This point about his videos being negative is one often raised in Jimquistion topics, or when his impressions are posted.
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Mr Negative (Jimquistion)
- Thread starter It’s Time To Go
- Start date
This point about his videos being negative is one often raised in Jimquistion topics, or when his impressions are posted.
I don't care about Sterling's videos being "negative" - the industry's media could use more skepticism and questioning. I do care that a lot of his videos seem to endlessly retread the same terrain, and some of his sourcing/research can be very thin (which he tends to wallpaper over through sheer, overwhelmingly self-righteous rhetoric).
I also find his overall presentation gimmick to be unamusing - the lectern, the glasses, the authoritarian motif, the Boglins and other 90s toys. But that's just personal taste.
He's not wrong that people crave negative content though. It's the reason people read tabloids, love reviews that "savage" the thing being reviewed, and so on. As Anton Ego said in Ratatouille - negative criticism is fun to write, and to read.
I also find his overall presentation gimmick to be unamusing - the lectern, the glasses, the authoritarian motif, the Boglins and other 90s toys. But that's just personal taste.
He's not wrong that people crave negative content though. It's the reason people read tabloids, love reviews that "savage" the thing being reviewed, and so on. As Anton Ego said in Ratatouille - negative criticism is fun to write, and to read.
The sad part is, he's absolutely right. There are several youtube channels I'm subscribed too, including Jim's, and I often ignore videos that aren't relevant to my interest.
Case in point I'm subscribed to CarlSagan42's channel for his amazing Mario Maker content. His 3 lowest performing videos in the past year or so were a hour long speech he gave at some event, a playthrough of man of medan, and a playthrough of Detroit become human. His only off brand thing that did well was Untitled Goose Game which he made during the peak of UGG's popularity, and I bet you the stats would show that video was watched little by his regulars and more by people looking for UGG content.
Specifically to Jim I usually don't watch his Jimpression videos because they're kinda of rambling train of thoughts unless I know for sure it's gonna be an angry shit on game fest. I listening to his podcast where Laura & Conrad are able to ask him questions or give their own opinions which imo is a better way of hearing about good games (in his opinion) like Man of Medan, Children of Morta, or Disco Elysium.
I do enjoy Jim's positive content Jimquisitions, but I'll admit I'm more likely to skip a positive video then a negative one.
Case in point I'm subscribed to CarlSagan42's channel for his amazing Mario Maker content. His 3 lowest performing videos in the past year or so were a hour long speech he gave at some event, a playthrough of man of medan, and a playthrough of Detroit become human. His only off brand thing that did well was Untitled Goose Game which he made during the peak of UGG's popularity, and I bet you the stats would show that video was watched little by his regulars and more by people looking for UGG content.
Specifically to Jim I usually don't watch his Jimpression videos because they're kinda of rambling train of thoughts unless I know for sure it's gonna be an angry shit on game fest. I listening to his podcast where Laura & Conrad are able to ask him questions or give their own opinions which imo is a better way of hearing about good games (in his opinion) like Man of Medan, Children of Morta, or Disco Elysium.
I do enjoy Jim's positive content Jimquisitions, but I'll admit I'm more likely to skip a positive video then a negative one.
Yea,this forum is the same.The tiniest piece of bad news results in huge long threads of people piling in,people love being negative on the internet.
Just look at the recent PS5 specs threads for a good example,lol.
Just look at the recent PS5 specs threads for a good example,lol.
At this point Jim has created such a compelling (for many) heel-like character that it doesn't surprise me that his primary audience tunes in for his scathing takes.*
People didn't watch Randy Savage or Ric Flair cut promos about not doing drugs or eating their vitamins. They watched to hear about tigers swimming in their bloodstreams and how big their houses were. 😉
(*character aside, I still feel Jim regularly touches on things that deserve to be addressed and criticized, so I'm certainly not saying the only worth in his videos are entertaining hot takes)
People didn't watch Randy Savage or Ric Flair cut promos about not doing drugs or eating their vitamins. They watched to hear about tigers swimming in their bloodstreams and how big their houses were. 😉
(*character aside, I still feel Jim regularly touches on things that deserve to be addressed and criticized, so I'm certainly not saying the only worth in his videos are entertaining hot takes)
The frustrating thing about the games industry is that many people place themselves on teams or they have certain publishers & developers that they deem untouchable. So when people like Jim rightfully criticize bullshit in the industry ... if it falls under the umbrella of a fanboy's untouchable list, the conversation turns into a pointless argument as the defense force is unwilling to acknowledge any wrongdoing whatsoever and instead label the person who initially pointed out the bullshit as being overly "negative".
I like some of the guys content over the years but overall I don't think he's too negative, I just don't like his act.
I felt the same about the Kinda Funny team or the girlfriend reviews videos, I respect the fans of the Youtubers here I just don't rate most of them at all.
All too often you need to put this in context that you don't wish the content creator any bad vibes personally, because online hate has been weaponised as we all know.
Too tired of Jim's post-modern schtick, in a nutshell.
I felt the same about the Kinda Funny team or the girlfriend reviews videos, I respect the fans of the Youtubers here I just don't rate most of them at all.
All too often you need to put this in context that you don't wish the content creator any bad vibes personally, because online hate has been weaponised as we all know.
Too tired of Jim's post-modern schtick, in a nutshell.
How do you mean,I'm talking about the hyperbolic negative reactions so many had in those threads.
i dont care if hes negative or positive but that hes correct and accurate. After seeing him basically whip up a frothing crowd to go after the Ooblets devs i refuse to watch another video of his.
I'm at a point where I think anyone who focuses on positivity turns out to be a real asshole behind the scenes, Resetera itself is evidence of that.
I don't hate Sterling, but I stopped watching him a long time ago because he can turn one little piece of news into a 12 min video. Yes, DLC bad, game industry bad, and you can speak out against that, but it starts to become disingenuous when we all know, including him, that he gets paid to complain. It's practically old man yells at Cloud, but also gets paid to do it.
I don't hate Sterling, but I stopped watching him a long time ago because he can turn one little piece of news into a 12 min video. Yes, DLC bad, game industry bad, and you can speak out against that, but it starts to become disingenuous when we all know, including him, that he gets paid to complain. It's practically old man yells at Cloud, but also gets paid to do it.
sadly, yes. there's some of his videos that i know it's doom and gloom just because of the thumb + title.
it's tiring for me but it works for him
his Dark Souls is political video is amazing, tho.
User Banned (1 Week): Inflammatory Comparison and Thread Derailment; Prior Related Bans
ib4 15 minute video explaining how him being a big shithead is everyone else's fault
Jim can shove off after the ooblets video. One of the worst examples of bottom feeding youtubers who thrive on stoking hate no matter who it hurts
Trump's news conferences get good ratings btw. Maybe Jim should take notes and go full Trump, since you're justified in any behavior and any content as long as it gets more views
Jim can shove off after the ooblets video. One of the worst examples of bottom feeding youtubers who thrive on stoking hate no matter who it hurts
Trump's news conferences get good ratings btw. Maybe Jim should take notes and go full Trump, since you're justified in any behavior and any content as long as it gets more views
It's not the internet's fault. The internet just makes it more observable. Blame evolution.
en.wikipedia.org
Negativity bias - Wikipedia
So you didn't watch it (again) before complaining. Is this a hobby of yours?
It's one thing to criticize guys like Sterling for being hasty and/or negative. The comparison with Trump is lazy, disingenuous and trollish. Get out of here with that false equivalence.
[EDIT] Also, after reviewing the Ooblets controversy, it seems Sterling privated the video where he criticized the devs, and made a follow-up video and tweets about harassment (and how it's absolutely not acceptable). Ah yes, very Trump-like behavior, hmmmhmmm.
Last edited:
I honestly don't even think Jim's stuff is that negative. Do people who think this only watch The Jimquisition?
His Jimpressions videos are extremely fair, and I find align super closely with my own tastes. He's more realistic than most reviews but no less positive or affirming on stuff he actually likes.
His Jimpressions videos are extremely fair, and I find align super closely with my own tastes. He's more realistic than most reviews but no less positive or affirming on stuff he actually likes.
OP
OP
He makes a point in the video of saying it's next to impossible to change track once your channel is known For something, Regardless if it's his shtick or minecraft players or fortnite. Which I can totally believe.
This video absolutely hits the nail on the head. While I don't watch his stuff as much anymore because if you've seen one Bethesda video you've seen 'em all, I like Jim as a person and go out of my way to watch his Jimpressions videos, because that's the content I want.
Hell, I think some of his Jimquisitions have been way off-base. As a Shenmue fan, that "Waterworld" video where he flipped his whole act 180 degrees and was all of a sudden concerned about a game not making enough money, and asking if it's even "worth it" for a game to exist if it doesn't make money...all because he wasn't a fan, I guess? F-ing yikes. But no one's perfect. He may get it horribly wrong sometimes, but he's a nice dude.
Hell, I think some of his Jimquisitions have been way off-base. As a Shenmue fan, that "Waterworld" video where he flipped his whole act 180 degrees and was all of a sudden concerned about a game not making enough money, and asking if it's even "worth it" for a game to exist if it doesn't make money...all because he wasn't a fan, I guess? F-ing yikes. But no one's perfect. He may get it horribly wrong sometimes, but he's a nice dude.
It's a shame that it actually lost him both subscribers and patrons, though.
I feel like it's healthier to just straight up avoid youtube channels where the entire schtick is "person is angry and cynical as a default and consumes EVERYTHING through that lens"
Youtube has brainwashed people into thinking the more cynical you are about everything that that must mean that you're insightful. Hence I avoid channels like Jim's. There are way way way healthier ways to criticize.
Youtube has brainwashed people into thinking the more cynical you are about everything that that must mean that you're insightful. Hence I avoid channels like Jim's. There are way way way healthier ways to criticize.
It's always been his schtick. I tired of it years ago, so I don't watch his videos. If you're watching his videos and complaining while at the same time knowing that it's his schtick, that's on you, not him.
Yeah he's pretty positive in a lot of of his jimpressions stuff.
Isn't that the most funny part of it all? Most people accuse him of negativity but really they are arguing in bad faith since if you take the layer of entertaining hyperbole (something he actually managed to get right without seeming like an actual obnoxious person instead of say, Moviebob) you'll see that he's mostly, like he said in this video, trying to keep accountability instead of just shitting over games.
My only experience with Shenmue was Giantbombs endurance run and even I went fucking Yikes at that one. It was clear he did that just for clicks or some vendetta against the series since everthing he said in that video contradicts everything else he goes on about. I went from at watching most of his content to maybe watching 3 videos since then.
I think Jim's like the closest thing the industry has to a pundit and I appreciate it. I disagree with him sometimes (maybe 40-50% of the time), but I'm never really angered or put off by his stuff like half of this board seems to be. He rails against the things many of us hate on, and he's not afraid to inject leftist politics into his videos. You'd think it would align with this board more, but alas.
I'm genuinely confused by the derision some of his videos get. The same brigade always comes in to tell people that they're not gonna watch it or why people shouldn't watch it.
It's bizarre.
I'm genuinely confused by the derision some of his videos get. The same brigade always comes in to tell people that they're not gonna watch it or why people shouldn't watch it.
It's bizarre.
I don't think he's negative. He does call out a lot of bad practices the industry does do, and sadly there are lots to call out. That said There are definitely YouTubers that trade in misery and they just move from controversy to controversy. Jim also does do positive videos but whe he does , miserable people accuse him of Schilling for whatever he just praised
If I had a dollar for every time Jim Sterling tried to push blame for his toxicity and negativity on "the viewers" I'd be a rich man.
I did?
He said his negative videos get more views so it's everyone else's fault that he has to negative ones!
Watched the video to see if he'd talk about what use Patreon can or can't be for escaping the trap of the YouTube algorith, but that topic only got the most superficial, short treatment.
Jim Sterling remains a prime example of self-flanderization.
Jim Sterling remains a prime example of self-flanderization.
Obviously you didn't since he addresses this (very dumb) argument.
He did not say that. He said he'd keep making positive videos anyway, such as his upcoming one on RE3. Stop fucking trolling. Did he kill your dog or something?
No, he says he has plenty of positive stuff too. He didn't stop making those even if they get less views. It's just that the people complaining about him being all negative like you don't actually watch his positive stuff.
If I had a dollar everytime some rando complains about Jim Sterling in a Jim Sterling thread without watching the actual video, I'd be a rich man, too.
He's not pushing the blame on the viewers.
Personally, I feel that Jim's general tone of contempt/ disparagement is now more of an issue in all of his videos, not just the Jimquisition episodes or those scathing hot take things about random news items.
Case in point: his recent Jimpressions for Doom Eternal. He talks about the game in a positive way but the overall noncommittal tone of the video suggests that he's merely "okay" with the whole experience. Now obviously I don't expect him to fire rainbows and confetti out of the speakers in bombastic approval (though such flamboyance would actually suit his personal style), but it would be nice to see some constructive appraisal/ criticism every so often (afterall, he started as a writer - he's clearly capable of it). Merely pointing at aspects of a game and saying "yeah, it's alright innit" isn't really conducive to criticism of any kind, whether positive or negative.
Overall though, I've this pervading sense of dread regarding Jim and his output these days, though said feeling isn't in anticipation of his condescension but more of the fatalism that seems to permeate all of his videogame content at this point. Given the way that he seems to position himself through social media and his ever increasing disdain for the "videos that get the clicks", I can't escape the creeping doubt that Jim won't be producing this Youtube gaming content at all in five or six years time.
It's almost as if this video is a vague self-deconstruction of a man who just can't hear the laughter anymore...
Case in point: his recent Jimpressions for Doom Eternal. He talks about the game in a positive way but the overall noncommittal tone of the video suggests that he's merely "okay" with the whole experience. Now obviously I don't expect him to fire rainbows and confetti out of the speakers in bombastic approval (though such flamboyance would actually suit his personal style), but it would be nice to see some constructive appraisal/ criticism every so often (afterall, he started as a writer - he's clearly capable of it). Merely pointing at aspects of a game and saying "yeah, it's alright innit" isn't really conducive to criticism of any kind, whether positive or negative.
Overall though, I've this pervading sense of dread regarding Jim and his output these days, though said feeling isn't in anticipation of his condescension but more of the fatalism that seems to permeate all of his videogame content at this point. Given the way that he seems to position himself through social media and his ever increasing disdain for the "videos that get the clicks", I can't escape the creeping doubt that Jim won't be producing this Youtube gaming content at all in five or six years time.
It's almost as if this video is a vague self-deconstruction of a man who just can't hear the laughter anymore...
Well no shit. Negative stuff in all fields gets more views.
Look at Era. How many times do you see people post negative news from a topic that usually doesn't get discussed vs positive news on that same topic? The negative news is actual news.
Look at Era. How many times do you see people post negative news from a topic that usually doesn't get discussed vs positive news on that same topic? The negative news is actual news.
