I'm gonna go through the player list quick because I feel like there's a lot of people off my radar:
[He/him] saenima - light town read, based on Aeleus point that I barely remember. Something about picking a fight with... Stu? No red flags, at least
[He/him] BronsonLee - carefree start, but has been very light on actual content. I think he's an overwhelmed newbie rather than coasting scum though
[They/them] Aeleus - Null, some decent posts, not ruffling any feathers as far as I remember. Could be competent newbie scum
[He/him] WhySoDevious - Null, hasn't really registered to me yet, sorry
[She/her] Kitsunelaine - scum? Has some strange posts, most notably that recent scumread on Godfather.
[He/him] Kalor - lives under the radar. I almost noticed him earlier but I've already forgotten why.
[He/him] Stuart444 - early town read but I've been cooling on it since. He seems a bit overeager to push after others have agreed with / defended him.
[He/him] LuxCommander - null, not enough activity. I think the votes on him are roughly as bad as the votes on melon though
[He/him] Grizzly - scum, I've said enough here already
[He/him] Zippedpinhead - willingly making himself a distraction. Unlikely to be scum with that play but he refuses to stop, so I'm not against his lynch. Still my emergency lynch.
[He/him] B-Dubs - probably scum, don't remember why ¯\\_(ツ)_/¯
[-] Godfather - Difficult one, I've flipped a couple of times already. Play has improved since he returned to the thread - responding to criticism without acknowledging it? Light scum read.
[He/him] Z-Beat - Null. I only remember him being a bit too mechanics focussed, undecided on that being scummy or enthusiastic newbie.
[He/him] flatearthpandas - Huh not much from feps today, he got a strange amount of attention from Lux though. Wonder if they're scummates.
[He/him] Kopite - Null, he's started getting mentions lately but was completely off my radar before that
[He/him] Hecht - ehhh light town read. Maybe null, I've liked his reads I guess
[He/him] Muffin - light scum, although he's been defending himself well and kinda made me feel slightly better about him. Still, not against his lynch.
[He/him] StanleyPalmtree - null, too little content. I don't think that's a scumtell in itself but it is making him hard to resolve.
[He/him] Fat4all - Not a great day 1 from Fats, possible scum
[He/him] Turmoil - uhh null, hacent really noticed him since he subbed in
[He/him] *Splinter - do we still put "towniest town" jokes here? I'm not caught up with the meta
[He/him] SaucyKaz - I think Kaz is another who I complimented for their carefree attitude early on. Been a bit of a non presence since then though. Null
[She/her] Girlofgotham - Very light town read, although it's just decent, steady play, nothing that couldn't be faked.
[She/her] weemadarthur - I don't actually have much on weemadarthur even though she's been posting quite a bit. I guess I'd give her the same light town read as Girlofgotham