After watching all these shows over the weekend, seeing all these games with super pristine polished graphics but these interchangeable visual identities, frequent lack of gameplay, and comparatively risk-free designs, I feel like I come to appreciate the more "A-AA" sized games coming out like NEO TWEWY, Psychonauts 2, and No More Heroes 3.
All those games have varying degree of roughness to them but it feels like these are games where their aspirations are strictly within the realm of what the developers know they can provide, and that you can just take it or leave it. Doing something totally crazy, stuff that might look/feel awkward to the common consumer, but just straight up knows it's willing to compromise on itself and push its humble ambitions to deliver something no one else is going to give you on a holistic level, doing so with confidence. "Anti-pretentious" in a way. It reminds me of the wild west of the fifth gen when we'd get games like God Hand, Killer7, the original Psychonauts, Stranger's Wrath, etc. Games that weren't scared of being something a little different while being focused in knowing entirely what they want out of themselves.
Obviously I still want these games to be polished and all, and everything is still subjective, but y'know, just speaking in a general sense. I guess I'm just thinking about that now and seeing how PlatinumGames, one of my favorite developers, continues to feel like they get dealt a bad hand by the producers they work for when their tenure since Clover made them the premiere provider of these kinds of "we just want to do something crazy and unique" experiences in my eyes, like I could always expect them to offer something truly unique that stands out, even when not always the most polished. It feels like the studio always gets contracted because they're known as the studio who makes those good combat hack 'n slashes, even though their nuances go deeper than that. Sometimes they'd do a super crazy take on a third person shooter, or their take on a Zelda-like, or a side scrolling beat em up. I miss those scrappy days.