• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Ac30

Member
Oct 30, 2017
14,527
London
Why don't the Kurds or the US eliminate these ISIS fighters which are already identified as having committed massacres?

...you realise you're asking for summary executions, right?

the right thing to do would've been to take back our citizens and have them face trial here, but that's, politically-speaking, impossible.
 
Oct 25, 2017
15,110
Why don't the Kurds or the US eliminate these ISIS fighters which are already identified as having committed massacres?
Rule of law and the Geneva convention. Also a question of who is even responsible for them. They are citizen of all sorts of countries, including many Europeans among them etc.
But would anyone be surprised if mass murders happened when they can sense they will lose control and they might escape?
 

stew

Member
Dec 2, 2017
4,188
It's war, I'm assuming there are means to cover up. They're are in a situation where they'll have to deal with them again. It's weird to imagine that the most dangerous ones will be able to flee while everyone is watching doing nothing.
 

EVIL

Senior Concept Artist
Verified
Oct 27, 2017
2,783
You think this whole thing might end up in a substantial land grab from turkey?
 

Xando

Member
Oct 28, 2017
27,321
Turkey is apparently shafting the americans and is pushing further south and west than the americans got told.
 

Commedieu

Banned
Nov 11, 2017
15,025
No no, we just do not understand the 24934589349D chess that Trump is playing in all his amazing, unmatched wisdom.

The report of them bracketing the base was alluding to it being the proxies firing on us targets. As when the us called turkey, the shelling and firing stopped.

im sure these proxies for hire have no liking of the us troops. It's being done on purpose to drive us out and it's working.

worlds most advanced military means nothing when an idiot is the commander.

This is an embarrassing disaster and I hope no troops are killed over it. If so Trump needs to be tried for treason. By courts or by the people.
 

Jibreel

Member
Oct 25, 2017
343
You think this whole thing might end up in a substantial land grab from turkey?

This is the supposed goal of their operation:

v16k4fozoir31.png
 

DonaldKimball

Member
Oct 28, 2017
1,413
TSFA is pretty much uncontrollable and Turkey knows this. So far they haven't commited their own forces to the fighting except for air strikes. They are sending the TSFA to bombed positions to take out SDF forces with their main forces only as backup.

The general turkish population would not take kindly to TAF getting slaughtered and would start asking questions.

On the other hand TSFA is comprised of crazy fucks with zero restraint. Not a good look for turkey. Its only a matter of time until the turkish people will start to question the purpose of this mission.

If erdogan turns this into an ongoing situation, he is doomed.
 

Xando

Member
Oct 28, 2017
27,321
Turkey bombed another civilian convoy.


Apparently journalists from france, brazil and kurds were among the convoy.
 
Last edited:

sleepnaught

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
4,538
Just read 950 ISIS fighters have escaped from a Kurdish prison because of Turkish attacks. Bravo, Trump.
 

sleepnaught

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
4,538
You realize the few Americans over there will get annihilated if they get drawn into a fight? This shit is heinous all around, and your internet nerd bloodlust is frankly disgusting.
Never would have happened to begin with had the US not withdrawn from the beginning. Turkey would have never attacked US forces in the region.
 

Xando

Member
Oct 28, 2017
27,321
The full video shows a dozen dead soldiers with machine guns. Not excusing it but I feel like thats an important fact they deliberately cut.
The tweet literally says they were escorted by SDF fighters which is custom in conflict regions (good luck traveling alone as a western journalist).

Looks like atleast 2 french journalists were injured.
 

poklane

Member
Oct 25, 2017
27,932
the Netherlands
As an European what sickens me the most is that the end of the day our politicians won't do jack shit like they always do. Time and time again our adversaries threaten us, invade countries around them and they do nothing. Russia invades Moldova? Nothing is done. Russia invades and partitions Georgia? Nothing is done. Russia invades Ukraine, shoots down MH17 and annexes a part of Ukraine? Nothing is done. Turkey invades and partitions Cyprus? Nothing is done. Turkey invades Cyprus' economic zone? Nothing is done. Turkey repeatedly invades Syria with the help of jihadists? Nothing is done.

Russia and Turkey are trying to destroy us and unless we do something to stop it they'll succeed.
 

DiipuSurotu

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
53,148
As an European what sickens me the most is that the end of the day our politicians won't do jack shit like they always do. Time and time again our adversaries threaten us, invade countries around them and they do nothing. Russia invades Moldova? Nothing is done. Russia invades and partitions Georgia? Nothing is done. Russia invades Ukraine, shoots down MH17 and annexes a part of Ukraine? Nothing is done. Turkey invades and partitions Cyprus? Nothing is done. Turkey invades Cyprus' economic zone? Nothing is done. Turkey repeatedly invades Syria with the help of jihadists? Nothing is done.

Russia and Turkey are trying to destroy us and unless we do something to stop it they'll succeed.
France and Germany at least have banned arms exports to Turkey in response to these attacks on the Kurds. They plan to take it to the EU on this Monday.
 

Xando

Member
Oct 28, 2017
27,321
As an European what sickens me the most is that the end of the day our politicians won't do jack shit like they always do. Time and time again our adversaries threaten us, invade countries around them and they do nothing. Russia invades Moldova? Nothing is done. Russia invades and partitions Georgia? Nothing is done. Russia invades Ukraine, shoots down MH17 and annexes a part of Ukraine? Nothing is done. Turkey invades and partitions Cyprus? Nothing is done. Turkey invades Cyprus' economic zone? Nothing is done. Turkey repeatedly invades Syria with the help of jihadists? Nothing is done.

Russia and Turkey are trying to destroy us and unless we do something to stop it they'll succeed.
The problem is as long we (europeans) don't have a unified military. If we (germans) had an actual military instead of that clownshow i'd argue to impose a no fly zone.
 

K Samedi

Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,990
The Turkish exonomy is suprisingly versatile. Sanctions won't collapse the economy, it will only slow things down and with 4 million syrians wanting to go to Europe I don't think sanctions will be a option for Europe. They will probably strike a deal about the scope of the operation. Turkey also has legitimate reasons to do this operation. Northen Syria has been a haven for PKK terrorist for years now.
 

behOemoth

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,624
TSFA is pretty much uncontrollable and Turkey knows this. So far they haven't commited their own forces to the fighting except for air strikes. They are sending the TSFA to bombed positions to take out SDF forces with their main forces only as backup.

The general turkish population would not take kindly to TAF getting slaughtered and would start asking questions.

On the other hand TSFA is comprised of crazy fucks with zero restraint. Not a good look for turkey. Its only a matter of time until the turkish people will start to question the purpose of this mission.

If erdogan turns this into an ongoing situation, he is doomed.
Is it really an Erdogan thing though? The whole turkish parliament minus the HDP greenlighted this without any questions.
 

Personae

Member
Oct 29, 2017
150
I don't think they are, they're just appear to be supportive of Erdogan as he's jailing those who's not. They are not actually. There are zero reasons for anti-Erdogan people to support him. Dude is a freaking traitor just like Trump. This war really looks like to them Turkish soldiers dying in a foreign land just to make the lives of the refugees better. And this pisses people of as the refugees are already in much comfort living in Turkey. "Why aren't they fighting own wars? Why do Turkish youth need to die for these lazy fucks?" It's the main mentality for many people in Turkey. Everybody knows this "Safe Zone" thing is complete bullshit.

Don't forget that people also terrified of economic consequences of this stupid war. Turkish lira will lose in value greatly after the sanctions and mins will be out of job. Everything will get even more expensive as if they're not expensive enough right now. Labor unions and syndicates are already warning Turkish people of what's to come after this. Not good.

And for last 7 years, 90% of the terrorist attacks happened in Turkey were done by ISIS. PKK is a rebel group, they don't attack civilians. Even if they "do", they're usually falsely accused by the government. Especially by Erdogan himself. That's why Turkey didn't have any PKK activity during Ecevit adminstration. AKP government has been the most active one against PKK. Right wing is right wing.
Hmm I see, PKK is a rebel group, they don't attack civilians!! And now I understand your posts here, why they have little to no truth in them. But I'm a propaganda machine so...
Attacking civilians and arrested soldiers have nothing justifiable. They should be punished if true. When arriving conclusions based on anything now I try to be careful. What I see is there is a lot of fake or false photos, videos, news from both Turkey and YPG. Some Twitter accs posted here have amazing history of being objective, it's good no one calling them propaganda or biased /s. Some tweets have conflicting information. I don't expect them to publish actual Turkish soldiers', not FSA, videos properly capturing and arresting people which is the norm and acceptable. Also look at Raqqa, that city almost vanished. And look at the places Turks attacked. Do you see same destruction? There is a video foreign fighters talk about Turkish attack and they sit on living room and say they bomb weaponry and food supplies.
I don't know if you ever notice, some are one-sided as much as Turks. Ooh they hurt American soldiers... No no they attacked them, no no they attacked near them... Just one km away? They kill civilians and free ISIS members. Wow all stupid moves possible and at nearly same moment. I wonder why?
Lastly I want to thank you, guys. I wrote some emotional or biased things. I realize I should be thankful to this forum after seeing other places such as twitter. Maybe I'm wrong about some of what I say. But I really try to be honest. I don't want anyone to die. I feel sick. But I know any solution would require existing part's perspective so I try to contribute. All I can think of most of the time, this would have been avoided.
 
Last edited:
Oct 25, 2017
15,110
Is it really an Erdogan thing though? The whole turkish parliament minus the HDP greenlighted this without any questions.
The Turkish population seems to be fully behind this operation.

The hell did Erdogan do to get his dream scenario?
Probably told him he would buy some stuff from the US and he would do the whole thing for free!
Trump just needs to be convinced he made a good deal, which more and more dictators are able to achieve. All because he doesn't listen to his own agencies.

I feel like Trump is someone who would quit his day job if he won $500 in the lottery.
 

K Samedi

Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,990
That's not even close to true. The turk financial industry is already close to collapse and kicking them out of the EU customs union will absolutely destroy the turkish economy.
It won't. Don't make stuff up. The Turkish economy is not in a good state for a good 2 to 3 years now but that's mostly because of questionable policies. Turkey has a huge work force and the economy has its own strengths. All sanctions will do is extend the recession a bit. Turkey has loads of options outside of the EU and the EU is not really eager to lose an economic partner like Turkey. It goes both ways.
 

DonaldKimball

Member
Oct 28, 2017
1,413
Is it really an Erdogan thing though? The whole turkish parliament minus the HDP greenlighted this without any questions.

No one in Turkey would publicly oppose the operation right now because they would be labelled terrorist sympathisers and lose any support.

This operation is a desperate attempt to get his voters back (and the ultra nationalists). People in turkey are sick of the millions of refugees, they don't have the infrastructure to take care of them and the help the EU/USA offered wasn't nearly enough to help in that regard.

He wants to dump them to stop the critics.

There are other reasons too, see 9-Volt's post.
 

pulsemyne

Member
Oct 30, 2017
2,641
The full video shows a dozen dead soldiers with machine guns. Not excusing it but I feel like thats an important fact they deliberately cut.
Journos go on convoys with soldiers a lot of the time in war zones because they are protection. Journos do not go out into warzones on their own most of the time. If they want to get to the front line for reports then they are escorted.
 

Deleted member 8583

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
8,708


Sorry, translation:

Syria. We were in the convoy of Kurdish civilians targeted by Turkish forces or their allies in Ras Al Ain. Our team is fine but some colleagues are dead. Our story from the

@ 20hFrance2

tonight with

@AuerNicolas

and Yan Kadouch

@franceinfo

@ france2tv

#Rojava #Turkey