It's not about whether or not you ever used being against Puns' lynching as a defense, it's about whether or not you set it up
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
They Might Be Giants Mafia |OT| Everybody Dies Frustrated And Sad, And That Is Beautiful
- Thread starter Apopheniac
- Start date
It's not about whether or not you ever used being against Puns' lynching as a defense, it's about whether or not you set it up
But I didn't set it up! I just wasn't convinced Puns was scum so I didn't vote for him. I was also asleep when you guys turboed him so I wouldn't of been able to vote either way
my friend
that is exactly what scum would say
*rides into the sunset*
Tbh I dunno why the Puns lynch happened at all except for his personal style but I missed the heat of that moment. Feel the same about the Trigger lynch. But that's benefit of having been outside the game and not in it.
I will consider a bit and make my order I guess. Struggling a little here.
I will consider a bit and make my order I guess. Struggling a little here.
==== DAY 8 VOTES ====
Day Start
godfather (1 votes)
thechuggernaut - #3109
thechuggernaut (1 votes)
kitsunelaine - #3120
theworthyedge (1 votes)
godfather - #2994
Post Counts:
dr. monkey: 65 thechuggernaut: 53 theworthyedge: 43 godfather: 41 kitsunelaine: 41 verelios: 40 absolutbro: 18 grizzly: 1
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start
godfather (1 votes)
thechuggernaut - #3109
thechuggernaut (1 votes)
kitsunelaine - #3120
theworthyedge (1 votes)
godfather - #2994
Post Counts:
dr. monkey: 65 thechuggernaut: 53 theworthyedge: 43 godfather: 41 kitsunelaine: 41 verelios: 40 absolutbro: 18 grizzly: 1
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Yeah, I mean, he was being TP. I can see how it can happen and maybe how it it didi, so no judgment. I might have gone right along with it in the moment. But from my outsider POV, he and Trigger rang very town to me.
Triggrr had that late vote that looked really bad the day before, and then didn't do much to defend himself after.
Puns lynch was weird because Puns self turboed.
Puns lynch was weird because Puns self turboed.
Puns threatened town with martydom...not sure how you see it but that doesn't scream town to me.
No, I get that the Trigger vote looked scummy but it also just looked clumsy. It doesn't matter, really. AbBro, what do you think about today?
Dr. Monkey You asked for my thoughts about Chuggs, you've had time to read 'em now, what's your response?
OP
OP
==== DAY 8 VOTES ====
Day Start
godfather (1 votes)
thechuggernaut - #3109
thechuggernaut (1 votes)
kitsunelaine - #3120
theworthyedge (1 votes)
godfather - #2994
Post Counts:
dr. monkey: 67 thechuggernaut: 53 theworthyedge: 43 verelios: 41 godfather: 41 kitsunelaine: 41 absolutbro: 19 grizzly: 2
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start
godfather (1 votes)
thechuggernaut - #3109
thechuggernaut (1 votes)
kitsunelaine - #3120
theworthyedge (1 votes)
godfather - #2994
Post Counts:
dr. monkey: 67 thechuggernaut: 53 theworthyedge: 43 verelios: 41 godfather: 41 kitsunelaine: 41 absolutbro: 19 grizzly: 2
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
You're right. It did and it doesn't. I'm working on a larger post which I hopefully will have up shortly.
7 alive, so 4 is majority.
It's thin, but it's something. There are some things that don't quite match what I've seen (like he's not pushing you?) and some fair points. My question back to you is: if it meant the game, would you bet the game on that case?
4
before I do anything else
TheChuggernaut Do you mind telling me why you saved me when it was down to Geno and myself? I admit, I wasn't likely to vote for Geno for the reason I laid out that day phase. But then you and Battousai both voted for Geno. You said "I want to see where this goes" in your vote post, but I was basically posting a last testament type thing.
TheChuggernaut Do you mind telling me why you saved me when it was down to Geno and myself? I admit, I wasn't likely to vote for Geno for the reason I laid out that day phase. But then you and Battousai both voted for Geno. You said "I want to see where this goes" in your vote post, but I was basically posting a last testament type thing.
Sure. I was expecting to get asked about this more at the time, but then Geno filpped scum and no one questioned it. When that happened I was still thinking you and him were both scum, so I was worried there was going to be nonsense with tieing up the vote at the last second, so I took my vote off you, and put it on Geno to swing it further in the direction of making it harder to tie. Batts already mentioned he was leaning Geno so I thought it was the safest bet.
I don't know. I really don't. Coming in late is hard. Honestly. I think I would rank TWE as best bet. I think his behavior today has been strange. I expect that's where I'll vote. I consider Verelios basically confirmed (if I'm wrong, RIP) so I'd like to hear from him again.
Oh okay, I see what you mean. TWE is odd because his vote record is good and he's been consistent, but the no NK does muddy the water here and if you believe him then that explains it...but if you don't then that opens him up to scum not inputting the nk. I personally think I believe him, or want to believe him because it makes some sense for what happened. That, and TWE wasn't in much danger today so it would be a weird thing to lie about.
So quick question that's not super on topic. If we hit the last day and there's only 3 left how does that usually play out? I feel like you have to be super careful because as you screw up and throw down a vote on the other town person then scum is going to insta turbo
My biggest issue is that the people putting up my hackles are the ones that it can't be with what we "know".
Like, I don't trust some of Godfather's posts (or CoolestSpot's for that matter), but if we "know" Vere is a town tracker then we have to believe there's either a scum (most likely) or neutral (exceedingly unlikely) role blocker, so it literally is down to (from my POV) TheWorthyEdge, TheChuggernaut or Kitsunelaine.
The fact that our town cop hasn't come forward to even say "sorry folks, I've got jack and shit" is making me question whether town even HAS a cop. I suppose it is entirely possible that the Godfather/Ninja was in play specifically to avoid scum knowing which town PRs were in play from their own PRs. A double fake, essentially.
But then I wonder how Verelios is even still alive. I mean, he's literally the one exposed town PR with the ability to bring them down. By tracking them to a kill. And as the number of players gets smaller and smaller, the chances of him doing that go up, so why is he still alive? It makes no sense this late in the game.
I dunno, I've reread quite a bit and nothing makes sense in this game.
Like, I don't trust some of Godfather's posts (or CoolestSpot's for that matter), but if we "know" Vere is a town tracker then we have to believe there's either a scum (most likely) or neutral (exceedingly unlikely) role blocker, so it literally is down to (from my POV) TheWorthyEdge, TheChuggernaut or Kitsunelaine.
The fact that our town cop hasn't come forward to even say "sorry folks, I've got jack and shit" is making me question whether town even HAS a cop. I suppose it is entirely possible that the Godfather/Ninja was in play specifically to avoid scum knowing which town PRs were in play from their own PRs. A double fake, essentially.
But then I wonder how Verelios is even still alive. I mean, he's literally the one exposed town PR with the ability to bring them down. By tracking them to a kill. And as the number of players gets smaller and smaller, the chances of him doing that go up, so why is he still alive? It makes no sense this late in the game.
I dunno, I've reread quite a bit and nothing makes sense in this game.
it is the most stressful thing in the land and you usually coordinate votes
That has happened, yes. Usually you try and convince one other person to vote with you, and there's two other people trying to convince you too. It's crazy.
I have thankfully never survived to end game like that. Closest I got was Star Wars and we flubbed that pretty badly. Still won, and to be fair one of our scum team was actually scum aligned neutral, and I had no scum chat...
know what, it wasn't close at all.
know what, it wasn't close at all.
I also wonder how I'm alive, but then think scum thought they could get me lynched ala GenoDream.
I think Vere has said he is out of shots so mafia doesn't really have to kill him at this point. I'm assuming they're more worried about trying to find the fabled cop.
Like if there were no tracker thing, I would vote you, AB. Your record is awful.
If there's weird scum fuckery and lies going on, it's you and Vere. But I don't think it is. Vere believing TWE is a wrinkle for me. Scum, if we don't find you, please nk me tonight, and with my thanks.
If there's weird scum fuckery and lies going on, it's you and Vere. But I don't think it is. Vere believing TWE is a wrinkle for me. Scum, if we don't find you, please nk me tonight, and with my thanks.
Kyan the Town Vigilante said he was out of shots. He still died that night. Scum can't take the risk that the person is lying.
I could honestly not blame you. My glorious return to Mafia has been anything but. Killing Zipped and leaving Fran alive... I'm telling you scum chat is going to hurt to read after game end.
I do not understand how they possibly thought that would work. There's no way anyone was going to go along with Geno when he came in blitzing like that.
Yeah. Maybe they're just hoping we kill him ourselves? Which seems weird because we haven't done that yet and Geno and Fran tried to set that shit up. I dunno, how the hell are you alive, Vere?
If it's Chuggernaut, well done, dude.
If it's kits, well done PogChamp in particular, and nice job replacing, kits.
If it's TWE, you'll probably get away with it at this rate.
I don't want to be the decider. Let me go back and look at my analysis.
If it's kits, well done PogChamp in particular, and nice job replacing, kits.
If it's TWE, you'll probably get away with it at this rate.
I don't want to be the decider. Let me go back and look at my analysis.
I think this is the first I've gotten to play with you, though! I hope we play again.
Watch mafia NK one of us three just to fuck everything up further
I think I have to go with the worst voting record of the unknowns, which would be Chuggernaut. Nothing personal, my dude. I hope you keep playing with us.
I'll be honest, if it comes down to a mylo situation I'm going to kill TWE if I'm still alive.
is it wrong I kind of want to kill vere now? like the geno thing was so obviously not going to work that I have to wonder what the fuck was going on
I mean, I'm not voting for vere, but there's part of me that wants that flip now
I mean, I'm not voting for vere, but there's part of me that wants that flip now