As it's been over a week since I've finished Kingdom Hearts III, I've had some time to mull over the experience, the series as a whole, and the direction that the series seems to be going towards.
My point is, there are several things wrong with the way Kingdom Hearts X is being implemented into the series.
Kingdom Hearts X, was originally a Japanese browser game that was ported to mobile phones (rebranded as Kingdom Hearts Unchained X) and made available for players worldwide who owned smart devices. It was created as a way for Square Enix to capitalise on the KH brand via the lucrative mobile market, and no doubt the game has been a huge success making them millions and will continue to do so (in the current iteration which is titled Kingdom Hearts Union X, more on that later).
Now as some of you know, Kingdom Hearts X (KHX) is very dense in Kingdom Hearts Lore, taking place decades before even Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep. So much so that the original story of the base game was ported over to the consoles in movie form (Kingdom Hearts X Back Cover), in the KH2.8 collection. Logically, many fans assumed that KHIII would contain some elements of this story as part of the conclusion of the saga and that Back Cover was simply a way to get more information on these elements. An optional prequel, if you will.
Having finished KHIII, this isn't the case. From the epilogue, It's clear that the future of the series is going to be heavily based on the setup in KHX's story. To make matters worse, Kingdom Hearts Union X is still ongoing, with new major story beats and reveals that will most likely tie into the future of the series (for example Maleficient's entire arc has already been ret-conned thanks to KHUX, and her "story" in KHIII is a direct result of this).
Now as some of you know, Kingdom Hearts X (KHX) is very dense in Kingdom Hearts Lore, taking place decades before even Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep. So much so that the original story of the base game was ported over to the consoles in movie form (Kingdom Hearts X Back Cover), in the KH2.8 collection. Logically, many fans assumed that KHIII would contain some elements of this story as part of the conclusion of the saga and that Back Cover was simply a way to get more information on these elements. An optional prequel, if you will.
Having finished KHIII, this isn't the case. From the epilogue, It's clear that the future of the series is going to be heavily based on the setup in KHX's story. To make matters worse, Kingdom Hearts Union X is still ongoing, with new major story beats and reveals that will most likely tie into the future of the series (for example Maleficient's entire arc has already been ret-conned thanks to KHUX, and her "story" in KHIII is a direct result of this).
My point is, there are several things wrong with the way Kingdom Hearts X is being implemented into the series.
- I think the fact that the mainline titles of the series are being set up by a gatcha-based mobile game sets a dangerous precedent, and honestly I can't think of any other time a AAA franchise has done something like this. Imagine if Last of Us 2 came out after the release of a hypothetical mobile title "Last Of Us: The Last Union" that took place years before The Last Of Us, but set up vital plot beats regarding Ellie's immunity, that were followed up in Last of Us 2. Gamers would be up in arms.
- It was bad enough when the series was spread on different handheld devices, but one could argue that at least those experiences were whole titles that were entirely fulfilling experiences. Kingdom Hearts was always an "financially-exploitative" series, albeit with a heart. However, players who view the epilogue will be immediately drawn to the free-to-play mobile game, designed explicitly to keep you hooked as they drip feed you story updates every few months.
- (Speculation) Kingdom Hearts storytelling has slowly devolved into an unfriendly mess with each subsequent game, and with KHIII I think many were assuming that years of character development would be shown in a way that made it easier for newcomers and veterans alike to identify with characters. This is absolutely not the case, and anyone jumping from KHII to III would be completely lost because many characters do not even have simple lines of expository dialogue to re-cap the events they had been through. In the current state, I don't have faith that all these KHUX elements will be reintroduced to the players in a friendly way, but instead KHUX will be repurposed into a new game a la Kingdom Hearts Re:Coded. Many hoped that KHIII would tie up all loose ends and plots the writers had cornered themselves into, therefore eliminating the need to continue re-making games so fans could keep up with the multi-console spanning story.
- (Personal) Before KHIII I was always under the impression that KHX/UX would be a self contained prequel to the series as a whole, similar to The Silmarillion.
Last edited: