• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

TheMoon

|OT|
Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,778
Video Games
I think many developers choose the first icon that they find of other versions and don't change it anymore. Even if it looks like a turd on big screen.
This happens mainly with late ports. (And Sonic Mania)
With Sonic Mania they just went "shit, we accidentally shipped a good Sanic game for once, we have to fuck SOMETHING up ...here, take this icon!"
 

SCB360

Banned
Oct 30, 2017
1,639
This shit was beautiful :p
vKbmONq.png


Why are Bayonetta's eyes closed in 1, q eye open in 2? Was 3 gonna have both open?
 

Deleted member 43657

User requested account closure
Banned
May 19, 2018
5,115
I just downloaded the Dragon Quest Builders 2 demo and the icon is gorgeous.

Please. SquareEnix. For the love of god: fix the icon for the original Dragon Quest Builders!
 

tolkir

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,252
Icons of the week

graveyardkeeperqkk8v.jpg
bloodstainedritualoft3yjen.jpg
terraria17jn6.jpg
furwindymkf1.jpg
chiki-chikiboxyprowretukjy.jpg

psyvariardeltatqk8i.jpg
superneptuniarpg6ajrv.jpg
wartechfightersr5kd1.jpg
penguinwarslpjac.jpg
nekoparavol.3j2kib.jpg

segaagesvirtuaracingi2k51.jpg
segaageswonderboymonsp2j8w.jpg
arcadearchivescluclulq4j37.jpg
devilmaycryq1kk1.jpg
q-yoblasterwek3a.jpg

ironycurtainfrommatryzrkfn.jpg
goonyafighternyku2.jpg
humanrocketperson3qkbc.jpg
baobabsmausoleumep213mdjav.jpg
headballsoccerdeluxe66k0t.jpg

supermariomaker2rzkyd.jpg
motogp193cjhk.jpg
fortboyardfpk5z.jpg
spellcastingpurrfectlqvjdb.jpg
realdriftracingb7kuf.jpg

bitlogic-acyberpunkartcjqb.jpg
attackofthetanktoysp2jeh.jpg
rallyrocknracingmtjn1.jpg
maddeningeuphoriacvj8g.jpg
dobutsushogiworldydjwu.jpg



- Japan

segaagesspaceharrierggk9g.jpg
la-mulana2guk2p.jpg
jinruinominasamahebejty.jpg
clockzeroshuuennoichih9koe.jpg
jikkyoupowerfulproyak1ejqj.jpg


- No Logo

dandydungeon-legendofi0jeo.jpg
we.therevolutionb3k72.jpg
raincitymgkpf.jpg
azurantrialsccjxz.jpg
linesx6kj5j.jpg

epicastrostoryp0kw5.jpg

Dandy Dungeon: Legend of Brave Yamada
We. The Revolution
Rain City
Azuran Tales: Trials
Lines X
Epic Astro Story
 

SpankyDoodle

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,082
Yes hmm yes I do feel that a game titled "Lines X" is very properly represented by a green dot with a black outline.
 

Robin64

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,625
England
Well, here we are, contender for the worst icon. "World of Riders", it's just a bad screenshot of the game, cropped, then given rounded corners like an iOS app. Hoo boy.

25e6d3c4f57886ad508bd720b80b0660ccb27716bec6f00ae5d824a24c7c7cdf.jpg
 

tolkir

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,252
Icons of the week

strangerthings3thegampvk0t.jpg
dreamdaddyadaddatingshqktf.jpg
whatremainsofedithfin0wjea.jpg
redfactionguerrillare8ajxd.jpg
ovivomvjga.jpg

lucahbornofadreamcqj4g.jpg
zigguratxxkf1.jpg
clannadrrj3m.jpg
ankhguardian-treasuren6kzk.jpg
asdivinediospykrr.jpg

arcadearchivesninjaspztj2e.jpg
paradoxsoulh8km1.jpg
puremahjongo3kxn.jpg
heroexpressdtkdm.jpg
busfix2019r7jos.jpg

laserkittypowpown2j2j.jpg


- Japan

taisenhotgimmickaxes-6kjk1.jpg
3-bikinokobutatoookam2vk5s.jpg


- No Logo

siralim3zgkza.jpg
bubblecatsrescueozj02.jpg
redneckskeetshooting3lj4d.jpg
worldofridersinjf1.jpg

Siralim 3
Bubble Cats Rescue
Redneck Skeet Shooting
World Of Riders
 

Maximus

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,586
But the devs know what the system UI looks like and what icon is being displayed on their devkit unit which uses the exact same home menu UI. I see no world in which they're confused about this. :(

From my experience, the devs I have worked with in non gaming capacities do not have an eye for design/think about the little details. It's just get something there or what they think looks good, isn't what actually looks good.

It could also be an oversight where one thing is put in as a first go and then never changed because "who cares".

Not speaking for all devs, but that's what I have experienced a lot of the time. It's not like they don't want things to look nice, but just need to be shown what is better and have the time/care to implement the better solution.
 

Myriotes

Member
Jan 30, 2018
532
Germany
Not only is the title missing, but the logo also is missing some "punch". Does not look good between Diablo 3 and Stardew Valley in the (excellent) preview feature.
 

Garfunkiel

Member
Oct 29, 2017
3
PK means 1024 x 1024, the original resolution. I only store at 400 x 400 as a space/size compromise (they're only displayed at 256 x 256 on an actual Switch, after all)

Also the full ranking's page can be a bit of a slog for some browsers, it's way too big now and something I need to solve. Best to use the search box top right of the main page.

The Pixel King I have a tool that may be of help, I'll PM you as it's SUPER SEKRIT.

Would you mind sending me that as well? I searched but couldn't find any references on how to get the original versions.
 

Dany1899

Member
Dec 23, 2017
4,219
I tried searching for WorldEnd Syndrome on Google images to see if I could find out what the icon for it actually is, but nothing seems to show it all. Wanted to see if it was part of a bigger picture or something. Does it show up in-game?
Now I can answer, yes it appears in the game. I took a screenshot without the text so that it is completely out of context:
D_QIx6oU8AA-Cco
At least there is a connection to the story - even though the icon still is the worst in my Switch.
 

tolkir

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,252
Icons of the week

eagleislandwtks3.jpg
blazingchromecgjj0.jpg
lethalleagueblazemfk0x.jpg
tinymetalfullmetalrum0lkz5.jpg
deadinvinlandmkjx6.jpg

streetsofrogueoekw1.jpg
professorlupoandhishobdj13.jpg
metaloidoriginbkjf8.jpg
forklift-thesimulatioyzj9r.jpg
3littlepigsbadwolfjkkvt.jpg

dragonquestbuilders2xjkgh.jpg
godeater3kwjfj.jpg
senrankagurapeachball15kqy.jpg
vektorwarsarjsc.jpg
arcadearchivesshusseo8ek7t.jpg

hyperlightultimateklk6m.jpg
desktopbowling91jkz.jpg
adrenalinerush-miamid3hk8c.jpg
grasscutteriojlz.jpg
madbulletsyxk3z.jpg

bouncybullets7lk1u.jpg
lustfordarkness08jgh.jpg
nellycootalotjsj37.jpg
questhunter3xj63.jpg
alienescapeq6kor.jpg

switchyroad2ikkz.jpg


- Japan

shoujotodragongenjuuk12ju8.jpg
kaerubatakedetsukamaey4kib.jpg
puru-charafriendshopp87jwb.jpg


- No logo

solseraph96j6y.jpg
skullsoftheshogunbonerekv7.jpg
doodlegodcrimecityzakao.jpg
wayoutr1jsy.jpg
supermutantalienassaugzkhw.jpg

SolSeraph
Skulls of the Shogun: Bone-A-Fide Edition
Doodle God: Crime City
Wayout
Super Mutant Alien Assault
 

Robin64

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,625
England
Nice try, Nintendo of America, but that's not the game's icon. That's the website's search icon, the actual game icon is a little more zoomed in.

A subtle difference, to be sure, but accuracy is everything!

Game's icon
NoA's "icon"