Haha. Haven't thought about that album in a while. I eMuled that mother, back in the day.
I'm really struggling to think of something different yet well known.
I really can't stand the trend of heavier/louder/more energetic songs sung in a sparse, vulnerable way. It's the laziest and shittiest kind of cover.
I was playing in a covers band, doing parties and the like, and the singer wanted us to do 'Sound of Silence' by Disturbed. I really didn't like that song the first time I heard it, after practicing it for an hour we all absolutely hated it!
I was also in an indie/folk band in London in the 00s. We did a cover of Army of Dreamers by Kate Bush, with xylophone and mandolin. The band was ever so slightly hipster!