To be honest, they're both pretty. Rose the character isn't glamorous, but she's a mechanic and she's suppose to be a surrogate character.No feelings just facts. People on Era have explicitly said if Veronica Ngo had the Rose role they wouldn't have minded the character. TLJ was just too much for the male nerd power fantasy genre where the only characters allowed are people you want to be/ can masturbate to.
Not saying if you don't like Kelly you're a weird male nerd but I've lost count of the amount of people who said "Rose's sister would have been better for the role." when the actress had no meaningful dialogue to indicate that/ screen time with Finn to know if they had better chemistry.
According to Wikipedia her character was complemented in reviews at the time, I understand she's not one of the main 4 characters but they could have give her something... something, because despite all the hate the character got, she did in fact have some fans. And honestly it takes you out of the world, when suddenly a secondary character is basically ignored. Of course so many decisions in ROS are addressing common things people complained about, that the world feel less genuine because you're constantly reminded of the intent of the choices of the writer.
Yoda foiled Luke from being the one to burn down the tree! And Leia foiled Poe's mutiny. Ughh... all these fucking characters foiling people.
Yea and he was nothing. There and gone. Now I recall him being at the resistance base afterward as well.
Cursory glance at the thread should be able to give you the answer.
1. Maybe read at least an OP before commenting
3. I think people should read those Jenny Nicholson tweets as well.
Remember the thread about her getting harassed off of social media and people felt it was more important to say they hated her character.
I agree with this. They could have deleted the guy from lost and given all his screen time to Rose.
Him, Dominic Monaghan, and Jannah (I wouldn't be surprised if everything she did was supposed to be done by Rose tbh, she's basically the same character besides being a former Stormtrooper) all could've been easily replaced with Rose.
Well yes duh, but when someone just kisses you heat of the moment or not that brings alot of feelings into it. It should at the very least have made things a little more awkward between them
He had an entire character about learning what it means to be a hero.
This would actually be a fun dynamic, I think. Give her a few "Ugh, these (loveable) knuckleheads...." moments.
Yeah all this "fuck JJ for appeasing the racists" is absolute nonsense. Rose was poorly written (imo) in TLJ and JJ didn't feel the need to bring her back. People who harassed her in real life are fucked up and she did not deserve any of that. People are quick to point fingers when there could be a lot of factors other than JJ appeasing the reddit crowd.
