• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

RowdyReverb

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,934
Austin, TX
Imagine saying I "bleed PlayStation" as if I haven't been reporting critically on the company for years and didn't just publicly call out Sony's two biggest directors.

Imagine sharing doctored video clips of me to advance your deranged console warrior agenda (actual video: https://twitter.com/AtrioxIsComing/status/1275826108823244800)

Imagine not even realizing that I play all of my games on PC and Switch and wouldn't even get a next-gen console if I didn't have to for work lmao
I am so embarrassed for this thread right now
 

Bunkles

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
5,663
I don't think Lockhart is going to "hold Series X back" like a lot of people here but I do believe MS has a massive marketing challenge to make these two systems make sense with a cohesive message.
 

jschreier

Press Sneak Fuck
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
1,098
And as for Jason, I made a simple comment a few pages back. And I'll stand by that comment as my own personal view on the matter, but accept others have their own. I wish I kept my mouth shut now but hey ho. What I will say Jason is that you blocked me on twitter for saying something positive about the Xbox when some guys were slagging it off on one of your posts. No previous engagement from me, no chat, nothing. I simply corrected a Sony guy on some quite odd technical facts, and boom, you blocked me. Kinda makes a person think.
Actually, I just looked you up. I blocked you on Twitter for saying "Does Neil not realise Schreier bleeds blue, to the point he burns if he has to say anything positive about another company...? This must be hurting Schreier very hard..." https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272247847434489865

Then you wrote this gem: https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272252907019218945

Real class act over here. Amazing that you're lying when this happened less than two weeks ago, too.
 

Kaguya

Member
Jun 19, 2018
6,408
Actually, I just looked you up. I blocked you on Twitter for saying "Does Neil not realise Schreier bleeds blue, to the point he burns if he has to say anything positive about another company...? This must be hurting Schreier very hard..." https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272247847434489865

Then you wrote this gem: https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272252907019218945

Real class act over here. Amazing that you're lying when this happened less than two weeks ago, too.
Holly shit lmao.
 

Yerffej

Prophet of Regret
Member
Oct 25, 2017
23,565

Prine

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
15,724
I don't see the need to discuss Jason's semantics to validate his report or not.
It is a matter of "logic" that Devs would not like to have one more device to work with, regardless of whether it is easy to scale or not, it is literally more work. As I said, it shouldn't be a big deal, especially for first parties, but I don't see what's so absurd in his (and Digital Foundry's or other site's) report.
If Devs increase access to their games, and if the tools support that overhead keeps things to a minimum then it's not much of point to raise, it's just business. It does comes across as a proxy for console wars, just like this fake concern about cross gen games which is geared as something that helps onboard gamers to next gen.
 

BradC00

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
2,158
I don't see the need to discuss Jason's semantics to validate his report or not.
It is a matter of "logic" that Devs would not like to have one more device to work with, regardless of whether it is easy to scale or not, it is literally more work. As I said, it shouldn't be a big deal, especially for first parties, but I don't see what's so absurd in his (and Digital Foundry's or other site's) report.

they already do it. ps4, ps4 pro, og xb1, xb1s, xb1x, pc w/ 50 different cards, and in some cases the switch. if anything in a year itll be less work because itll be ps5, xss, xsx, pc w/ 50 different cards, and switch. this just seems like concern trolling to me.

Imagine saying I "bleed PlayStation" as if I haven't been reporting critically on the company for years and didn't just publicly call out Sony's two biggest directors.

Imagine sharing doctored video clips of me to advance your deranged console warrior agenda (actual video: https://twitter.com/AtrioxIsComing/status/1275826108823244800)

Imagine not even realizing that I play all of my games on PC and Switch and wouldn't even get a next-gen console if I didn't have to for work lmao

yeesh.
 

Gamer17

Banned
Oct 30, 2017
9,399
Actually, I just looked you up. I blocked you on Twitter for saying "Does Neil not realise Schreier bleeds blue, to the point he burns if he has to say anything positive about another company...? This must be hurting Schreier very hard..." https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272247847434489865

Then you wrote this gem: https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272252907019218945

Real class act over here. Amazing that you're lying when this happened less than two weeks ago, too.
Oh damn. Thank you for shedding some light on it .your input is always appreciated here
 

Fabtacular

Member
Jul 11, 2019
4,244
If it does then, wow. That's an incredible package for people strapped for cash at a time like this. Lets not forget the Christmas present fiasco of retail, where little Timmy has a mum/dad go in and look at the consoles. These will be VERY pricey, but then when they see Series S sat there that plays the same games just in 1080p, like his bedroom TV... But nearly half the price... Its going to be no contest.

I mean, its still possible that if it supports ray tracing capabilities, its using a more cut down version like the PS5 stuff we have seen so far. Quarter res with limited bounce for reflection for example. It still gives a great result for a brilliant overall picture, its just not as high end as Series X.

Back when we were all speculating about the specs of the chips, Albert Penello said that there are only two real factors in cost w/r/t silicon: (1) design/testing, and (2) size of the chip. They don't have to pay more to have any technology, because they just pay a flat license for AMD's technology when they do a deal with AMD. So unless the RT takes us substantial physical room on the silicon, there's not extra extra cost to implement RT. And I think (but can't be certain) it's just baked into the RDNA2 design.
 

Bunkles

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
5,663
Imagine saying I "bleed PlayStation" as if I haven't been reporting critically on the company for years and didn't just publicly call out Sony's two biggest directors.

Imagine sharing doctored video clips of me to advance your deranged console warrior agenda (actual video: https://twitter.com/AtrioxIsComing/status/1275826108823244800)

Imagine not even realizing that I play all of my games on PC and Switch and wouldn't even get a next-gen console if I didn't have to for work lmao

Just curious, knowing what you know about PS5, you don't think you'd personally get one if you didn't have to for work? I seem to remember you being pretty excited about the hardware, IIRC.
 

Eamon

Prophet of Truth
Member
Apr 22, 2020
3,545
Actually, I just looked you up. I blocked you on Twitter for saying "Does Neil not realise Schreier bleeds blue, to the point he burns if he has to say anything positive about another company...? This must be hurting Schreier very hard..." https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272247847434489865

Then you wrote this gem: https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272252907019218945

Real class act over here. Amazing that you're lying when this happened less than two weeks ago, too.
WOW lmao
 

jschreier

Press Sneak Fuck
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
1,098
Just curious, knowing what you know about PS5, you don't think you'd personally get one if you didn't have to for work? I seem to remember you being pretty excited about the hardware, IIRC.
What I conveyed was that developers were excited for the hardware. I personally am way more excited about my PC. If I didn't cover games for a living, I'd probably get a PS5 for Horizon 2 and other exclusives down the road, but I definitely wouldn't get it at launch.
 

Uzupedro

Banned
May 16, 2020
12,234
Rio de Janeiro
Actually, I just looked you up. I blocked you on Twitter for saying "Does Neil not realise Schreier bleeds blue, to the point he burns if he has to say anything positive about another company...? This must be hurting Schreier very hard..." https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272247847434489865

Then you wrote this gem: https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272252907019218945

Real class act over here. Amazing that you're lying when this happened less than two weeks ago, too.
lol
If Devs increase the access to their games, and if the tools support that overhead keeps things to a minimum then it's not much of point to raise, it's just business. It does comes across as a proxy for console wars, just like this fake concern about cross gen games which is geared as something that helps onboard gamers.
Yeah, I agree with all that you said. But at the same time I believe in the reports (that someone linked a few pages ago), maybe everyone is right in this situation, since the opinions of the developers may have changed since these news came out.
 

tomwarren

Senior Editor, The Verge
Verified
Apr 18, 2018
339
*Jason Schreier enters the chat*

giphy.gif
 

Biosnake

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,253
Actually, I just looked you up. I blocked you on Twitter for saying "Does Neil not realise Schreier bleeds blue, to the point he burns if he has to say anything positive about another company...? This must be hurting Schreier very hard..." https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272247847434489865

Then you wrote this gem: https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272252907019218945

Real class act over here. Amazing that you're lying when this happened less than two weeks ago, too.
yo DAMN
 

Prine

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
15,724
That's why a publisher would like the idea. A dev (and by extension QA staff) would definitely see the downside of developing for two divergent systems.
Lol, at the QA comment, it's literally their job description. And if devs aren't restricted creatively, then what your saying isn't accurate either. The gold standard is the one they'll be proud of, downstream versions are just a formality. And this has been done on PC for decades, it's integrated into Dev pipeline, it's not something radical. These imagined concerns are something else.
 

CliveLH

Member
Jun 22, 2019
2,225
They're not gonna release a > $499 console after what happened to XB1 in 2013.

PS5 will most likely be $449 regular and $349 for Digital

$349 or 379 Lockhart is accurate
$449 or 479 Series X

In my dreams:
$199 Lockhart All-Digital
$299 Lockhart
$399 Series X
You think a Digital 10 TF PS5 and a Digital 4TF Xbox would cost the same ?
 
Oct 28, 2017
27,133
I'm trying work and close tickets but this is the most compelling thread we've had on the gaming side in some time.




On Topic
Is Ray-Tracying 1080p a attainable goal for the Lockhart or is it too much to ask? I'm getting a series x however if that means no grubby cheeto hands and capri sun juices in my console, I'll gladly pay for a streaming box for my boys room.
 

Prine

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
15,724
lol

Yeah, I agree with all that you said. But at the same time I believe in the reports (that someone linked a few pages ago), maybe everyone is right in this situation, since the opinions of the developers may have changed since these news came out.
I think we had a Dev here confirm the profiling options a few months ago, and reiterated it's not a big deal, they have well established processes in place to manage versions due to years of experience on PC. I will try to dig it up.
 

Zedark

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,719
The Netherlands
Jason's takedown was savage LMAO!

His comment from a few months ago imo lines up well with this rumour, since the RAM amount really seems lacking if this is indeed the case. It'd be a bummer, I wonder why they would have gone with 10 GB rather than 12 GB, which I believe would probably alleviate that bottleneck in order to make the downgrades more balanced. I guess the GDDR6 modules don't come cheap. Ah well, we'll see how things shake out. From my comfy armchair, the spec sheet doesn't look excessively difficult to work with, but I'm not working with it, so I don't really know. We'll have to see what devs say as they get to work with it over time.
 

Pryme

Member
Aug 23, 2018
8,164
Actually, I just looked you up. I blocked you on Twitter for saying "Does Neil not realise Schreier bleeds blue, to the point he burns if he has to say anything positive about another company...? This must be hurting Schreier very hard..." https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272247847434489865

Then you wrote this gem: https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272252907019218945

Real class act over here. Amazing that you're lying when this happened less than two weeks ago, too.

Whoa
 

Deleted member 1589

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
8,576


Make of it what you will.


Imagine saying I "bleed PlayStation" as if I haven't been reporting critically on the company for years and didn't just publicly call out Sony's two biggest directors.

Imagine sharing doctored video clips of me to advance your deranged console warrior agenda (actual video: https://twitter.com/AtrioxIsComing/status/1275826108823244800)

Imagine not even realizing that I play all of my games on PC and Switch and wouldn't even get a next-gen console if I didn't have to for work lmao

A doctored video.

What in fucks name is wrong with you people.
 

retrosega

Member
Jun 14, 2019
1,283
No way the Lockhart can be sold for the same (or more) than the PS5 Digital.

Not a chance, as it would be pointless, day one.
 

WhiskerFrisker

Teyvat Traveler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,349
New York City
If you have nothing worthwhile to say, you keep your mouth shut. I would have thought that criticism is something that a journalist who wrote critical pieces might understand. However, we seem to live in a world where common sense is not so common, and where blanket statements that are dumb as shit are used to describe people that prefer one platform as dumb as shit.

I personally find it funny that there are those that think he does not have a bias. Have them; we all have them, but it is not right for it to be portrayed differently.

As for his take on the console and what he has been hearing........well, how is this anything new in what has been decades of scalable engines? We really need to sometimes look at what game development is.
I'm the one to shut up when what you said and linked has added nothing to the conversation?
 

Deleted member 60772

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 21, 2019
396
It's fair to say it's a lower powered Xbox Series X made for rendering at FHD instead of 4K.

So, it'll pretty much run everything, just at lower res?

...I know I'm asking so pretty basic questions here, but I'm trying to get my head successfully around where this machine sits, and whether I want to buy one or not.
 

Thatguy

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
6,207
Seattle WA
Even if you have a 4k set, if its 42-inches or you sit 7-8 feet away from your 65-inch set, I don't think most people are going to see a great difference. When I moved from my 50-inch 1080p plasma to my new 65-inch 4k set, I didn't really notice any difference in resolution. What I mostly noticed was the HDR / brightness difference.

It all just comes down to price. I think a $150 difference would justify the tradeoff for someone buying a Fortnite/Minecraft box, or the person who just plays NBA2k/COD every year.
Thats what I mean by 'the one you want'. In a living room situation where you're sitting 8-12 feet away you need to go up to 80"+ to see the difference. Plus you're going to want HDR10, V-Sync, 120Hz+, etc. At todays prices thats a $5,000 set.
 

Exit Music

Member
Nov 13, 2017
1,082
Actually, I just looked you up. I blocked you on Twitter for saying "Does Neil not realise Schreier bleeds blue, to the point he burns if he has to say anything positive about another company...? This must be hurting Schreier very hard..." https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272247847434489865

Then you wrote this gem: https://twitter.com/Gavavva/status/1272252907019218945

Real class act over here. Amazing that you're lying when this happened less than two weeks ago, too.

This takes me back to those awesome Xbox forum posts where parents would get the receipts for why their kids were banned from Xbox Live. Thank you for sharing these tweets lmao.

My bold prediction:

PS5 - 549
PS5 Digital - 449
Xbox Series X - 449
Lockhart - 299
 

Uzupedro

Banned
May 16, 2020
12,234
Rio de Janeiro
they already do it. ps4, ps4 pro, og xb1, xb1s, xb1x, pc w/ 50 different cards, and in some cases the switch. if anything in a year itll be less work because itll be ps5, xss, xsx, pc w/ 50 different cards, and switch. this just seems like concern trolling to me.
It's not because they do that it means they like to do it, Jason's(and other's) story was about dev's thought/opinions in working on more than one device, and as others told me in the answers above, there is the market point of view that would bring more reasons why devs shouldn't bother to work on more than one console, a point that I hadn't thought of and that maybe changed their general opinion on this subject since the stories came out.
And why say I'm doing "concern trolling"? Not necessary.
 

Zedark

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,719
The Netherlands
So, is it fair to say the Lockheart machine falls somewhere in the middle between One X/ Ps4 Pro and Series X/Ps5?
Lockhart GPU would be about on par with XBOX One X or thereabouts, the CPU and SSD are what make it much better than the One X.
So, it'll pretty much run everything, just at lower res?

...I know I'm asking so pretty basic questions here, but I'm trying to get my head successfully around where this machine sits, and whether I want to buy one or not.
That's the thought, yeah. The GPU gap between this and the Series X is 3x, which should probably be a good enough gap to drop resolutions from 1800p-2160p to 1080p-1440p. Maybe some settings are lowered as well, but it doesn't seem like the settings need to drop dramatically in order to be compatible with next gen games.
 

jschreier

Press Sneak Fuck
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
1,098
The stupidest thing about people calling me a PlayStation fanboy is that if I have any emotional attachment to a video game company, it's Nintendo. (Not that that'd ever stop me from reporting critically on the company or its games.) I have zero attachment to Sony or PlayStation. I imagine anyone who's listened to Splitscreen/Triple Click can probably attest to this too.

Anyway, to get this thread back on track, I believe Tom Warren is correct, as he usually is. I heard/reported last year that Lockhart's GPU was around 4 teraflops and that it has an SSD and a faster CPU than any current console. (https://kotaku.com/sources-microsoft-is-still-planning-a-cheaper-disc-le-1840203823)
 

Wereroku

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,249
So, it'll pretty much run everything, just at lower res?

...I know I'm asking so pretty basic questions here, but I'm trying to get my head successfully around where this machine sits, and whether I want to buy one or not.
No one is sure yet. If you have a 4k xsx game theoretically it will just need the resolution and textures reduced. However towards the middle of the gen we might start getting lower res xsx games. If that is the case lowering res might not be enough. They might have to turn off effects and other things. Basically just like if you had a 2080ti and a 2060.
 

Thatguy

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
6,207
Seattle WA
They're not gonna release a > $499 console after what happened to XB1 in 2013.

PS5 will most likely be $449 regular and $349 for Digital

$349 or 379 Lockhart is accurate
$449 or 479 Series X

In my dreams:
$199 Lockhart All-Digital
$299 Lockhart
$399 Series X
I think Sony and Microsoft are holding their cards close on next gen streaming solutions. I'll be surprised if they both don't offer 4k/60fps within the next 5 years, plus all digital purchases streamable. When this happens, look for the streaming SKU thats just a controller and a little box for $150.
 

Rover_

Member
Jun 2, 2020
5,189
why these kinda of threads with some mighty inflammed persona making a scene always age like fine milk? lol'd
 

wwm0nkey

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,584
Jason with the fucking receipts, nice lol

While I do have thoughts about bias on this site, I also don't think this is the thread for that lol
 

RadioJoNES

Prophet of Truth - One Winged Slayer
Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
1,879
The stupidest thing about people calling me a PlayStation fanboy is that if I have any emotional attachment to a video game company, it's Nintendo. (Not that that'd ever stop me from reporting critically on the company or its games.) I have zero attachment to Sony or PlayStation. I imagine anyone who's listened to Splitscreen/Triple Click can probably attest to this too.

Anyway, to get this thread back on track, I believe Tom Warren is correct, as he usually is. I heard/reported last year that Lockhart's GPU was around 4 teraflops and that it has an SSD and a faster CPU than any current console. (https://kotaku.com/sources-microsoft-is-still-planning-a-cheaper-disc-le-1840203823)
Thanks for keepin it real J.
 

Deleted member 8784

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
1,502
Anyway, to get this thread back on track, I believe Tom Warren is correct, as he usually is. I heard/reported last year that Lockhart's GPU was around 4 teraflops and that it has an SSD and a faster CPU than any current console. (https://kotaku.com/sources-microsoft-is-still-planning-a-cheaper-disc-le-1840203823)

Do you have any idea why the thing is being kept so under wraps? Or is it literally because the target audience for the thing won't be interested in anything about it until it's on the shelves?

The news cycle for this generation has been fascinating in its oddness.
 

Deleted member 60772

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 21, 2019
396
No one is sure yet. If you have a 4k xsx game theoretically it will just need the resolution and textures reduced. However towards the middle of the gen we might start getting lower res xsx games. If that is the case lowering res might not be enough. They might have to turn off effects and other things. Basically just like if you had a 2080ti and a 2060.

Right. Fair enough. The graphics card analogy is a good way to put it, thanks.

Lockhart GPU would be about on par with XBOX One X or thereabouts, the CPU and SSD are what make it much better than the One X.

That's the thought, yeah. The GPU gap between this and the Series X is 3x, which should probably be a good enough gap to drop resolutions from 1800p-2160p to 1080p-1440p. Maybe some settings are lowered as well, but it doesn't seem like the settings need to drop dramatically in order to be compatible with next gen games.

Gotcha. That's much clearer now. Much appreciated. Depending on money and what games it has, I'd like to spring for both PS5 and Series X, but will consider Lockheart if money is a bit tighter, and it still retains some good exclusives.