It's fine, it's really on me because I went in a little hard. I got a bit frustrated hearing certain posts over and over in the OT and saw a fresh thread to blow off a little steam. I get why some people saw it the way they did.
I also do think they should consider improvements... I'm just not sure how much they should listen to people asking for things that go against the system they built.
(Now this may not be the best example, but trying to illustrate my point). If some people ask From to add a "press x to jump" to a Souls game (not Sekiro!), even though it would change what they were aiming for, do you think From should consider it?
I don't think so, because I think those people misunderstand what the design of that game is attempting to achieve.
Don't be deaf to critiques, they're incredibly valuable, but if a person's critique shows more that they want a different system rather than a suggestion that would bolster what the system is trying to do?
It's a tough balancing act I can imagine. Hell maybe I'm wrong and they'll add something I'm calling bad and convince me... maybe they'll change it entirely and I'll hate it, or just fuck it all up beyond recognition.
After the twists and turns we've had on our way to this game... anything is possible.
Yeah, it often gets hard to discuss true points here, since so many people cant differentiate between "hating something" and "seing flaws in it". Its either the best thing, or crap.
There is stuff i find highly flawed and loved (i could talk hours about stuff that could be improved in botw, or that was not optimal to begin with...and it is still one of my favorite games). And other stuff that ifind really hard to find flaws, but still dont love.
With this game (and, i only played a bit at myflatmates ps4, i'll wait for the anouncement of the last part before i invest myself fully), but the game is far from perfect. At the same time, it is less of a clusterfuck than i somehow expected by the team. From what i've seen its a game that has space to improve in all areas, while none is really bad. (except arguably story aditions (i spoiled myself), and here i would argue as long as you see it through a anime/camp lense it can be a fun romp.)
But im also one that can enjoy 6/10 games if in the right mood and the right game.