The singular 'they' has been in use for centuries.
See: https://public.oed.com/blog/a-brief-history-of-singular-they/
In 1660, George Fox, the founder of Quakerism, wrote a whole book labeling anyone who used singular you an idiot or a fool. And eighteenth-century grammarians like Robert Lowth and Lindley Murray regularly tested students on thou as singular, you as plural, despite the fact that students used singular you when their teachers weren't looking, and teachers used singular you when their students weren't looking. Anyone who said thou and thee was seen as a fool and an idiot, or a Quaker, or at least hopelessly out of date.
All my support to them.
I admit that there are things I don't understand, but I'm glad that people like Sonic Fox may help me see and wrap my mind around questions like this. People should be what the fuck they want and I'm sure that his/their example will help some people feeling not wrong. :)
Quick note, you don't have to combine both pronouns into one, it's presented as an either or choice. You didn't do anything wrong, just thought I'd let you know. :pAll my support to them.
I admit that there are things I don't understand, but I'm glad that people like Sonic Fox may help me see and wrap my mind around questions like this. People should be what the fuck they want and I'm sure that his/their example will help some people feeling not wrong. :)
When talking about them in the third person, both "he" and "they" (and the associated words like his/their, him/them) are acceptable pronouns to use.I'm confused, non-binary male but they want to be referred to as he/they?
Careful now.
Still reading through the thread but I was thinking this too, I don't really know any non binary people.Honest question: if you really are going to ask people to identify you as "he" or "they", how many people are really going to go for "they"?
Or is what SonicFox saying they want to go from being called "he" --> "they"
Honest question: if you really are going to ask people to identify you as "he" or "they", how many people are really going to go for "they"?
Or is what SonicFox saying they want to go from being called "he" --> "they"
It means they're comfortable with using either. It might be that they want to explore using non-gendered pronouns to see if it's something that resonates with them - or that they sincerely don't mind either way. If they're coming to all of this later in life having been AMAB (assigned male at birth) then it might be they feel comfortable with he/his as it's familiar and what people close to them have always used.Is it me or being from another generation that genders are so confusing. I think of myself as very accepting, i just can not keep up. How can you know how to call someone they/she/he? If SonicFox himself is confused how to hell am i supposed to know. They need to teach this at schools from now on.
"I like SonicFox I think he's a cool person"Even though i read threadmark i am still confused about he/they how are they interchangeable
"I like SonicFox I think he's a cool person"
"I like SonicFox I think they're a cool person"
"I'm a fan of SonicFox, I like him a lot"
"I'm a fan of SonicFox, I like them a lot"
Nope, singular they is a thing.Isnt in english (not my first language) he/she/it means single person while they/we/you means multiple person?
Shouldnt he call himself "it" in this example
this is confusing as hell
Isnt in english (not my first language) he/she/it means single person while they/we/you means multiple person?
Shouldnt he call himself "it" in this example
this is confusing as hell
No, it wouldn't be it. You frequently use they in the singular in English when referring to people you don't know very well or are unsure of their gender:Isnt in english (not my first language) he/she/it means single person while they/we/you means multiple person?
Shouldnt he call himself "it" in this example
this is confusing as hell
I'm actually not sure! I use dude as a gender neutral term, but if that's wrong I'm open to being corrected.
When I was in school there was a big drive to remove "they" from use in essays etc. They wanted us to specifically use he/she instead of they. I'm not sure just how widespread that was but according to "Oxford English" at least this did mean a lot of people think that using "they" is not correct grammarIsnt in english (not my first language) he/she/it means single person while they/we/you means multiple person?
Shouldnt he call himself "it" in this example
this is confusing as hell
..or we could stick to how it's currently used in the singular and not pretend like this is somehow mind-breaking.Might make more linguistical sense if we said they is when talking singular and they are when talking plural.
I am now officialy so old that I had to Google both "SonicFox" and "non-binary man".
Many people according to the responses in the thread. The question is why you're incapable of ignoring a single forum topic you're not interested in.Yeah this, I mean, who cares about this? Why should we know? Why is this important?
heh, I know how you feel. I thought this was something to do with the hedgehog.Yeah this, I mean, who cares about this? Why should we know? Why is this important?
omg please no that sounds awfulMight make more linguistical sense if we said they is when talking singular and they are when talking plural.
Am I a terrible person if his #IMGAY hashtag thing now means less to me?
I probably am
But it did mean something to me
😐
This is not grammatically correct when referring to an individual though.
I have no problem not referring to somone as "he/she" or "him/her." But "they" implies plural.
See the following:
You wouldn't say, for example "The object belongs to them." when referring to a non-binary individual. The English language requires the word "him," "her," or "it" for an individual.
They/them can be used in both the singular and plural.
"SonicFox is good at MK, I hope they put on a good match"
"Those players are good at MK, I hope they put on a good match"
Both are correct uses of they, even if it sounds a little awkward in the singular.
Any idea how this would translate into a language where there's a feminine and a masculine "they"?
..or we could stick to how it's currently used in the singular and not pretend like this is somehow mind-breaking.
"Ignore Jamie, they're just jealous that you got a sweet and they didn't"
"Ignore Jamie, they's just jealous that you got a sweet and they didn't"
Jesus, the salt of some people because Sonic Fox had the GALL to ask to be recognized for who they are.
"BUBU THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE THOOO", get fucked.
It typically doesn't, not easily, and that's something that's being actively challenged and discussed at the moment in things like localisation issues.Any idea how this would translate into a language where there's a feminine and a masculine "they"?
Apologies, it's hard not to be condescending when people persistently act like it's not something that's already a part of the language or needs changing.Well when you're taught otherwise, and they used as a singular isn't part of your vocabulary, it is kind of mind-breaking. It takes time to get used to, I guess. And I doesn't help if you get all condescending about it.