A video showing three policemen beating and tear-gassing a Black man in his Paris office for several minutes has reignited a French debate about police brutality and the public's right to film officers on duty.
On Thursday morning, digital media outlet Loopsider published a report on the police operation that led to the beating of the man in the video, who has only been named as Michel, a music producer.
According to Loopsider, the incident began on Saturday when Michel, upon seeing a police car, entered his production studio in northwestern Paris. He was not wearing a mask and said he had hoped to avoid a fine.
Footage obtained by Loopsider from the studio's CCTV, neighbors, and artists who were in the studio's basement show police officers entering the studio without a warrant.
The footage then shows the officers striking Michel repeatedly with their fists, knees and batons.
As Michel was shouting for help, artists in the basement went up to the first floor office and managed to drive away the three policemen.
Neighbors who had been in front of the studio filmed the second part of the police intervention.
The three policemen, who by then had been reinforced by a dozen colleagues, threw a tear-gas grenade into the studio, forcing Michel out on the street as one police officer pointed his gun at him. Other policemen re-entered the studio and arrested artists who were in the basement.
Policemen initially claimed that Michel had provoked them and tried to steal their weapons.
However, Loopsider reported that the Paris prosecutor office said it closed its case without further action, and that it asked the general inspector of the national police (IGPN) to open an investigation against the policemen for "violence and forgery."
The video comes in the middle of a debate on a security bill that would ban sharing videos identifying policemen with the "manifest intention of harming their physical or psychic integrity." The National Assembly voted in favor of the bill and it will be discussed at the Senate in December.
Opponents of the bill, including NGOs Amnesty International and Reporters Without Borders (RSF), said the notion of malicious intent was both vague and hard to prove. It could also be open to misinterpretation from police and, ultimately, lead to abuses that could endanger freedom of speech from citizens and reporters.
Violent beating of Black man by police causes outrage in France
The video comes in the middle of a debate on a security bill that would curtail sharing videos of policemen.
www.politico.eu
Last edited: