• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

disparate

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
7,904
LMFAO nobody cares about ARR my guy. The main meat of FFXIV is the expansions. What a ignorant ass post
Nearing the end of Shadowbringers myself, yes the expansions are the meat of the game, but that doesn't stop ARR from being a horrifically awful barrier dozens of hours long. I'm still unsure if I'd ever recommend this to anyone new given how bad it is.
 
Aug 7, 2020
67
100% this.

Look, I never enjoyed MMOs before FFXIV and I know a lot of us didn't. The team behind this game is so talented that I overcame that hurdle because hot damn it's a good Final Fantasy.

But even for those of y'all who can't get past the MMO aspect, I get it, you don't have to play the game; just please trust me: they are the best team at Square overall. Incredibly talented and their passion and reverence for the franchise shines through constantly even as they pave bold new roads for what it means to be an FF.

literally started it on my iMac TODAY. Little overwhelmed, my only MMO experience was a few hours of XI many years ago on PS2. What I've played so far is fun, very polished and nicely written. I really need a controller though, I'm so not used to playing with a keyboard and mouse.
 

Ovvv

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Jan 11, 2019
10,030
Love the hate on FFXIV ARR from people who gave up on it an hour in.
 

Mediking

Final Fantasy Best Boy (Grip)
Member

Quinton

Specialist at TheGamer / Reviewer at RPG Site
Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,253
Midgar, With Love
literally started it on my iMac TODAY. Little overwhelmed, my only MMO experience was a few hours of XI many years ago on PS2. What I've played so far is fun, very polished and nicely written. I really need a controller though, I'm so not used to playing with a keyboard and mouse.

Nice, enjoy! I strongly recommend a controller, yessss. (Though I am admittedly biased, as I play on PS4, lol.)
 
Oct 31, 2017
14,991
Actually I lied

I'm more than okay with high fantasy

If it's something like the Suikoden games and Fire Emblem Three Houses

Where there's still a heavy focus on character drama despite the political plot

And the characters don't speak in purple prose


Which tbh is what I'm frightened of for a high fantasy FF
 

kurahador

Member
Oct 28, 2017
17,523
Nearing the end of Shadowbringers myself, yes the expansions are the meat of the game, but that doesn't stop ARR from being a horrifically awful barrier dozens of hours long. I'm still unsure if I'd ever recommend this to anyone new given how bad it is.
ARR is at worst one of those generic MMO made after WoW gained popularity years ago. Unless it's someone who really hate MMO, I wouldn't mind recommending it.
 

Zen

The Wise Ones
Member
Nov 1, 2017
9,657
Nearing the end of Shadowbringers myself, yes the expansions are the meat of the game, but that doesn't stop ARR from being a horrifically awful barrier dozens of hours long. I'm still unsure if I'd ever recommend this to anyone new given how bad it is.
The expansions are structured much the same as ARR with some tweaks and quality of life changes. The difference is in the writing and scope, and narrative presentation. I think for what it was at the time of its release ARR is good at what it set out to do. The team has also matured in the 7 years since its release and it shows. Yeah ARR will always be necessary to experience for what comes after, but it isn't some nightmare of an unplayable mess that has to be endured for the 'good part' to kick in. The good stuff later on only happens at all because ARR set up for it to.
 

Issen

Member
Nov 12, 2017
6,814
I'll be the guy to defend ARR. It's a good game that establishes a universe and brings a shit ton of lore to the table, brings your character up from a run of the mill adventurer to an involved VIP, and introduces characters who will later grow and change in ways most FF casts could only hope to. It's also faithful to the original job systems of early FF. Burying your head in the sand and repeating that it sucks ad nauseum doesn't convince anybody that you're right. It just makes you look stubborn.
And I'll be the guy to tell you you're right. ARR has plenty of fantastic story beats in it. Some of it is boring filler shit but it's far from being all or even most of it.
 

ZeroX

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
21,266
Speed Force
The base game is essentially free or at most like $5 now. So paying for ARR + skip will really cost you $16, barely over a month of subscription
Again, why should I have to pay to get past all the awful content? The game is forcing a sub and a skip on me or a slog is the issue. You also have to pay for the level up item, don't you? Which looks like it's double the price of the story skip.

You realize you can manually skip cutscenes without paying right? I brought up both options because you aren't limited to one.

Paying to skip allows you to jump right in but it will still function like an MMO which means you need to level a character in order to reach the newer content. This should be expected in any online game.

They have also streamlined ARR recently making it even EASIER to bypass the dull story and moments. You have plenty of options that don't force you to sit through 50+ hours of old and unsatisfying content. There is zero excuse to still hold it against the rest of the game.
But it's still a horribly boring fetch quest of a game, at least up until MSQ 35 where I stopped. Skipping cutscenes isn't going to make it a 5 hour game, it's still a boring 30+ hour title. The cutscenes weren't amazing but it's not like the gameplay was hot either. They both suck.

Like what other JRPG requires such a ridiculous time investment to 'get good'? It's a long genre but usually they kick into gear within the first 5 hours. Like fuck P5's pacing but the story and gameplay were both 10x better than ARR.

Love the hate on FFXIV ARR from people who gave up on it an hour in.
I gave it 30ish hours
 

Ehoavash

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 28, 2017
7,232
FF7R is not unpolished lol

tenor.gif
 

disparate

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
7,904
Love the hate on FFXIV ARR from people who gave up on it an hour in.
I hate it and I got to level 80 in Shadowbringers thanks to quarantine and having a friend that's a healer that could get me through queues faster than 20 minutes. I doubt I would have made it through otherwise. Shadowbringers and Heavensward are good, but I'm not going to dismiss how awful ARR was to get through to get there in the first place.
 

Makoto Yuki

▲ Legend ▲
Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,397
If I had more time I would be playing AAR, but WoW still is the MMO that has my attention. Which is unfortunate because Legion pretty much was the last expansion I cared for.

I can't wait to see FFXVI

A new FF, this will finally get me excited for next generation.
 

Marie

Member
Oct 25, 2017
650
lol imagine feeling forced to buy a level-up skip.

Leveling is never an issue in FFXIV. Its so easy to level in this game. ARR sucks compared to the expansions but its not that terrible. It sets up so much stuff that makes the expac way better. Without ARR, SHB would not be as good as it is. And once again ARR was inherited from the shitstain that 1.0 was
 

Yeul

Member
Oct 25, 2017
203
disparate and I have been playing XIV with friends since quarantine started like he mentioned and yeah...ARR was definitely a slog. Having played through all of the content now I can obviously say that overall the game is great and has totally given me hours upon hours of enjoyable story and dungeon/raid experiences with friends, but I can't sugarcoat the fact that I do have memories of me muttering my displeasure at ARR pacing. Still I'm excited to see what the FFXIV team can do because their recent output has been really enjoyable.
 
I would absolutely love an SP FF done the by the XIV team!
lol imagine feeling forced to buy a level-up skip.

Leveling is never an issue in FFXIV. Its so easy to level in this game. ARR sucks compared to the expansions but its not that terrible. It sets up so much stuff that makes the expac way better. Without ARR, SHB would not be as good as it is. And once again ARR was inherited from the shitstain that 1.0 was
Heavensward is godly but it's largely because of the buildup that ARR provides
 

kurahador

Member
Oct 28, 2017
17,523
Again, why should I have to pay to get past all the awful content? The game is forcing a sub and a skip on me or a slog is the issue. You also have to pay for the level up item, don't you? Which looks like it's double the price of the story skip.
Because there's also a skip cutscene feature that is free and you still blame the game just for its existence. Also...if you have HW expansion, there are new jobs that starts at 30. And SB's jobs starts at 50 while Shb job starts at 60.

And this crusade of yours to scare off people from playing this game is grating.
 

Wazzy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,070
But it's still a horribly boring fetch quest of a game, at least up until MSQ 35 where I stopped. Skipping cutscenes isn't going to make it a 5 hour game, it's still a boring 30+ hour title. The cutscenes weren't amazing but it's not like the gameplay was hot either. They both suck.

Like what other JRPG requires such a ridiculous time investment to 'get good'? It's a long genre but usually they kick into gear within the first 5 hours. Like fuck P5's pacing but the story and gameplay were both 10x better than ARR.
Then that is a you problem. You obviously just don't like the MMO structure and that is fine but that doesn't mean the game is bad.

Fetch quests, grinding and boring repetitive quests happen in MMOs. WoW has the same content because these games are meant to follow a progression path for levelling and reaching the end.

None of this has any bearing on the writing, music and battle system.

Comparing this to a standard JRPG makes no sense because again this is an MMO. It's common sense that things will work differently from a solo RPG. The content will always be longer and the experience won't be for everyone.

No one is forcing you or anyone to play an MMO. If you dislike how they work then it's not for you. This doesn't mean you get to dismiss an entire MMOs praise and positive reception.

If I had more time I would be playing AAR, but WoW still is the MMO that has my attention. Which is unfortunate because Legion pretty much was the last expansion I cared for.

I can't wait to see FFXVI

A new FF, this will finally get me excited for next generation.
Retail or classic?
 
Last edited:

Orion

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
6,766
I really liked XIV, but I always feel like I missed something when people praise its story. I only got as far as finishing ARR though, then my free month ended so I never went back lol.
 

Viale

▲ Legend ▲
Member
Oct 25, 2017
11,614
lol imagine feeling forced to buy a level-up skip.

Leveling is never an issue in FFXIV. Its so easy to level in this game. ARR sucks compared to the expansions but its not that terrible. It sets up so much stuff that makes the expac way better. Without ARR, SHB would not be as good as it is. And once again ARR was inherited from the shitstain that 1.0 was

I haven't played the expansions yet (in 2.4 now), but ARR was a fucking slog imo. Good moments separated by loads of stuff that felt meaningless with constant backtrack, and Gameplay that isn't remotely interesting until like the 40s.

Luckily it gets pretty immediately better in the subsequent patches and I'm hyped for the expansion.
 

Zen

The Wise Ones
Member
Nov 1, 2017
9,657
disparate and I have been playing XIV with friends since quarantine started like he mentioned and yeah...ARR was definitely a slog. Having played through all of the content now I can obviously say that overall the game is great and has totally given me hours upon hours of enjoyable story and dungeon/raid experiences with friends, but I can't sugarcoat the fact that I do have memories of me muttering my displeasure at ARR pacing. Still I'm excited to see what the FFXIV team can do because their recent output has been really enjoyable.
I won't defend that part of it yeah. The pacing is lax until you reach Coerthas and the main meat of the plot kicks in around level 37ish, and in the patch content between you'll feel sluggish if you aren't vested in what's going on around Eorzea. I guess it's where the MMO vs standard RPG break becomes apparent. I think I'll give ARR a replay sometime to see how my memories hold up.
 

Saibot

Member
Nov 3, 2017
36
[...]
Developed by the FFXIV team [...].
twistedvoxel.com

Final Fantasy XVI Announcement Reportedly Planned For PS5 Showcase

Square Enix is planning to announce Final Fantasy XVI during the upcoming PS5 showcase according to some reports. The event is set for this Wednesday.

Well, that would certainly explain their drop in quantity and quality content for the MMO since post-Shadowbringers (at least imo).

FFXVI for PS5 only (or time-exclusive) would be a killer for sure. But I doubt it would be due before late 2021 or later, so it's whatever anyway
 

DNAbro

Member
Oct 25, 2017
25,866
I would've gone further but playing with randoms in the dungeons stressed me out. I tried to be a healer for a bit and it didn't end well lol. Did they ever make it all solo-able or is it just the newer stuff?

Only Shadowbringers on is solo able for dungeons. Trials always require multiplayer. Also I don't heal either cause that's a stressful job lol.
 

Zen

The Wise Ones
Member
Nov 1, 2017
9,657
I would've gone further but playing with randoms in the dungeons stressed me out. I tried to be a healer for a bit and it didn't end well lol. Did they ever make it all solo-able or is it just the newer stuff?
It's just Shadowbringers where you can solo a dungeon with NPCs. Healing can be stressful yeah. Go with a DPS job and you'll have an easier time (albeit longer queue times).
 

NoalleGospell

Member
Dec 3, 2018
1,748
Puerto Rico
This turned into a another thread about arguing if ARR is good or not. Maybe it's cause I started the game in the launch window of ARR(on ps3 at that) I never found my time playing through to be a slog and the story was enjoyable. They only problem I can can see going back to do those parts of the game is the sever lack of skills since so many of the abilities back then have been removed which made later levels better.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.