Finished the game & while it definitely would have been my GOTY in 2012, in 2022 its just okay. Didnt regret playing it but its little too rigid in a way that feels dated in a 360-era kinda way & I think theres a lack of imagination in the playing as a cat aspect. For long stretches (particularly in the backhalf) you're interchangeable with any other third person protagonist except small. Loved doing stuff like using the meow to lure Zurks away from where you need to go, loathed the third person shooter sequence in the sewer.
Once you meet B-12 they basically become the plot's protagonist but the game wants to keep acting like its the cat leading to imo weird gamey disconnects. For example, I wouldve been fine accepting B12 was the one going through its inventory menus instead of the bizarre implication its the cat doing it. Its fun to knock over a painting to find the 4 digit code you need but it begs the question why a cat is finding keycodes at all. I will be the first to admit I'm being nitpicky but it routinely stood out to me & contributed to me feeling like less of a cat & more of a lil man, just a small kinda guy, as the game went on.
Also (ending spoilers) as someone who cared about reuniting with the other cats but didnt really care about the companions & b12, the ending was really hollow for me. I was hoping the game would be one long side story in the cats journey to reunite with its friends instead of that aspect being completely dropped.