I have a sheet with games that I finish and I do score by them but not in numbers.
I classify in classic, excellent, good, mediocre and bad.
If it was in number, probably the only 10 would be the last of us 2 this gen but my top 5 this gen all with classic score were:
1 the last of us 2
2 god of war
3 red dead redemption 2
4 uncharted 4
5 spider man PS4