• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Smoothcb

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,080
And it will. Of course it will.



You said it all here. 100% it's disruptive. And it won't accomplish anything other than virtue signal and provoke China to tighten its grip on Taiwan. They've BEEN doing this.
But you need to stand up to bullies or they'll keep getting more aggressive (USA included)
 

Aztechnology

Community Resettler
Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
14,134
It was really interesting (as someone who's learning mandarin) that I thought pinyin was some special way for English speakers to learn Chinese and was the cheaters way not used by locals etc and it is… but it's also something that came about as a way of basically advancing/modernizing their technology and became standardized amongst most people? because China and Taiwan's character systems are so vast/complicated. So when Mao and his party pushed for a new romanized way of translating Chinese characters for computing, specifically keyboards. Taiwan recognized the importance/significance of the idea, but absolutely understandably hated Mao. So they have their own version called Zhuyin (feel free to correct me if that's not entirely correct) I'm not sure how common pinyin has become in Taiwan. I was just interested to learn that history and the importance of that component of language to the Chinese and taiwanese's typing skills (faster than pretty much any other as they started developing T9 type capabilities long before the U.S etc) and culturally, socially etc. But that effectively the language itself too was split off because of the desire for distinction/independence between Communist China and Taiwan.

(Again really sorry if I'm off on anything, do not mind being straightened out or clarified on this. May also not be the right place/time but I think it kind of speaks to the independence of Taiwan a bit).
 

Foltzie

One Winged Slayer
The Fallen
Oct 26, 2017
6,780
Oh boyyyyy lol...hard to believe this isn't a coordinated effort by the White House. Xi prob raging reading this
I mean, the travel had to go through The White House, as they provide the military escort, so despite statements downplaying support they backed Pelosi's move.
 

giallo

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,220
Seoul
From what I've read (I'm not actually in Taiwan at the moment, although I've got a Gold Card visa & I'm trying to get my family visas as well), most people in Taiwan don't care. High ranking politicians from various countries come to Taiwan periodically, China postures, nothing happens. They don't see this as anything different.

From what I understand, not only do most people not care, but a lot of people in Taiwan don't even know anything is happening. It's that insignificant.

I'm not so sure that's true. My wife is glued to her phone atm (she watched the plane land), and it seems like it's really big news in Taiwan media.
 

werezompire

Zeboyd Games
Verified
Oct 26, 2017
11,318
It was really interesting (as someone who's learning mandarin) that I thought pinyin was some special way for English speakers to learn Chinese and was the cheaters way not used by locals etc and it is… but it's also something that came about as a way of basically advancing/modernizing their technology and became standardized amongst most people? because China and Taiwan's character systems are so vast/complicated. So when Mao and his party pushed for a new romanized way of translating Chinese characters for computing, specifically keyboards. Taiwan recognized the importance/significance of the idea, but absolutely understandably hated Mao. So they have their own version called Zhuyin (feel free to correct me if that's not entirely correct) I'm not sure how common pinyin has become in Taiwan. I was just interested to learn that history and the importance of that component of language to the Chinese and taiwanese's typing skills (faster than pretty much any other as they started developing T9 type capabilities long before the U.S etc) and culturally, socially etc. But that effectively the language itself too was split off because of the desire for distinction/independence between Communist China and Taiwan.

Zhuyin is used to teach children in Taiwan (generally right next to the actual Mandarin character). However, I have seen pinyin used in stuff like street signs.

I know that Taiwan has said that they want to transition to having English be an official national language in a few years (along with Mandarin).

I'm not so sure that's true. My wife is glued to her phone atm (she watched the plane land), and it seems like it's really big news in Taiwan media.

I'm just getting this from my wife who is tuned in to Taiwan social media (mostly expats in the area, she's learning Mandarin, but not at the level she can read social media). This was also a day or two ago, so it'd be understandable that things could be totally different now that it's actually happening.

Wait what? Sources please. China and Japan/other neighbors have pretty normal trade relationships right now, was my impression. It ain't North Korea. In fact Mainland and Taiwan have been pumping up trade in the past decade. (I am from China, but have been out of the country for a decade +, never heard of this analysis)

asia.nikkei.com

China bans thousands of Taiwan food imports as Pelosi trip riles

Halt on everything from vegetables to baby food comes as Sino-U.S. tensions soar

Stuff like this has been going on for a while - they banned pineapple a while back which was a big deal, because Japan responded by saying they'd buy all the pineapple Taiwan wanted to sell them.

Apparently, they just banned Taiwanese chips and so they're lots of jokes about how the Chinese tech industry is going to be demolished. Mind you, they banned chips that you eat, so the jokes are about how all those Chinese programmers aren't going to be able to function because they won't have anything to snack on while they're working.
 

Ceerious

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,192
Asian
It was really interesting (as someone who's learning mandarin) that I thought pinyin was some special way for English speakers to learn Chinese and was the cheaters way not used by locals etc and it is… but it's also something that came about as a way of basically advancing/modernizing their technology and became standardized amongst most people? because China and Taiwan's character systems are so vast/complicated. So when Mao and his party pushed for a new romanized way of translating Chinese characters for computing, specifically keyboards. Taiwan recognized the importance/significance of the idea, but absolutely understandably hated Mao. So they have their own version called Zhuyin (feel free to correct me if that's not entirely correct) I'm not sure how common pinyin has become in Taiwan. I was just interested to learn that history and the importance of that component of language to the Chinese and taiwanese's typing skills (faster than pretty much any other as they started developing T9 type capabilities long before the U.S etc) and culturally, socially etc. But that effectively the language itself too was split off because of the desire for distinction/independence between Communist China and Taiwan.

(Again really sorry if I'm off on anything, do not mind being straightened out or clarified on this. May also not be the right place/time but I think it kind of speaks to the independence of Taiwan a bit).


You don't need to be sorry, it's messy history

Chinese language originally had no phonetic notation system. Chinese scholars tried to invent such a system since late 19 century so people can have better education. zhuyin(注音) system was invented in 1908 by famous scholar Zhang Taiyan. Government of ROC adapted his system, made some revisions and made it official phonetic notation system for Chinese.

After civil war, both ROC and PRC continued to use this system. But PRC developed their own 'Pinyin(拼音)' system in 1950s and ban the use of Zhuyin. Taiwan, as ROC's successor, has been using Zhuyin until this day.
 

Mabase

Member
Oct 29, 2017
1,038
I work in a Taiwan research institute. It's a fantastic place that I love dearly, a consolidated democracy with progressive politics for East Asia in many regards. If it was a realistic possibility, I'd love for Taiwan to be an independent country. But it's not possible when the PRC is your neighbor and threatening your right to exist.

Therefore, I was hoping Pelosi would not make the trip. I am not sure if you all are aware, but Xi Jinping is in an extremly difficult spot right now. The economy has been close to a recession, he's not getting Covid sorted and he wants his tenure to be extended in autumn. In China, there has been decades of state-induced nationalistic education in their schools, and many of these are now very vocal and extremly loud nationalists pressuring the government to take a hard stance and act (my Chinese colleague just texted me that the nationalists are already heavily attacking Xi that he didn't prevent the trip from happening). Basically, the Communist Party cannot back down in conflicts even if it wanted to. Leaders under pressure can make very bad decisions in foreign policy.

I understand that Taipeh feels like it must fight back against the diplomatic isolation that China is continuing to pursue. I was in favor of the clear commitment the US gave for Taiwan's safety earlier this year. But I don't want this great island to end up like Hongkong, and today has made it more likely, and that's why I fear this was not the right move.

I think sometimes in these times we are so keen in setting signals (of support etc.) that we can forget if the decisions in the long-term will really achieve what we want, which in this case is a continuously free Taiwan.

I completely agree. I don't understand Pelosi's timing.
 

sbenji

Member
Jul 25, 2019
1,875
Also, the really funny/sad thing is that China could probably completely save their economy right now just by recognizing Taiwan's status as an independent country. The huge influx of trade from Taiwan, Japan, and other countries in the region would be a huge boon to them.

China will never recognize Taiwan. The CCP have been literally fighting the precursor (Guomindang) to Taiwan since their founding. They view it as a fulfillment of the revolution.
 

EntelechyFuff

Saw the truth behind the copied door
Member
Nov 19, 2019
10,133
I work in a Taiwan research institute. It's a fantastic place that I love dearly, a consolidated democracy with progressive politics for East Asia in many regards. If it was a realistic possibility, I'd love for Taiwan to be an independent country. But it's not possible when the PRC is your neighbor and threatening your right to exist.

Therefore, I was hoping Pelosi would not make the trip. I am not sure if you all are aware, but Xi Jinping is in an extremly difficult spot right now. The economy has been close to a recession, he's not getting Covid sorted and he wants his tenure to be extended in autumn. In China, there has been decades of state-induced nationalistic education in their schools, and many of these are now very vocal and extremly loud nationalists pressuring the government to take a hard stance and act (my Chinese colleague just texted me that the nationalists are already heavily attacking Xi that he didn't prevent the trip from happening). Basically, the Communist Party cannot back down in conflicts even if it wanted to. Leaders under pressure can make very bad decisions in foreign policy.

I understand that Taipeh feels like it must fight back against the diplomatic isolation that China is continuing to pursue. I was in favor of the clear commitment the US gave for Taiwan's safety earlier this year. But I don't want this great island to end up like Hongkong, and today has made it more likely, and that's why I fear this was not the right move.

I think sometimes in these times we are so keen in setting signals (of support etc.) that we can forget if the decisions in the long-term will really achieve what we want, which in this case is a continuously free Taiwan.

Last thoughts: After China's threats over the past few days, Pelosi could not back down anymore. That's also true but I'm not talking about that but the decision per se.
Did what happened in Hong Kong occur as a result of some overt show of Western solidarity?

Genuine question.
 

Buckle

Member
Oct 27, 2017
41,039
Good on her. More politicians need to start recognizing Taiwan as an ally and a country in the coming years as the CCP's mask will continue to slip on the global stage like Putin's.

Time to stop to pretending China is just another global partner and solidify real alliances more clearly.

Get ahead of things rather than act caught off guard when they invade Taiwan and follow in the footsteps of their russian friends with war crimes and inhumanity.
 

Aske

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
5,573
Canadia
I hate and am terrified of war, but I absolutely think this was the right thing to do. No CCP, you don't own Taiwan, and we are firmly slamming the door that you feel Putin left open for you.
 

TheHunter

Bold Bur3n Wrangler
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
25,774
I work in a Taiwan research institute. It's a fantastic place that I love dearly, a consolidated democracy with progressive politics for East Asia in many regards. If it was a realistic possibility, I'd love for Taiwan to be an independent country. But it's not possible when the PRC is your neighbor and threatening your right to exist.

Therefore, I was hoping Pelosi would not make the trip. I am not sure if you all are aware, but Xi Jinping is in an extremly difficult spot right now. The economy has been close to a recession, he's not getting Covid sorted and he wants his tenure to be extended in autumn. In China, there has been decades of state-induced nationalistic education in their schools, and many of these are now very vocal and extremly loud nationalists pressuring the government to take a hard stance and act (my Chinese colleague just texted me that the nationalists are already heavily attacking Xi that he didn't prevent the trip from happening). Basically, the Communist Party cannot back down in conflicts even if it wanted to. Leaders under pressure can make very bad decisions in foreign policy.

I understand that Taipeh feels like it must fight back against the diplomatic isolation that China is continuing to pursue. I was in favor of the clear commitment the US gave for Taiwan's safety earlier this year. But I don't want this great island to end up like Hongkong, and today has made it more likely, and that's why I fear this was not the right move.

I think sometimes in these times we are so keen in setting signals (of support etc.) that we can forget if the decisions in the long-term will really achieve what we want, which in this case is a continuously free Taiwan.

Last thoughts: After China's threats over the past few days, Pelosi could not back down anymore. That's also true but I'm not talking about that but the decision per se.
If we assume post Ukraine invasion that China is considering an invasion would a preemptive sign of unwavering support to head it off not be a good idea?
 

SilentPanda

Member
Nov 6, 2017
13,632
Earth
Is there anything on the perspective from the people of Taiwan?

Its just another politician from another country coming to say they support Taiwan, but wont recognize us as a independent country, and China will fly plane to our ADZ and ban some product and Japan or Korea will buy it.
And its fun to see the little pink going crazy on their universe.

Were more focused on other thing, this was more of a bet money if she land or not.
 

Buckle

Member
Oct 27, 2017
41,039
Its just another politician from another country coming to say they support Taiwan, but wont recognize us as a independent country, and China will fly plane to our ADZ and ban some product and Japan or Korea will buy it.
And its fun to see the little pink going crazy on their universe.

Were more focused on other thing, this was more of a bet money if she land or not.
Little pink?
 

GYODX

Member
Oct 27, 2017
7,233
America has one national sport.

And that is, getting the most expensive stick possible and using it to poke sleeping bears, and then kneeling in front of a flag in solemn remembrance of all the 18 year olds it sent to die against the enraged bear they claim to have nothing to do with.
Fucking stupid take
 

TheHunter

Bold Bur3n Wrangler
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
25,774
It has been official state policy and the US has supported tons of war crimes for a very long time. The Jarkata Method shows this.



The US has annexed territory many times. It still has colonies.
In the modern era.

Post Vietnam saw a rapid change in how we conduct war. If you can't see that perhaps educated yourself and follow what is happening in Ukraine thord.
 

GYODX

Member
Oct 27, 2017
7,233
I see the trolls have succeeded in derailing the thread and making it about US invasions when that has nothing to do with the topic at hand.
 

Thordinson

Member
Aug 1, 2018
17,908
No, I don't. What are you referring to?

Marshall Islands were annexed then.

I see the trolls have succeeded in derailing the thread and making it about US invasions when that has nothing to do with the topic at hand.

Same with folks bringing up Russia too, yes?

In the modern era.

Post Vietnam saw a rapid change in how we conduct war. If you can't see that perhaps educated yourself and follow what is happening in Ukraine thord.

I won't deny there was a change but if you don't think America still doesn't commit nor encourage other countries to commit war crimes then I'm not sure what to tell you.

Yes, the US is not currently doing the exact same thing that Russia is currently doing. That's a given.
 

Deleted member 22750

Oct 28, 2017
13,267
Nancy should stick to juking the stock market, taking lobbyists money, and lying to her constituents.

For context here it's not so much I hate her as it has to do with America falling apart and she has a job here to try to fix things. She can make comments about her support from here. While she does her job. While her constituents are homeless and dying.
 
Last edited:

TheHunter

Bold Bur3n Wrangler
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
25,774
Marshall Islands were annexed then.



Same with folks bringing up Russia too, yes?



I won't deny there was a change but if you don't think America still doesn't commit nor encourage other countries to commit war crimes then I'm not sure what to tell you.

Yes, the US is not currently doing the exact same thing that Russia is currently doing. That's a given.
So...you agree there's a difference between Russia and the US!
 

Deleted member 43

Account closed at user request
Banned
Oct 24, 2017
9,271
Marshall Islands were annexed then.
No, they weren't. That's a complete misunderstanding of the situation.

The Marshall Islands, along with Micronesia, Palau, and the Northern Mariana Islands, were part of the of the Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands, a UN trust territory of former Imperial Japanese islands overseen by the US after WWII. Those lands were never annexed by the US, and when the TT was dissolved each part voted on their political status. The Marshall Islands, Micronesia, and Palau voted for independence (which they have), and the NMI voted to become a territory of the United States.

Again, none of them were forcibly annexed into the USA.
 

Biske

Member
Nov 11, 2017
8,255
I love how every single thread about important international politics somehow transforms into people cynically dropping by making quips about one minor US domestic thing or another.

Guys, I assure you, US strategic policy in the Pacific has nothing to do with student debts or whatever.

It's also stupid because it doesn't actually take attention away from anything. Our right wing media and the Republican outrage machine marches on and dictates the conversation literally regardless of what is actually happening in the world.
 

Aztechnology

Community Resettler
Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
14,134
You don't need to be sorry, it's messy history

Chinese language originally had no phonetic notation system. Chinese scholars tried to invent such a system since late 19 century so people can have better education. zhuyin(注音) system was invented in 1908 by famous scholar Zhang Taiyan. Government of ROC adapted his system, made some revisions and made it official phonetic notation system for Chinese.

After civil war, both ROC and PRC continued to use this system. But PRC developed their own 'Pinyin(拼音)' system in 1950s and ban the use of Zhuyin. Taiwan, as ROC's successor, has been using Zhuyin until this day.
Thanks for the clarification. It was really fascinating to learn about that shift. Like I said I kept thinking, oh I'm learning incorrectly because it's the "convenient" but shortcut way. Learning that while that is true, it's also the current way of learning for native people as well. How much of the part about shifting to being able to use it for keyboards is true?
 

Sobriquet

The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
9,831
Wilmington, NC
It's also stupid because it doesn't actually take attention away from anything. Our right wing media and the Republican outrage machine marches on and dictates the conversation literally regardless of what is actually happening in the world.
I"m actually curious what the right-wing media is saying about this (but am not going to watch/read to find out). Theoretically they should be for this visit, and half of the Republican Senators support it publicly. But on the other hand ... Pelosi.
 

kazinova

Member
Oct 27, 2017
935
User Warned (Permanent Thread Ban): Low-effort post, Ageism commentary
I always feel two conflicting things about this type of story:
1. Do not bend to bullies, Taiwan is independent, deal with it
2. Why does someone 10+ years past her expiration date get to play brinksmanship with a nuclear power?
 

Deleted member 12867

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,623
I see the 'everything would be great if we just appeased bullies' takes have started
It happens every time.

I"m actually curious what the right-wing media is saying about this (but am not going to watch/read to find out). Theoretically they should be for this visit, and half of the Republican Senators support it publicly. But on the other hand ... Pelosi.
I'm betting they don't talk about it very much unless China does something they can scare their viewers with.