This is a thread about smacking, in case you're lost.
This is a thread about smacking, in case you're lost.
Like I'm not for spanking kids, in anyway... but this thread is a bit, well, ehhhh.
You lot come across as perfect parents
this is fine because the kid always has the opportunity to reverse the pressure back on you.What about a lightly applied figure four leg lock or sharpshooter? How bout that?
Exactly right. We are human. Parents get frustrated and make mistakes. No one is perfect. The important thing is to realize it was a mistake.Every parent makes mistakes but there's a difference in a mistake and defending plus perpetuating behavior that's been proven ineffective and damaging.
"Like I'm not for giving kids toys with lead paint but this thread is a bit, well, ehhh. You lot come across and perfect parents."
Same thing. It's damaging. Maybe at some point people thought it was fine and at that time I don't overly blame them or think they're monsters for doing it but now is not that time. We know better so we can be better.
Honestly the important thing is to not hit your child if you're going to have one, something most parents manage.Exactly right. We are human. Parents get frustrated and make mistakes. No one is perfect. The important thing is to realize it was a mistake.
Exactly right. We are human. Parents get frustrated and make mistakes. No one is perfect. The important thing is to realize it was a mistake.
I did this to my oldest daughter when she was 2. I felt awful, but somehow she had gotten a plug cover off of a wall outlet and I walked into the room just as she went to try and stick a hairpin into it.
I lunged at her and swung hard enough to knock her 3-4 feet to my left.
I felt so bad, but I was attempting to save her and it was all instinctive/no thinking reaction.
I'm assuming if they're a massive shit or playing with fire (literally). I wouldn't do it myself but I suppose you'd smack a toddler's hand if they were trying to stick it into a power socket?
Yes because I suggested beating my child.
Maybe I made my point poorly but some people in this thread seem to think that any kind of hitting or grabbing even when the child is in mortal danger or at risk of harming themselves is a bad thing.
If my child is about to walk into traffic or jam a fork where it doesn't belong I'll be using whatever force is necessary to remove that risk of harm.
This is hardly the only topic where this gets revealed. It is always a little surprising (and very disturbing) how eager some people are to endorse hitting children, and the relish with which they describe doing so.This is one of those threads that's good to look at whenever some calls Era a "progressive hivemend." Meanwhile we need a staff post telling people it's not OK to advocate for beating the smallest, weakest, most powerless people on the planet just to show them who's boss.
Every time in these threads. At least it is bannable these days to advocate child abuse, as someone who suffered a great deal of "corporal punishment" and did not "turn out okay," I appreciate that.
Yeah it's honestly fucking disgusting how some people bend over backwards to excuse this stuffEvery time in these threads. At least it is bannable these days to advocate child abuse, as someone who suffered a great deal of "corporal punishment" and did not "turn out okay," I appreciate that.
I have never hit my child, and whaddya know, she is turning out great.
A reminder that corporal punishment has been studied extensively and has repeatedly be shown to be both ineffective and incapable of actually bringing about good outcomes while also having a whole host of negative outcomes
Same. I guess I'd never read up on him before or anything but this is such a bummer since I've always really enjoyed him in practically everything I've seen him in.
Hitting kids is archaic and should be left in the past but this kind of generalization is ridiculous, what does bigotry have anything to do with thisI hate when people say things like "my parents hit me and I turned out fine, I don't hate them"
You might not resent them but you didn't turn out fine, people who say this are always assholes and usually some sort of bigot too.
This is not always true. Many people just believe that spanking is an acceptable punishment for bad behaviour in children. It has nothing to do with anger or self control.People who hit thier kids are angry people that lack self control and maturity. It's such a terrible message to send your kid that if someone is disagreeable, you hit them. He sounds like a major asshole.
It's an issue where "turned out fine" is usually only using incredibly surface level observations to define it, people not wanting to accept their parents who they love were pretty shitty at what raising them (or worse, that they themselves are shitty parents), and ignoring that even if not every kid who is spanked ends up poorly, the fact that many do end up worse and all studies have shown that it's ineffective at improving outcomes. It's like people saying it's fine to give your kids cigarettes because not all of them die young of lung cancer, ignoring the host of other issues that might crop up because of the smoking habits they're likely to have, and that even for the kids that miraculously manage to avoid becoming lifelong smokers nobody is actually better off for the decision
Misworded. I should have added that I was referring to people who say that to defend hitting kids. That's usually not the only shitty belief these people holdHitting kids is archaic and should be left in the past but this kind of generalization is ridiculous, what does bigotry have anything to do with this
Yeah, many of them are just straight up ignorant (it doesn't help that the idea that the bible straight up advocates for physical punishment and people unfortunately tend to put more weight on religion than actual facts and evidence)This is not always true. Many people just believe that spanking is an acceptable punishment for bad behaviour in children. It has nothing to do with anger or self control.
This is not always true. Many people just believe that spanking is an acceptable punishment for bad behaviour in children. It has nothing to do with anger or self control.
It's also teaching them the idea that enforcing violence on others is a smart way to get them to do what you wantDon't hit your kids. Take a minute, leave the room and take a quick breath if you can. I have a two year old. I have a "scream-towel" I use every once in a while in the bathroom. For me...not my kid.
Hitting your kid really isn't teaching them anything positive. It's teaching them to be afraid of their parent. Then that might turn into them intentional hiding stuff from you at a later age because they are afraid the the repercussions.
I knew that's what you meant and that's still quite a stretch that may be exclusive to your personal experience without any larger evidenceMisworded. I should have added that I was referring to people who say that to defend hitting kids. That's usually not the only shitty belief these people hold