I'm sorry, was I not clear enough? I wasn't defending the poor build quality issues that a lot of people are having with their switch pro controller d-pads.
My argument is that I believe people tend to blowup their use and/or importance of the d-pad.
For what reason, im not sure, maybe to appear interesting, or to let others know their down with playing the "retro' way, or maybe it's just because people like to complain and blow up anything to create drama( my money's on the later).
As I said I grew up playing on d-pads, NES,SNES,PlayStation, and I really don't ever use the d-pad, whether it be a 3d or 2d game. I'm sure there could be some that prefer them for 2d games, but I don't believe the majority or even a significant portion of the gaming audience uses them.