this ain't the answerCorbyn needs to go now, and the leadership with him. Need a top to bottom rethink now. A big, big clear out.
The party now has to get rid of the whole commie tag and, unfortunately, water down a hell of a lot of the lefty feel and policies.
Depressingly, they now have to offer incremental, tiny progress to a nation who overwhelmingly rejected a socialist view of what things could be.
What were their reasons, if you're allowed to share / don't mind sharing ?
The people who say "this would have happened to any leader" about the worst defeat in 85 years are almost the same people who were going all "don't believe the polls" before the election. Practically they just don't want to face the truth and that will continue to hurt Labour in the long run. Becoming a cult who lives outside the facts does not help one bit.
Western democracy has taken a hard turn into right wing conservatism and no amount of malicious cruelty and overt disdain for the average citizen seems enough to vote perpetrators out. It has happened in the USA, UK, and Australia, and every election that rolls around has the veil of enough-is-enough that seems to never be seen through. The entire political ecosystem is broken and the seeds of right wing conservatism planted deep, neatly pruned and catered to by a digital media age that doubles down on the right wing status quo.
Logic would deduce that there's no way the Republicans could possibly score another term. Reason would imply that Australia's 2022 election will throw the Liberal party and their devaluing of human rights out the window. In practice there is no reality where either of these things are remotely safe or guaranteed. The same shit that got them to where they are, that has lead to where the UK is now, will happen all over again and the results will probably be the same.
The media *destroyed* Brown because of the financial crash.
He still didn't do this badly.
Remember when the idea was that because of media ruled making fairness mandated during s campaign made the polls tighten in 2017 so that's what would happen here too because people would like Corbyns messages? Well they fell flat.
This is on him.
I have been feeling bad for the people in the UK, but it's wasted concern. It's a self-inflicted wound they got three years ago and then just keep digging in so hard, it's ridiculous. Honestly, at this point, the Brits probably deserve everything bad that will be happening to the majority of them, and it's hilarious how rich their new PM is gonna get with all the shady deals he will be setting up with the vultures heading in to feast (US, Russia, and China). Godspeed, Scotland, get out whenever you can.CNN says could be the largest Conservative majority since Thatcher...
Same I'm done caring at this point, hope this country crashes and burns so the people that voted for this shit realise how fucking stupid and bigoted they are.
I dunno. Starmer just has the right look as facile as that seems. He's in the right place politically for the party - Corbyn friendlyish but supported by the PLP. And for the voters, he's credible in a way that Corbyn never was with large swathes of the electorate. Yes he's a bleeding heart human rights lawyer. But he's a lawyer in a suit. Not some white Uncle Ho making jam in his garden. Also he's a good person.
Him or Phillips for me.
The Corbyn trio of RLB. Rayner and Pidcock are going to go down with him...probably. Though if they are fleet-footed enough they may escape the fallout
i never said that. i knew the polls were very grim for Labour from the moment they adopted the second referendum position and I had no expectation they would win. in fact, i definitely expected a Tory majority or largest party at the absolute limits, although I didn't anticipate the scale. but this result is not primarily because of Corbyn. he was a factor, but not the determining factor. no Labour leader with a pro-Remain, pro-second referendum election would have won this electionThe people who say "this would have happened to any leader" about the worst defeat in 85 years are almost the same people who were going all "don't believe the polls" before the election. Practically they just don't want to face the truth and that will continue to hurt Labour in the long run. Becoming a cult who lives outside the facts does not help one bit.
I think it is whether we like it or not. Just like the lib dems and austerity this election will hang around all of them in another election like a bad smell. It's incapable and they know it.
I'm not going to give their names or the company I work for, so it's good. This is just the messages I got from general conversations.
A few felt they had no choice. They thought Tories were the safe option and didn't trust Corbyn. A lot of them felt Labour were racist and the party was rife with antisemitism, yet ignore the racist problems in the Tory party (crazy side note, there is a young Muslim man in my team who was born in the UK to parents from Iran.......he confirmed he was voting Tory because Labour are racist?! Couldn't believe my ears)
Others were pure young Tories who have always voted for the party. Not all of them are middle-class, white kids either. Most of these kids are from working class backgrounds and not all are white. These people seem to support Tory because their parents do (one did admit she voted for Brexit and the Tories in 2017 because her dad "told her to".
There was one guy who was going to vote Green, but then changed his mind and voted Tory as he wanted to vote for a party that "could win".
Some of us in Britain did our very best to fight this, actually.I have been feeling bad for the people in the UK, but it's wasted concern. It's a self-inflicted wound they got three years ago and then just keep digging in so hard, it's ridiculous. Honestly, at this point, the Brits deserve everything bad that will be happening to them and it's hilarious how rich their new PM is gonna get with all the shady deals he will be setting up with the vultures heading in to feast (US, Russia, and China). Godspeed, Scotland, get out when you can.
No chance. There'll always be someone else to blame.Sorry for everyone affected. Hopefully once Brexit goes through and, you know, hurts everyone involved then people will get that the Tories suck.
Would it not in that case be simpler for the Labour leadership to dissolve the people and elect another?The only mistake Corbyn made, was believing in the morality, and integrity of the British Public.
wtf
We have to face, even is a hard reality to face, that the current neoliberal model is deeply rooted in our society and that a good chunk of the population may vote just to keep the status quo as damaging is in the long turn or for the whole society. People vote for their own selfish interest, even as a whole those end damging a great part of the people they live with(I don't care people die because they can't pay health services, as long as I'm fine is ok, etc...)
People really want to act like Corbyn's unpopularity was somehow something Labour could have controlled. Boris has been known as an embarrassment since he was London's mayor but no matter how many times he directly insults minorities, mocks the working class or hides from tough questions in a fucking fridge, the BBC will run endless stories on Labour antisemitism while inviting tories on for friendly chats.
The lesson here is that everything is fucked and better things aren't possible ever.
The people who say "this would have happened to any leader" about the worst defeat in 85 years are almost the same people who were going all "don't believe the polls" before the election. Practically they just don't want to face the truth and that will continue to hurt Labour in the long run. Becoming a cult who lives outside the facts does not help one bit.
On this forum I mean, not in general.
The people who say "this would have happened to any leader" about the worst defeat in 85 years are almost the same people who were going all "don't believe the polls" before the election. Practically they just don't want to face the truth and that will continue to hurt Labour in the long run. Becoming a cult who lives outside the facts does not help one bit.
You're not remembering well.Yes I remember the election well. The media was not nearly as venomous about Brown as it is Corbyn by a fucking country mile
stop it
I have been feeling bad for the people in the UK, but it's wasted concern. It's a self-inflicted wound they got three years ago and then just keep digging in so hard, it's ridiculous. Honestly, at this point, the Brits probably deserve everything bad that will be happening to the majority of them, and it's hilarious how rich their new PM is gonna get with all the shady deals he will be setting up with the vultures heading in to feast (US, Russia, and China). Godspeed, Scotland, get out whenever you can.
Well, they lost anyway so I don't know if that's really an argument.If he would've done that he would've lost the entire remain voting majority of his seats.
He would've been ousted by the membership.
Labour as a party overwhelmingly back remain and thinking he would've gained Brexit votes by trying to be a Brexit party Vs someone doing it with more conviction is lunacy.
the australian labor party has dealt in this kind of centrism for *decades* to awful, awful results. corbyn inspired a movement that was brought down by people attacking from all angles. it wasn't his policies that made him unpopular it was the lack of solidarity. it's not the time to turn backI think it is whether we like it or not. Just like the lib dems and austerity this election will hang around all of them in another election like a bad smell. It's incapable and they know it.
You're not remembering well.
Hell remember "Bigoted Woman".
He took so much stick over someone who was...frankly bigoted it wasn't even funny.
He was bodied in the media. By the end he was barely featured in local campaigning he was seen as that much of a liability.
Still didn't do this badly.
Corbyn needs to go now, and the leadership with him. Need a top to bottom rethink now. A big, big clear out.
The party now has to get rid of the whole commie tag and, unfortunately, water down a hell of a lot of the lefty feel and policies.
Depressingly, they now have to offer incremental, tiny progress to a nation who overwhelmingly rejected a socialist view of what things could be.