. Most of the people who do production based industry work in this country (the places where organizing needs to happen) who don't have union cards voted for Trump.
So how do you organize the racists to stop racism? Maybe warning labels on tiki torches that say "FOR PROGRESSIVE RALLY USE ONLY"?
2. The average blue collar American worker fucking sucks. They're slow. They whine. They aren't very good. This is why illegal immigrants infiltrate high production industries like landscaping, construction, factory work, etc. so easily. The average blue collar American is a fucking trashbag. Immigrants work twice as hard, three times as productive, and for half the money.
Deep down the racist white blue collar worker knows this. They've seen it. Instead of doing better they're blaming the people who currently do better. What kind of progressive organization strategy does Sanders or anyone else have to fix the fact that most of our workforce wake up each day hoping to "steal" a paycheck?
3. Despite what "Real Progressive*" (*self-applied label) types tell you we still live with economic scarcity. We can't just give UBI to everyone to where no one
needs to work and have our society still function. As someone who has cleaned asbestos and far, far worse industrial wastes on top of a lot of other things Dirty Jobs considered too dangerous to make an episode on no one is showing up to do that shit if they don't have to as a way to survive.
But guess what: If no one does them then lots of fucking people die. I cleaned asbestos from dorm rooms at my college campus in the early 2000's. Kids lived in those dorm rooms a month before that. If no one was willing to remove it how many more people would have gotten lung cancer?
Now expand that to industrial contamination on a larger scale. Who wants to pull samples of chlorobenzene wearing a full tyvek and respirator because the shit would burn your skin or scar your lungs without it to make any random ass number over UBI when UBI covers all basic needs? No one.
How about something as mundane as trash pickup, where even today that is an industry woefully understaffed and overworked, to the point of being dangerous, and yet without it we'd have people back yard burning (hello express lane to global climate change) or we'd just live in fucking filth, with disease rampant and spontaneous trash fires in most major metros.
I hate to break it to the hope and change crowd but when you shitpost things like "society is broken" it goes well beyond alt-righters with AR-15s and a VP who thinks electrocution "cures" homosexuality. We aren't just culturally broken. Our entire way of life depends on exploitative systems. We're balancing on a single jenga block at the bottom and you all are acting like we can just build a new stack on top without addressing the constant wobble.
If you want progress we get there one of two ways: Elect someone who forces it via the overextended powers of the POTUS or at the point of a gun when corporate exploitation finally hits the tipping point to where the majority of Americans are in poverty and a violent revolution starts. Until then you aren't going to wake people up from their Twitter/Facebook feeds, Netflix binges, MCU rewatch parties, fantasy football draft, etc. long enough to change anything.
Warren's plans hinge on trying the first step before we wind up on an inevitable downward slide to the second.