Just watch Schumacher's filmsI just wish they would go the other direction. Batman doesn't have to be super grounded gritty shit to be enjoyable.
Just watch Schumacher's filmsI just wish they would go the other direction. Batman doesn't have to be super grounded gritty shit to be enjoyable.
You'd think Guardians of the Galaxy would have shown everything doesn't need to be grounded
like Galactus doesn't need to be a dumb cloud anymore. that time has passd
guess Batman's an exception for some reason
Batman Begins had a ancient ninja-cult secret society and a slum right out of a pulp comic flooded with nightmare gas by stolen super-tech. Even "grounded" Batman was never grounded in the real world
Fuck no. I didn't say silly or camp, but comic book.
What about a gritty Batman isn't comic accurate? What exactly is it that you want from a Batman adaptation that's not achievable with a more grounded aesthetic?
One that's like the comic book. For instance using the riddler instead of riddler in name only zodiac killer which totally doesn't get the point of the riddler from what I have seen.What about a gritty Batman isn't comic accurate? What exactly is it that you want from a Batman adaptation that's not achievable with a more grounded aesthetic?
More grounded Batman movies? Guess I'm sleeping for another decade.
Fuck no. I didn't say silly or camp, but comic book.
EDIT: Like I have been reading Batman for years and still keep up, I want a more faithful adaption and that isn't grounded. Peacemaker shows you can do it, and you don't have to tone down violence or harder stuff either.
Aesthetically, Riddler might not look comic accurate, but the spirit of the character seems to be in tact. Recent TV spots have highlighted his sick sense of humor. This movie is shaping up to be the most like the comics out of all of the adaptations so far.One that's like the comic book. For instance using the riddler instead of riddler in name only zodiac killer which totally doesn't get the point of the riddler from what I have seen.
I imagine they want the other half of Batman's rogues gallery that never get to show up because they aren't grounded enough. Heck add like 90% of the supporting cast onto that aswell.What about a gritty Batman isn't comic accurate? What exactly is it that you want from a Batman adaptation that's not achievable with a more grounded aesthetic?
I didn't say quip fest. Hell make a horror movie adapted from any of the beat of Snyder's run. Either a true court of owls or death in the family with joker in a skin mask of his own face trying to destroy everything Bruce loves because he thinks it makes him weak and takes away from their dynamic.Like we have a zillion properties like this already. One just one property that can distinguish itself today and you want to turn that also into a quip fest with a zillion comic book references shenanigans.
Besides this Batman does look like its from the comics. It probably just happens to be comics you dont like.
Tynion's detective was god tier, and every time I see something labeled Gotham Knights I cry a little knowing it won't have anything to do with that run.I neverkkef Clayface as a kid but the Tynion run on Detective made me appreciate him more. I think if they cast a good actor for the role it could be a great fit for movies as he has a compelling backstory.
Which villains would that be? Can't think of too many of the good ones that couldn't be done in a "grounded" way. Grounded doesn't have to mean realistic. Matt Reeves is coming off two incredible films about talking apes. It's not like he's afraid of the fantastical.I imagine they want the other half of Batman's rogues gallery that never get to show up because they aren't grounded enough. Heck add like 90% of the supporting cast onto that aswell.
When people complain about "grounded" they don't mean that its a 1 to 1 to our real world. Just that the creators put a ceiling on the types of stories they can tell in order to maintain a sense of "realism". Everything you listed from Begins is just heightened reality. League of Shadows is just a terrorist group. The Narrows is just a very poor part of a major city. Nightmare gas is just hallucinogens/chemical warfare.Batman Begins had a ancient ninja-cult secret society and a slum right out of a pulp comic flooded with nightmare gas by stolen super-tech. Even "grounded" Batman was never grounded in the real world
Reeves letting Apes talk in his Planet of the Apes films isn't really proof that WB will let the Batman franchise get fantastical. Apes talked in his movies because talking Apes is part of the IP that audiences are familiar with. Reeves wasn't really pushing any boundaries because an Ape talking is like the Waynes getting killed in a Batman movie.Which villains would that be? Can't think of too many of the good ones that couldn't be done in a "grounded" way. Grounded doesn't have to mean realistic. Matt Reeves is coming off two incredible films about talking apes. It's not like he's afraid of the fantastical.
I didn't say quip fest. Hell make a horror movie adapted from any of the beat of Snyder's run. Either a true court of owls or death in the family with joker in a skin mask of his own face trying to destroy everything Bruce loves because he thinks it makes him weak and takes away from their dynamic.
I didn't say campy or like marvel, Batman has been in some dark shit, but it's still comic books with comic logic and not trying to explain how everything could actually work. It's a dude who dresses up as a bat.
Which villains would that be? Can't think of too many of the good ones that couldn't be done in a "grounded" way. Grounded doesn't have to mean realistic. Matt Reeves is coming off two incredible films about talking apes. It's not like he's afraid of the fantastical.
When people complain about "grounded" they don't mean that its a 1 to 1 to our real world. Just that the creators put a ceiling on the types of stories they can tell in order to maintain a sense of "realism". Everything you listed from Begins is just heightened reality. League of Shadows is just a terrorist group. The Narrows is just a very poor part of a major city. Nightmare gas is just hallucinogens/chemical warfare.
This plus there is a literal question mark in a cup of coffee lolAesthetically, Riddler might not look comic accurate, but the spirit of the character seems to be in tact. Recent TV spots have highlighted his sick sense of humor. This movie is shaping up to be the most like the comics out of all of the adaptations so far.
You're spitting. I'm glad the Batman movies are more grounded. Besides, it's not like everything else out right now isn't on the more fantastical sideAnd you are still getting a dude dressed up as a bat, A catwoman that looks straight out of the comics ( Finally looks like we are getting a decent Batman Catwoman dynamic from the comics). Just putting a little bit more effort to explain the psychology of the characters and the world around them does not mean that it is not comic book accurate
This.
And how does it matter? Would the movie have been better if it is just nightmare gas made from magic?
Also we just had Batman fight some CGI monsters recently. Like its not like we never got that or particularly new. We have a zillion super heroes fighting some variation of CGI monsters. Do we need another super hero to do that again in live action. Why cant one property be a little different.
Pretty sure he knows he made a successful film. He's experienced and already shown it several times.How about he waits to see if the first film is a success first...
More grounded Batman movies? Guess I'm sleeping for another decade.
What are you talking about? The poster I was replying to listed nightmare gas as not being a grounded weapon. The list of examples was just showing that everything Nolan did in his trilogy has a very real world parallel.And how does it matter? Would the movie have been better if it is just nightmare gas made from magic?
LOL. I don't know how you can bemoan about super hero properties being same when solo Batman movies have been the same for 20 years. People aren't clamoring for "CGI monsters" they just want the palette for the type of stories to expand beyond Batman fighting mob bosses/serial killers/terrorist. I never understand why a certain portion of the Batman fandom gets so defensive whenever anyone brings up wanting something different.Also we just had Batman fight some CGI monsters recently. Like its not like we never got that or particularly new. We have a zillion super heroes fighting some variation of CGI monsters. Do we need another super hero to do that again in live action. Why cant one property be a little different.
What are you talking about? The poster I was replying to listed nightmare gas as not being a grounded weapon. The list of examples was just showing that everything Nolan did in his trilogy has a very real world parallel.
LOL. I don't know how you can bemoan about super hero properties being same when solo Batman movies have been the same for 20 years. People aren't clamoring for "CGI monsters" they just want the palette for the type of stories to expand beyond Batman fighting mob bosses/serial killers/terrorist. I never understand why a certain portion of the Batman fandom gets so defensive whenever anyone brings up wanting something different.
You would enjoy the Schumer films.I just wish they would go the other direction. Batman doesn't have to be super grounded gritty shit to be enjoyable.
No, I hate all those films. I didn't enjoy a Batman film until Nolan, everything before that including Burton was not for me.
boy i can't wait for grounded boring "mr freeze" who just shoots people then leaves them in a freezer or something
I agree. The Arkham games kind of did both and it worked really well- not sure why we can't have that.So sick of " Batman in the real world" give me comic Batman already.
90's Batman movies being so insanely hammy really gave people brain damage.
He has one of the most tragic backstories from any comic book villain - yeah, I mean his backstory from the Animated series - and I would love to see his character in a movie made by MR.. the same with Clayface - a guy who fucks up his face and body with too many fat injections and weird stuff that he loses his mind and starts killing people who he thinks are taking the spotlight from him..
Or... you can just watch Mask of the Phantasm because that movie is perfect as-is. It doesn't need to be pulled out of animation to elevate it.I just wanna see someone make Mask of the Phantasm live action
Or... you can just watch Mask of the Phantasm because that movie is perfect as-is. It doesn't need to be pulled out of animation to elevate it.
Also Batman movies have not been the same for 20 years. We literally just had Lego Batman, Zack Snyders Batman fighting some fantastical things, If anything its other super heroes that could use a little bit of a change in how they are represented instead of the same old same old.
It would be one thing if we are getting an avalanche of `grounded` movies from punisher to daredevil in this space that is leading to fatigue but what is happening is exactly the opposite. So why not have this continue to be a little different from the rest of the super hero movies out there.
I literally just rewatched it acouple nights ago. You adapt that in live action, you don't get all that beautiful art deco, you don't get to play with the World of the Future metaphor, none of that. MotP is a perfect Batman movie. Let it rest undisturbed.I love mask of the phantasm. I just want more people to love it as well.
Oh it definitely looks like the best Batman film to date.I agree. The Arkham games kind of did both and it worked really well- not sure why we can't have that.
That said The Batman looks amazing so I'm in for whatever if it's good.