I see you point, but still, in Homelander's case, nothing would be more entertaining than watching him navigate his existence without superhuman powers. For him, it would be a fate worse than death. I'd prefer it if a supe taking permanent V to regain their powers ran the risk of death or getting a different superpower, like people taking V for the first time.I don't think their plans are to debuff Homelander or any supe for that matter, and then be done with it. Butcher wants all supes dead, so it's debuff->kill, so unless the permanent V is on like an insulin pump or something, I wouldn't say it's less impactful really.