Have Kingdra, Rotom, and Ludicolo been confirmed? I know Rhydon was deemed worthy of being let into Galar, but what about the rest?
Yup the flood gates really opened and it's become more the failures of GF over the past 10 years or so.In the past, when I was upset about a feature or a change, I just swallowed it and thought "it's not all about me." But this time, for once, it's about everybody. So everyone's just letting it out.
Have Kingdra, Rotom, and Ludicolo been confirmed? I know Rhydon was deemed worthy of being let into Galar, but what about the rest?
I actually think the gameplay is in the higher tier of the genre and I appreciate the game design not becoming trash like FF. I also dig the world building and characters. It just needs the post-game challenges to let the player have fun single player wise with it, also difficulty options would be nice.
That's a take, I guess.I said it earlier but take away the metagame of transferring your Pokemon from generation to generation and you're left with a pretty mediocre JRPG with cute monsters.
This seems to be it. It's the old "Every Pokémon is someone's favorite Pokémon", so there was no way this wasn't going to be a severely controversial decision.My reading is that, if you've been a lifelong Pokémon fan, you've been routinely disappointed one way or another by the series. Maybe they removed a feature you really liked, or maybe the series went in a direction you didn't prefer, but chances are even the most faithful fans have been disappointed by decisions Game Freak has made.
But people overlook those disappointments because they love Pokémon. And maybe there are design decisions you don't like or features removed, but it's still Pokémon, and that was always enough to to look beyond the things you didn't like and focus on the things you did. After all, people play Pokémon in so many different ways. Maybe the things that meant a lot to you just weren't popular enough to justify. If you were going to stick with the series, you needed to make peace with the fact you wouldn't always get everything you wanted.
But this change is just so fundamental. It has enormous implications for almost every single kind of player. You can't look past it and say "well, at least it's still Pokémon" because this time the fundamental Pokémon experience, something you took for granted, the thing that always kept you grounded despite the other changes, has been compromised. So no matter what you were disappointed with previously, and however you made peace with that, now almost every type of Pokémon fan is unanimously disappointed at once.
In the past, when I was upset about a feature or a change, I just swallowed it and thought "it's not all about me." But this time, for once, it's about everybody. So everyone's just letting it out.
They did it once, no reason to believe they wouldn't do it again
The contrast between Gamefreak's ambition of Pokemon as a game series and TPCI's ambition of it as a franchise is astronomical. TPCI is going nuts with trying to make SLEEP INTO ENTERTAINMENT meanwhile GF is unable to keep basic features of JRPGs, let alone support the pokemon they have created up until now.Unfortunately, that seems to be the main reason if you go by that Famitsu interview. They are saying it's just not sustainable to include them all anymore. Basically, they are admitting their limitations as a developer. Not saying that people have to accept that from the Pokémon franchise, but that's what they seem to be saying.
This seems to be it. It's the old "Every Pokémon is someone's favorite Pokémon", so there was no way this wasn't going to be a severely controversial decision.
I'm totally expecting it
Have Kingdra, Rotom, and Ludicolo been confirmed? I know Rhydon was deemed worthy of being let into Galar, but what about the rest?
From a communications point of view this has been an absolute shitshow. I guess Masuda deserves props for actually letting us know ahead of releasing the games (can you imagine if they didn't...). But reading through their rationale, I can't help but think "how is this my problem?!". Seriously, people spend their hard-earned money on your games and merchandise. A lot of them buy an entire console they wouldn't have bought otherwise just to play pokemon. The argument that this cannot be done from a technical standpoint just doesn't hold up when you see The Witcher 3 releasing on the Switch. I mean come on.
Unfortunately, that seems to be the main reason if you go by that Famitsu interview. They are saying it's just not sustainable to include them all anymore. Basically, they are admitting their limitations as a developer. Not saying that people have to accept that from the Pokémon franchise, but that's what they seem to be saying.
I don't have problem with Megas and Z-moves because they feel like logical steps for the series. A "special evolution" and a "special move", they're natural concepts related to core aspects of Pokémon. I agree that focusing the design in the story around them is bad and makes things generally worse, they should be integrated in smart ways, not forced; also balance better who is buffed by unique Megas and Z-moves instead of giving them to already strong Pokémon.I just think it needs to build more on underutilized aspects to make it more fulfilling. Theres no need for the gimmick battle mechanics.
Did I misread, or did the Famitsu interview with Masuda say they were re-modeling every Pokemon? If so, I'm not seeing it. Those are absolutely the X and Y models still. Do they really think we're so stupid that they can just lie to our faces like that?
My reading is that, if you've been a lifelong Pokémon fan, you've been routinely disappointed one way or another by the series. Maybe they removed a feature you really liked, or maybe the series went in a direction you didn't prefer, but chances are even the most faithful fans have been disappointed by decisions Game Freak has made.
But people overlook those disappointments because they love Pokémon. And maybe there are design decisions you don't like or features removed, but it's still Pokémon, and that was always enough to to look beyond the things you didn't like and focus on the things you did. After all, people play Pokémon in so many different ways. Maybe the things that meant a lot to you just weren't popular enough to justify. If you were going to stick with the series, you needed to make peace with the fact you wouldn't always get everything you wanted.
But this change is just so fundamental. It has enormous implications for almost every single kind of player. You can't look past it and say "well, at least it's still Pokémon" because this time the fundamental Pokémon experience, something you took for granted, the thing that always kept you grounded despite the other changes, has been compromised. So no matter what you were disappointed with previously, and however you made peace with that, now almost every type of Pokémon fan is unanimously disappointed at once.
In the past, when I was upset about a feature or a change, I just swallowed it and thought "it's not all about me." But this time, for once, it's about everybody. So everyone's just letting it out.
I don't know what goes into developing these games, but when dealing with translated interviews, it's important to consider everything paraphrasing, as something might be lost in translation. It's possible that they're not remodeling every Pokémon, also because that's Creatures Inc.'s job. But it might be a case of each Pokémon using specific shader settings to better represent their design and concept art. So it's no small task to go through each and every one of them, fine-tuning their graphics to what looks best for each. All of this might be getting simplified as "modeling".Did I misread, or did the Famitsu interview with Masuda say they were re-modeling every Pokemon? If so, I'm not seeing it. Those are absolutely the X and Y models still. Do they really think we're so stupid that they can just lie to our faces like that?
I mean, they did explain that it wasn't sustainable to keep supporting all Pokémon every game and they knew eventually they wouldn't be able to do it anymore. It looks like it was a case of them prioritizing other features over bringing over all Pokémon. The only thing they're not doing here is showing something to make up for that.They're not communicating it that way at all. I would expect that they would say "we know it might be disappointing for some fans but here's 10 reasons why this makes sense". It's kinda "yeah we're no longer doing that". The subtext is "you'll buy the games anyway".
Maybe they really are in a bad place right now
When is the company gonna step in and properly fund and staff the team then?
The contrast between Gamefreak's ambition of Pokemon as a game series and TPCI's ambition of it as a franchise is astronomical. TPCI is going nuts with trying to make SLEEP INTO ENTERTAINMENT meanwhile GF is unable to keep basic features of JRPGs, let alone support the pokemon they have created up until now.
To take it even further (while not entirely fair bit still the comparison can be made) is you look at Nintendo's games. All of their flagship franchises, Zelda, Mario, and to an extent Smash, are all blowing past previous heights of their respective series. How has GF not adapted to the standards of the rest of their direct contemporaries?
And who the fuck gives a shit about camping, hell even the Pokemon amie, it boosts your Pokemon up in battles and made them invincible, which was the annoying part.The idea that Gamefreak is creating new animations for this camping mechanic at the expense of half the roster over just reusing the perfectly-serviceable Refresh mechanic is infuriating.
Professor: "Oh my god, the ONE AND ONLY Rotom in ALL OF GALAR decided to live in your cell phone? Oh lucky you"
Those 10 Million sales from Let's Go sure took a hit on their finances huh?
Do you know how business works? The success of their games doesnt just magically get reinvested into the developer unless the people in charge make it happen
Not that I would have used Amie/Refresh anyway, but the boosts made me avoid it like the plague.And who the fuck gives a shit about camping, hell even the Pokemon amie, it boosts your Pokemon up in battles and made them invincible, which was the annoying part.
Believe my favorite is Roserade, which happened with Gen 6. I even booted up a copy of Platinum just to get a Budew into Soul Silver last year to have her.
The thing is, even if not a lot of people used bank to move their Pokemon, the ones that did bred those Pokemon and traded them and let everyone experience them.Have they ever released figures for Pokémon Bank? Because if it turns out only a small percentage of players actually bother transferring Pokémon across the games, I could imagine them deciding to put their focus elsewhere.
I like SM and skipped the Ultra games because they ruined the story. But otherwise they look mostly fine, even if they keep some problems SM has, like the meh map/level design.This just making me want to replay Ultra Moon. At least I know I'll be able to raise what I want there.
(I actually really enjoyed Ultra, dont look too deeply into this)
The Ultra games are good games. They're just disappointing in the story and amount of changes before Poni Island.This just making me want to replay Ultra Moon. At least I know I'll be able to raise what I want there.
(I actually really enjoyed Ultra, dont look too deeply into this)
SM has Poni island which is my favorite Area in the franchise. The other islands are just OK.My favorites are Heracross and Gardevoir, so I think they'll always be in. Feel bad for most of my other liked Pokémon like Lilligant, Mienshao, Liepard, etc.
I like SM and skipped the Ultra games because they ruined the story. But otherwise they look mostly fine, even if they keep some problems SM has, like the meh map/level design.
omg, I didn't realize the pop in was that bad.
Steelix just... appears. And it's really noticeable.
This just making me want to replay Ultra Moon. At least I know I'll be able to raise what I want there.
(I actually really enjoyed Ultra, dont look too deeply into this)
But if Roserade isn't in the Galar Dex then you still won't be able to transfer it into S/S
I like them all visually and how they make the world look lively. A few ones have nice design by themselves as well. What I don't like is how they're integrated in the world, they're basically different worlds not actually connected and that brings the whole thing down. It's cool to use surf and find the other islands, in SM you can't swim anywhere without rocks blocking you and you need to go through transition screens everytime you want to go to another island, it's lame.SM has Poni island which is my favorite Area in the franchise. The other islands are just OK.