• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Oct 25, 2017
2,899
Ontario
Depends on what you're criticizing though doesn't it? If you say that the messaging around this by the Dems is shit and they should do more to put Republicans on blast while continuing attemps to pass more comprehensive solutions then that's fine. If you think you could have somehow got a better deal by letting the GOP kill a more ambitious bill because you think they give a shit about optics which would have resulted in 0 coverage instead of the 20% we got then I don't know what to tell you.
the first one

the messaging that they already came out with from a political comms perspective is not setting them up well for if they do try to pass a more comprehensive solution. You have to lay the groundwork so the other side can't pain you into a corner

the reality is that dem leadership in the house just don't want to put that many corporations on blast, even during a time of national crisis
 

Dale Copper

Member
Apr 12, 2018
22,025
The bill also includes free coronavirus testing, even for the uninsured.

Also shores up food assistance for things like food banks, and to get food for 22 million children who get free or reduced price lunches.

Also prevents the work requirements for SNAP from going into effect during the pandemic.

Also bolsters unemployment insurance.

Fucking useless.
Truly useless....truly /sarcasm
 

JaseC64

Enlightened
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
11,008
Strong Island NY
Don't blame Pelosi--blame Mnuchin and republicans:



Read Tapper's entire thread. Republicans refused to vote for it without a cap. They were lucky to get anything.

Wait people on the left are blaming Pelosi/Dems for this fuckery? Have you guys been under a rock?

Not shocked Pelosi/Dems had to revise their original plan to compromise with Reps and get it passed by Trump.

Sure we can all be upset at all the parties involved but putting the blame on soley on Pelosi is stupid.

People originally were shocked about this being 'worked out with Reps' but as you can see, it had to be broken down to pass it with their support. I honestly would only be pissed at Reps as usual. Its because of them this bill is not better. As we all know, they care more about corporations than human lives. Though that tweet from Pelosi is likely trying to save some face on this thing.
 

Altairre

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,034
The bill also includes free coronavirus testing, even for the uninsured.

Also shores up food assistance for things like food banks, and to get food for 22 million children who get free or reduced price lunches.

Also prevents the work requirements for SNAP from going into effect during the pandemic.

Also bolsters unemployment insurance.

Fucking useless.
Might as well be a Republican bill.
 

Papajak

Member
Oct 27, 2017
190
All his career has been defined by doing the old "work across the isle" but exactly in this way: compromise, for the sake of having something to show, even if it ultimately the result may ended up not worth it.


In this particular case, Democrats should have done a very simple calculation: Do a full plan that involves all companies with large amount of workers; or let GOP/Trump absorb the full political cost of doing nothing. In election year.
But just like with the undocumented, they preferred to throw away the fight, even before starting. With, as expected, trash results.

It's not an either/or situation. There is nothing preventing Pelosi from passing a more comprehensive bill (in the house) AFTER this bill is signed into law. You get partial coverage AND put pressure on the republicans in the senate.
 

Seesaw15

Member
Oct 27, 2017
8,809
"Grow a spine." Sheesh.

The Dems trying to out big dog the Republicans isn't going to do anything. People have to actually vote.
 

Altairre

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,034
the first one

the messaging that they already came out with from a political comms perspective is not setting them up well for if they do try to pass a more comprehensive solution. You have to lay the groundwork so the other side can't pain you into a corner

the reality is that dem leadership in the house just don't want to put that many corporations on blast, even during a time of national crisis
I agree with that but a lot of people in this thread would rather pass nothing than this bill because they believe that Republicans can be bullied into a better solution RIGHT NOW. That's just not realistic. But yes, I think the messaging around this is weak and a valid point to criticize Dems on.
 

Ensorcell

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,441
How is the bill that was pass helping?




The bill they pass is allowing companies to do whatever they want to those who are sick or not doing enough. So...

They could just grow a spine and just call their bluff. Bring some exposure that every major company in this country are being greedy fucks and the Republicans are caping for them.

But nah, let's just worry about optics and looking good.

The bill helps SOME people. You're right in that I wished it helped more but attempting to stomp your feet and force the GOP 's hand when you don't have the leverage or the ear of the opposition is not a strategy, it's downright dangerous. It's not like further measures can't be taken in the future.
 

Sendero

Member
Oct 25, 2017
896
Do you people even READ what you're saying? The GOP/Trump absorbing the full political costs does FUCK ALL to help Americans and the stopping of this virus. The bill that the Democrats originally presented, which was significantly better, was chipped away by Republicans for it to even get through. If they didn't, we would have nothing at all.

"Nothing" is not an option when we're talking about a pandemic affecting the lives of every single one of us. This isn't a game and you all are treating it that way.
That's unfortunately, the exact same train of thought these politicians do.

First of all, that's untrue: The moment Pelosi put Trump as the responsible of the shutdown in the media last year, things started rolling. He is a narcissist, can't help it.
But it's not automatic, needs a proper PR strategy so it actually hurts him. Once again, it's election year.

Second: Dems have to target Republicans, as individuals. You may think they won't care, but there is a vast difference between pressing for impeachment, than putting them in the spot for publicly vote against something that otherwise will have severe consecuences for their own constituency - in the short term.

But above all of this: There was no actual meaningful negotiation. Never pushed for anything publicly, not even for a few days.
That's pre-capitulation. And now, it will be more difficult to get something else. It's up for you to decide if that's the path you want to follow.
 

JaseC64

Enlightened
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
11,008
Strong Island NY
Might as well be a Republican bill.
Republicans actually dont give a fuck about anything going on right now as they think it's a hoax. So yea they wouldn't even pass the bare minimum without the Dems insisting these things.

I think a lot of you are upset which is understandable but that shit is being placed on the wrong people. Pelosi is not the best but I know she is trying her best which what she has available. Remember she had to deal with a Rep Senate and supreme leader idiot.
 

Kotto

CEO of Traphouse Networks
Member
Nov 3, 2017
4,466
"Grow a spine." Sheesh.

The Dems trying to out big dog the Republicans isn't going to do anything. People have to actually vote.
Yes, grow a fucking spine. Call their bluff. This shit affects literally everyone and only 20 percent are covered for paid sick leave?

They better hope this doesn't get any more out of hand.

The bill helps SOME people. You're right in that I wished it helped more but attempting to stomp your feet and force the GOP 's hand when you don't have the leverage or the ear of the opposition is not a strategy, it's downright dangerous. It's not like further measures can't be taken in the future.

A very small "some" too.

I get trying to pass something but Dems need to understand a line between compromising and just bending the knee.
 

excelsiorlef

Bad Praxis
Member
Oct 25, 2017
73,316
Dems should have forced the GOP to be held responsible instead of passing something that isn't perfect

 
Oct 28, 2017
6,207
Which is why you need to do everything you can to slow the spread NOW. We've had a couple of threads about the GOP blocking similar bills already, they have literally shown that they don't give a shit despite the crisis. Dragging this out for weeks instead of getting 20% coverage now is not the play here.
We dont have enough tests. Money and bills alone wont stop the spread. Testing and quarantines and taking preventitive measures will. The bills are supposed to help the people dealing with the virus and a lack of work.
When it comes to passing a bill with respect to Coronavirus, I need someone to tell me what power they think Democrats have when legitimately evil Republicans control the senate and the presidency - let alone in a situation that's the very definition of time sensitive?
The administration bungled the response. They had WHO tests 3 months ago and ignored them. Trump fired the NSC pandemic response team. South Korea has handled the response better than out government. More people will get sick and die. That includes the Republican base. Democrats have a lot of leverage here if they are willing to exploit it. They aren't though.

They aren't even railing against the Senate for going home for the weekend while this crisis gets worse and they are still working. Why aren't they crying to the heavens: Where are the tests? Why are we so ill prepared?

The silence is deafening.
 

Altairre

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,034
Republicans actually dont give a fuck about anything going on right now as they think it's a hoax. So yea they wouldn't even pass the bare minimum without the Dems insisting these things.

I think a lot of you are upset which is understandable but that shit is being placed on the wrong people. Pelosi is not the best but I know she is trying her best which what she has available. Remember she had to deal with a Rep Senate and supreme leader idiot.
Mine was a sarcastic reply.
 
Oct 25, 2017
3,215
My wife works in a salon and her pay is 100% commission. Is there anything in this bill to help her get a paycheck for the next 2 weeks?
 

RDreamer

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,102
Yes, grow a fucking spine. Call their bluff. This shit affects literally everyone and only 20 percent are covered for paid sick leave?

They better hope this doesn't get any more out of hand.

I get trying to pass something but Dems need to understand a line between compromising and just bending the knee.
What gives you the impression republicans are bluffing? They don't want to do these things.

A bill that's like 95% what democrats want and doesn't have the biggest thing the republican president pushed for is bending the knee?
 
Oct 25, 2017
2,899
Ontario
I agree with that but a lot of people in this thread would rather pass nothing than this bill because they believe that Republicans can be bullied into a better solution RIGHT NOW. That's just not realistic. But yes, I think the messaging around this is weak and a valid point to criticize Dems on.
i think that the failure of messaging and the people who are coming in with hot takes are more then a little bit related

it is the responsibility of elected democrats to not just do good things but effectively sell current and potential voters on their values. Sometimes that requires stronger action then others

I'm not saying that you are the one doing this but some of the milder responses in here have been misconstrued and characterized as hot takes by people ignorant of the politcal system.


that's most certainly not the case
 

corasaur

Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,988
When legislation in the US has to go through a Republican senate to become law, that kind of limits what the bill can look like.

Fighting tooth and nail for a better world means seizing the opportunity to help tens of millions asap when it pops up.

Screaming your ideal version of a bill slightly more loudly is a useless tactic for winning over a group of votes whose ideal outcome is nothing happening. Spending weeks letting people starve and go bankrupt on the hopes that McConnell eventually grows a soul and supports a more sweeping bill would be super super fucked up if we can realistically pass some relief immediately.
 

lush

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,802
Knoxville, TN
Couldn't possibly be those strong, white, daddy Republicans that have majority control could it OP? Nah, let's blame the only party that actually gives a shit about this crisis or anything for that matter. Not just that, let's blame the female, minority leader that's probably the only reason anything got passed. Meanwhile from the top down this is a hoax until two days ago for the majority party and all its little lemmings.

Your stupid fucking take is why this country is where it is right now. Disingenuous bullshit seemingly designed to sew apathy and push "both sides."
 

Zombegoast

Member
Oct 30, 2017
14,224
What? The people that know how shitty the government is are the ones that KNOW we have to compromise to get anything done. No one is happy that we have to compromise, we're just acknowledging that it's the only way to get things done at the moment. Vote republicans out to change that. The amount of power Pelosi has is based on how we vote.

Compromising is what keeping the Republican party to have any form of power and weaponize it during the election.

Accepting this means we haven't learned nothing in the past 40 years and we should just be happy.
 

Bio

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,370
Denver, Colorado
Yeah they should be like bernie sanders and die on his high horse while actual people's lives get worse! That'll show the the establishment.

LMAO because current democratic leadership has given us such a wonderful modern American full of wealth equality and accessible healthcare and workers' rights and effective climate policy. You should keep voting for them; they've totally earned it.
 

metalslimer

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
9,558
People continue to be idiotic and forget that fucking republicans control both the senate and presidency. I dunno maybe if you actually went out and voted there would be a stronger bill
 

Quixzlizx

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,591
You should make sure not to vote in November to punish Pelosi and the establishment Democrats for their wicked ways.

Our socialist utopia awaits.
 

Altairre

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,034
i think that the failure of messaging and the people who are coming in with hot takes are more then a little bit related

it is the responsibility of elected democrats to not just do good things but effectively sell current and potential voters on their values. Sometimes that requires stronger action then others

I'm not saying that you are the one doing this but some of the milder responses in here have been misconstrued and characterized as hot takes by people ignorant of the politcal system.


that's most certainly not the case
That is fair and yet I do think it is important to channel criticism in a way that's more difficult to shoot down i.e. direct it at the actual issue. I won't disagree that poor messaging makes it more difficult to do that though.
Compromising is what keeping the Republican party to have any form of power and weaponize it during the election.

Accepting this means we haven't learned nothing in the past 40 years and we should just be happy.
So you just get nothing done instead?
 

Kotto

CEO of Traphouse Networks
Member
Nov 3, 2017
4,466
What gives you the impression republicans are bluffing? They don't want to do these things.

A bill that's like 95% what democrats want and doesn't have the biggest thing the republican president pushed for is bending the knee?
Yes, it still is.

Yea, they had a plan to include everyone, but to get them to allow every major employer to avoid paid sick leave is still wild regardless of how many times you guys mention they hold the Senate/WH.
 

UF_C

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,347
Can we get a title change here? First, it's not accurate and second, it creates a false argument that Pelosi is responsible for the bill.
 

Mr. Keith

Member
Oct 31, 2017
1,940
The people that would have everything burn rather than compromise need to take a step back and look at reality.

We do not have the leverage you think we do. If we just walk away when we can't get the perfect bill it hurts everyone. It's not gonna be a gotcha against Republicans.
 

RDreamer

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,102
Yes, it still is.

Yea, they had a plan to include everyone, but to get them to allow every major employer to avoid paid sick leave is still wild regardless of how many times you guys mention they hold the Senate/WH.
Yeah it's wild that republicans are that fucking bad but here we are.
 
Oct 28, 2017
6,207
Yes, which is why 20% are better for slowing the spread than 0.
Is it really though when a single person could infect 50? It will only be effective if they provide a test for every single person in the nation. We don't have enough tests yet. It's a major failing.

The people that would have everything burn rather than compromise need to take a step back and look at reality.

We do not have the leverage you think we do. If we just walk away when we can't get the perfect bill it hurts everyone. It's not gonna be a gotcha against Republicans.
Walk away? No need. Pass a bill giving the people what they need and dump it in Mitch's lap. Let him explain why the people can't have that.
 

Carnby

Member
Oct 25, 2017
12,236
So is sick coverage for all the "ideological wish list" McConnell is talking about in this bill?

 
Last edited:

dingobingo

Banned
Dec 5, 2017
2,099
I just dont understand this is how it should work. Pelosi has the majority In the house, provide everything that makes sense and is rational. No pork at all. Then announce we have passed a bill outlining everything in the bill. Then walk away. Give the Republicans no say and due to no pork they cannot refute or cry. The monkey would be on thier back then blast the media with news on what's in the bill. Its that fking simple. To the people that say we must remove partisan bickering and that this is a crisis. The country is fked passing this in a day or a week wont matter let them own this to thier fking graves
 

Mariolee

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
10,307
Have people saying Democrats have some sort of political leverage watched the last four years of Republicans doing the politically worst things of all time and constantly getting away with it?
 

Renna Hazel

Member
Oct 27, 2017
11,556
Compromising is what keeping the Republican party to have any form of power and weaponize it during the election.

Accepting this means we haven't learned nothing in the past 40 years and we should just be happy.
Yeah but when something goes wrong and people are dying the GOP doesn't care. They'd have preferred no bill get passed, and they'd just blame the dems. I'm not in favor of helping no one for the sake of scoring political points that likely wont be scored anyway.

The GOP will lose power when they're voted out of office.
 

lush

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,802
Knoxville, TN
Pelosi herself even said the focus for this first emergency package was on "testing, testing, testing."

"As the Senate works to pass this bill, the House will begin work on a third emergency response package to protect the health, economic security and well-being of the American people. We will do so in continued consultation with scientists, researchers, health care professionals, public health officials and community leaders, so that we can craft the most effective, evidence-based response."

You "the Democrats compromised" people don't realize that the Republicans don't want to pass anything. The alternative was hoping the Republican Senate doesn't go on recess and maybe, eventually passes their payroll tax cuts. Yippee!
 
Oct 27, 2017
17,973
That's unfortunately, the exact same train of thought these politicians do.

First of all, that's untrue: The moment Pelosi put Trump as the responsible of the shutdown in the media last year, things started rolling. He is a narcissist, can't help it.
But it's not automatic, needs a proper PR strategy so it actually hurts him. Once again, it's election year.

Second: Dems have to target Republicans, as individuals. You may think they won't care, but there is a vast difference between pressing for impeachment, than putting them in the spot for publicly vote against something that otherwise will have severe consecuences for their own constituency.

But above all of this: There was no actual meaningful negotiation. Never pushed for anything publicly, not even for a few days.
That's pre-capitulation. And now, it will be more difficult to get something else. It's up for you to decide if that's the path you want to follow.

Except that the virus' progression path is clear and isn't giving anyone a choice of path except to follow it and end up with masses of cases and death, or take measures to encourage as many people as possible to social distance with financial support.

This thread is way more politics-as-usual than anything Pelosi has been engaging in the past week or so. She even said there are things that need to be worked on that require the full debate cycle of the House, which would hold up any immediate measures like this. Not to mention the previous 275+ bills the Senate won't even take up. And the coronavirus relief bills that McConnell has already decried on the floor of the Senate. Making the perfect the enemy of the good, against a virus that doesn't give a shit either way, won't change the path the curve is tracing.

The only ones that can take quicker action right now are corporations who can enact their own benefits, the Trump admin, the Senate, and state governors once they receive waivers from the Trump admin to do so. What are they all doing? In your state, do you even know?
 

RDreamer

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,102
Pelosi's Coronavirus bill is fucking useless
One of the dumbest things you could type out, honestly. She's one of the most effective legislators the democrats and liberals in general have. She's great at her job, which isn't to be an ideologue, it's to represent and lead the democrats in the house. All of them.
 

Deleted member 17402

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
7,125
These threads are so god damn annoying. Full of meaningless platitudes that suggest just because you imagine it, it can happen. Mother fuckers, we work with a GOP-controlled government. We're lucky to get anything passed through the Senate and Trump. Y'all with the pie-in-the-sky resolutions that aim to resolve either EVERYTHING or nothing at all in one legislative push are idealistically dumb as fuck, and it's infuriating.
 
Oct 27, 2017
2,165
It's not useless, but it's really just about the bare minimum a country like the U.S. can be doing at a time like this. Literally one step above doing absolutely nothing. At least it helps some people I guess.
 

lush

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,802
Knoxville, TN
Walk away? No need. Pass a bill giving the people what they need and dump it in Mitch's lap. Let him explain why the people can't have that.
Lmao, because the parties are treated even remotely the same as evidenced by this thread. The bill would join the others sitting on the pile of House passed bills that won't even be brought to the floor as the media says jackshit about it. Meanwhile people still would be dropping hot takes on Pelosi on social media blaming her.

It took everything to get a bill guaranteeing everyone could get tested to pass and even then it was just barely.