I don't know what to tell you except it's there and very audible. If you can't hear it, good on you I guess?
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Reports of Loud Coil Whine on PS5
- Thread starter Psychotron
- Start date
- Sony Tech
I don't know what to tell you except it's there and very audible. If you can't hear it, good on you I guess?
I caved in, I opened the second PS5...
I'm currently downloading demon's souls. With Astrobot, one was slightly louder than the other. But it's not so much the noise level, but the pitch and whirling sound.
With demon's souls running on both consoles I'll be fixed.
None of them are dead silent.
I'm currently downloading demon's souls. With Astrobot, one was slightly louder than the other. But it's not so much the noise level, but the pitch and whirling sound.
With demon's souls running on both consoles I'll be fixed.
None of them are dead silent.
Neither I have a soundbar nor use headphones, so I hear the console noise more obviously.
And nope, not going to start using them because of this.
This kind of issue is very difficult to discuss because each person has a very different tolerance for noise. On top of that, the environment we all play in is vastly different - the base noise level, distance from the PS5 and so on. It also appears that there is some degree of variance between different PS5 units in terms of how loud the coil whine/ electrical buzzing is. It also heavily depends on which game you play as it is not a steady noise. The loudest I've heard my PS5 was in the Black Ops multiplayer menus which have uncapped frame rates.
For people whose units can be heard over speakers/headphones - this is not normal or acceptable. If it was my unit, I would contact Sony. For all the rest of us, we can only hope that coil whine will diminish with time or that Sony will find a way to tweak power draw or cap frame rates to 60/120 through firmware updates to minimize this.
For the people who commented on having silent PS4 Pro units, it must have been later revisions because most launch units were absolutely horrendous, at least 2-3 times as loud as my PS5.
For people whose units can be heard over speakers/headphones - this is not normal or acceptable. If it was my unit, I would contact Sony. For all the rest of us, we can only hope that coil whine will diminish with time or that Sony will find a way to tweak power draw or cap frame rates to 60/120 through firmware updates to minimize this.
For the people who commented on having silent PS4 Pro units, it must have been later revisions because most launch units were absolutely horrendous, at least 2-3 times as loud as my PS5.
I guess. I do get really annoyed by certain environmental sounds, and I know that if I could hear the system it would likely bother me too. I don't know if this would make any difference, but is there any other spot you could possibly place yours, or even just angle it differently? The noise on mine isn't what bugs me the most though, it's the obnoxious, blaring lights on the front which are like a Las Vegas strip in a dark room. So I have mine behind my TV. Maybe that's dampening the whine somewhat.
Would the dashboard be at an unlocked, max frame rate though? Plus, what about when playing games that are capped at 60? My previous two 1080s both had intermittent coil whine, but I always kept the frame limiter to 60.
Wow, that's seriously loud then, or at least at a frequency that cuts through all other ambient noise. My PS4 Pro sounds like a jet engine but I can't hear that from 6-7 feet away with headphones on.
Ive been playing Astrobot, Spider man MM, Ghost of Tsushima and Uncharted Multiplayer constantly in rotation. It was the worst on day 1 in Ghost of Tsushima Legends.
To me this sounds more similar to the guy who had an issues with a sticker becoming dislodged and rubbing against the fan than coil whine.
Well, it's very subtle but I think the new one is slightly quieter, but I can still hear it from my couch and it's still a little annoying buzzing sound. Can't hear it over game audio like the other one, I think they are on the same level and it's even more stressful to decide which one to keep 😂
My quest for a silent ps5 ends here.
Time to sell the other one.
My quest for a silent ps5 ends here.
Time to sell the other one.
The sound instantly changes when I switch between in-game and home screen. If it was a fan related issue you'd assume there is a delay with the fan ramping up/slowing down but there is none of that. The pitch of the hum instantly changes between main menu, loading and actual gameplay as well. Additionally, the sound emanates from the bottom of the console where the PSU is located. The fan is at the top (talking about vertical orientation of the console of course).
I am pretty positive this is coil whine and not a fan related issue.
Last edited:
Or try like me to send the other one at sony and pray they will correct this, if not then sell it if they say its normal.
Thought about that as well. Are there maybe differences with the used resolutions? I am playing on a 1080p screen with serious coil whine, maybe there is less of that with 4k screens.
My "new" ps5 does that and the "old" one was loud because of the fan. There's two loteries you have to win in order to get a silent ps5.
It' s so widespread that I think it's normal. Seriously, if I didn't read people saying they got dead silent ps5, I would not think twice about it. Both my PS5s are quieter than the Switch fan ffs. I have to mute the audio and focus on the sound of the ps5. If I can live with the ps4 pro, I can deal with this level of noise.
Let's play the lottery again in 3-4 years with the ps5 pro!
Yeah the fan noise is normal. They all do that and should sound nothing more than a whooshing sound. The definition of "whisper quiet". People who say theirs don't do that either have ambient noise that's louder in their room or have a PS5 with a broken fan, because it's clear Sony kicks the fans up any time a game is started. The coil whine though is something none of the consoles should have. In a perfect world, all consoles would achieve the level of quiet MS did with the XSX. It's not even whisper quiet. It's straight up silent.
That's exactly what I noticed as well. Even if I'm on the homescreen with Demon's Souls running in the background the buzzing is as loud as when the game is on screen. The moment I close the game the sound goes down immediately. Definitely the buzzing is related to the CPU/GPU load.
I've seen people say that the coil whine isn't a big deal if you're playing a game and not right next to the console, but the thing is that we have different variations in how noisy it is. I don't agree with the statement "we all have some coil whine, it's normal" because it undercuts how severe it can get for some people. This isn't normal.
This one is not a coil whine. Like the other video, it seems to be fan related. Coil whine would not generate that kind of vibrations
I'm starting to wonder if my buzz isn't fan related and not coil whine since it seems to be constant and even no matter if I'm in a game or on the Home Screen. I can only hear it if I get up close, do you think it's worth it to try and open up the console and see if there's anything caught in there or is that too risky?
It is "normal" for Sony :)
All joking aside, I agree with you that as customers, we should not accept any degree of coil whine as the norm. In theory, at least.
The people who have more severe cases of this electrical noise should absolutely get their consoles exchanged/repaired. At least the odds of getting one that is less noisy will be in their favour. It is not realistic to expect that they will get a totally silent console at this point in time though. Sony may address this issue in a future revision of the PS5 hardware if we put a lot of pressure on them, but I would not hold my breath. Considering how many units exhibit a certain degree of coil whine, they must have noticed this in their own testing and thought that it was within acceptable limits.
Yeah, I agree with this. If the coil whine is only noticeable 2 feet away from the console, I wouldn't care, but my problem is that I can hear it from my couch. I want a quieter console, but I'm not expecting it to be completely silent or anything.
Same, I can hear my high pitched whirl sitting 6 ft away during quiet parts of games. Going to return my unit and try my luck with another unit. I already have a silent Series X.
Mine sounds just like this. I also can hear it from across my living room. I don't have Demon's Souls but mine makes a loud buzzing sound like this while playing AC Valhalla. It's quieter in Fortnite and Astrobot probably because they aren't pushing the system as hard. Who knows how loud it will get once more next-gen games come out that actually push the system's performance.
OP
OP
Here's another. Seeing more and more videos on YouTube. Also, people giving shit about being close before the phone picks it up, you need to understand that the phone doesn't do a great job of picking this buzzing up. My ears can hear it from 10 feet away easy. This buzzing, much like plasma buzz, bounces off walls. Playing Demon's Souls, even at a high volume with a pretty badass surround system, I can hear a very noticeable buzzing. Moving the camera changes the pitch and intensity.
There are way too many people trying to say that we can't hear our own PS5's because they couldn't hear it when the mic wasn't near the console. What reason would anyone here have to lie? If we say we can hear it from 6-10 feet, we probably can, otherwise why would we be unhappy? If mine made a noise right next to it but not from my seating position, you'd never see me post anything about it. This is a shitty thing happening to people who were very excited about their new console. The fact that this console does so much right just pushes the dagger in further when once again, it's an audible noise messing it up.
There are way too many people trying to say that we can't hear our own PS5's because they couldn't hear it when the mic wasn't near the console. What reason would anyone here have to lie? If we say we can hear it from 6-10 feet, we probably can, otherwise why would we be unhappy? If mine made a noise right next to it but not from my seating position, you'd never see me post anything about it. This is a shitty thing happening to people who were very excited about their new console. The fact that this console does so much right just pushes the dagger in further when once again, it's an audible noise messing it up.
Wow that's bad. Mine is like that too. Yeah I don't understand why people feel the need to tell us we aren't hearing things or it's not that bad. I have a 7.1 high-end home theater setup and the buzzing cuts right through whenever a game quiets down. I posted a few responses on Reddit and people instantly pile on saying the noise is normal and exaggerated by the camera. Also many defending Sony's decisions to allow this level of noise variance in the manufacturing. "cOiL wHiNe iS nOrMaL!"
Yeah. I'm beginning to think people who thinks this is normal has never experienced coil whine before ps5. This shit is not normal and those of us who lived through shoddy ass quality GPUs on our PC can attest to this. It's not something you will ever get used to unless you have an amazing patience of tuning out a high pitched white noise constantly whining.
Dunno if videos alter the pitch in some way, but mine definitely has a noticeable whir to it, but thankfully at a lower hum. I can hear it across the room, but thankfully it comes across as more white noise/ambience than some of these examples.
OP
OP
Furthermore, media outlets with clickbait titles should be ashamed. Gamespot and Push Square posting that stupid sticker video that is clearly a different issue, yet saying in their titles "Coil Whine Could Be Caused by a Loose Sticky Label." Really? Besides being factually impossible since coil whine has zero to do with anything near the fan, it's taking attention away from the real coil whine issue. I was glad to see they mentioned in the article that there are people facing real coil whine issues, but come on, you buried that part and most will just see the title and run with it. This doesn't help at all.
Damn wish they went into the game to move around the camera to show how bad it gets. That so far is the closest to what mine sounds like.
Has anyone tried different power strips, surge protectors or even outlets to see if affects anything? I moved mine to a nearby outlet and it didn't change a thing.
Mine is audible enough to be annoying when not wearing headphones / in quieter scenes, but low enough to where I can mostly tune it out. Sucks having it in a small bedroom though where the buzzing noise bounces off the walls and sounds louder than it really is lol
The sound on mine is definitely the fan, i took it apart and when the fan starts spinning faster it hums, i have very little coil whine.
Last edited:
I think i could need some help here, i want to know if i write a little letter in the repair box that explain the problem a little better then the useless guy french guy on Sony support (the first i've got in the morning was amazing, not the second one during PM). I have a feeling he wrote stupid thing in the report. Does it could help the repair center ? After 10 hours with my second ps5, coil whine is there, but really less noticeable at distance.
In theory you can. You just make the console draw less power, which has a very obvious effect on performance, so they'll never do that. We just need to live with it apparently.
MS did last gen, but the power they were negating was the draw that Kinect was pulling, which obviously wasn't an issue since Kinect was no longer being included. But yes, in the case of the PS5, you can't unfortunately.
I just want to say sorry to all you who have coil whine/noises with your PS5. Truly a bummer. I don't have any noise yet but I wouldn't be surprised if it shows up at some point - really haven't stressed the system at all.
I've got the same issue and it's more audible in person, the microphone isn't going to pick up on it as well as you can hear it. I don't understand trying to downplay it when there's numerous people in this thread that have said it's clearly audible in person, not just when you're right next to it.
No, it's the coil whine. The sound is louder as you get closer to the PSU.
I have mine plugged in a ups-surge protector, so I tried plugging it directly to the outlet on the wall and made zero difference unfortunately