I mentioned that as a possibility, but I don't think Bear would put one in that doesn't notify the doused players/have the ability to 'save' them.
I mentioned that as a possibility, but I don't think Bear would put one in that doesn't notify the doused players/have the ability to 'save' them.
Okay, so yeah, it's what I was saying. Sure, we can leave it, but just like I said, if we do mislynch (and I think we're at the point where it's very likely with no great leads), then we're going to be at -3 tomorrow instead of -2.
I'm not an arsonist or a poisoner or anything evil. Wouldn't people have received PMs saying they got doused or something? If there's anyone whose flavor says they're allergic to pineapple or something that'd be one thing I guess, but I haven't moved once all game.
Ok. You're probably right.I mentioned that as a possibility, but I don't think Bear would put one in that doesn't notify the doused players/have the ability to 'save' them.
Did you win Price is Right, by any chance?I'm not an arsonist or a poisoner or anything evil. Wouldn't people have received PMs saying they got doused or something? If there's anyone whose flavor says they're allergic to pineapple or something that'd be one thing I guess, but I haven't moved once all game.
I mean, it's a new day. Well, I was going to bring up one less player to suspect (aside from the lynchee), but tomorrow's NK is likely Fantomas. Still, we'd naturally have more info to operate with with a lynch.If the additional people couldn't conjure up the great leads now, what makes you expect they'd do it tomorrow?
Are you really?hello i am hunter who hunts pizza man hmm should i or should i not shootbangbang that one weird vote on pizza or not hmm
Role claim, please. :P
Holy shit this had not occurred to me.
Thank you for this ripping contribution.Is Bear just sitting there hitting F5 to get the top of the page every time, or is he running a script?
Important question of the day.
Have you talked about this before? That link doesn't ring a bell.
Why?
Fair. But I feel like outside of a few, most players aren't talking about others.
Are there many scum interactions with Blarg? Kyan? Fireblend? rac? It's not hard to ignore some people; that way you don't get that awkward wolf-wolf and can leave a void in post-flip reads.
With a handful of scum left in 15 people we're in a good spot but it doesn't hurt to start looking elsewhere as the crowd thins.
Yeah, for all that I'm suspicious and I am, I don't see the benefit to lynching him right now. The arsonist idea is funny/fascinating but I really doubt it.We're not lynching Fireblend today. We can find out if Fireblend is telling us the truth very easily. There is no reason to think that he will become some kind of unstoppable monster if we don't lynch him.
If we lynch him today, what we are doing is putting our scum hunting on hold for a day instead, and all these topics we've already talked about today, will just be brought up again tomorrow. That's not a good idea.
Holy shit this had not occurred to me.
Sorian gave no notification of the lover pairings. Normally people do get notified when there's an arsonist, but that would be in keeping here.
Yeah, I already followed up to myself.See my other post above on the matter but to add, secret arsonist is much further past bastard than my role is. Let's remember who the mod is here.
I'll be in the movies for few hours, so any vote counts and similar gamerunner duties might be delayed.
Oh I just noticed that's actually incorrect. You voted me day 4. Sorry.Lone_Prodigy care to place a vote today? You haven't put down a single day vote in this game.
I mean I can if things keep staying this close as Day End approaches but I'd really rather not. :xRole claim, please. :P
On a more serious note, who are your top scum reads here? Who would you want to see lynched today?
Shirking your duties?
We'll try not to light the thread in fire
What was the second instance of Brazil trying to save scum outside of turmoil? Drawing a blank here.I mean I can if things keep staying this close as Day End approaches but I'd really rather not. :x
Let me jump to the tallest mountain and proclaim the name Brazil to all the land. His role is completely different from the other 2 that have claimed and I will stand by that I believe he is lying about it in order to cover himself. He has tried to save or help 2 scum players in different situations. Hes who I want lynched today.
I'm still unsure on Malus but I'm leaning town moreso than not. His vote for Bae gives me pause and the reasons people are giving to justify it as Scum aren't staying me. I'll also say that I don't think Malus and Brazil and both be Scum, I think it would be one or the other. If it's not clear I think the scum is Brazil lol. If Malus does end up scum then I'm probably way off on Brazil...
I will move my vote if I need to in order to save myself.
What do you think about Brazil's interactions with Bae following her fake claim on D2?Let me jump to the tallest mountain and proclaim the name Brazil to all the land. His role is completely different from the other 2 that have claimed and I will stand by that I believe he is lying about it in order to cover himself. He has tried to save or help 2 scum players in different situations. Hes who I want lynched today.
What comes to mind for me is when Brazil tried to divert focus to Chuggernaut as a potential lynch target in D3 when Faddy's claim was made.What was the second instance of Brazil trying to save scum outside of turmoil? Drawing a blank here.
Quoted a few pages back but Brazil asked people not to ask Bae for her proof of clearing Ket.What was the second instance of Brazil trying to save scum outside of turmoil? Drawing a blank here.
Why is it you expect a town role to match up with neutral roles again?
What was the second instance of Brazil trying to save scum outside of turmoil? Drawing a blank here.
Why is it you expect a town role to match up with neutral roles again?
What comes to mind for me is when Brazil tried to divert focus to Chuggernaut as a potential lynch target in D3 when Faddy's claim was made.
Quoted a few pages back but Brazil asked people not to ask Bae for her proof of clearing Ket.
I don't but are you honestly going to tell me Grizzly made roles involving the modifiers and one just 'happened' to not follow the thematic precedent set by the others? It sticks out like a sore thumb.
Gonna have to get back to you here after I get to work. Sorry.What do you think about Brazil's interactions with Bae following her fake claim on D2?
My counter point is another game, GoT. There were, if I remember right, only two roles that had anything to do with the Religion mechanic in that game. One was Zeke's Neutral role, the other was my Town role. Zeke's was more specifically focused on a certain religion, mine was more nebulous and not very useful.I don't but are you honestly going to tell me Grizzly made roles involving the modifiers and one just 'happened' to not follow the thematic precedent set by the others? It sticks out like a sore thumb.
Tbf I wouldn't say I have "pre-info on modifiers", unless knowing that I'll exit the game counts. I have no idea what that modifier actually entails.only neutrals seem to have pre-info on modifiers so far which is why Brazil's seems out of place to be modifier focused.
why would scum!brazil try and save fando by trying to be lynched first and then with that weak ass claim
Fair - though I'm pretty sure you can go grab a lot of quotes from more than one person that discuss balance/mechanics wise Chugg's claim being the sketchiest (neutrals are somewhat often given a BP).What comes to mind for me is when Brazil tried to divert focus to Chuggernaut as a potential lynch target in D3 when Faddy's claim was made.
I guess I can see that if you come at it from the perspective of Bae being vague in hopes of not getting counter claimed by a different investigative role. It's not an inherently scummy statement though.Quoted a few pages back but Brazil asked people not to ask Bae for her proof of clearing Ket.
I don't but are you honestly going to tell me Grizzly made roles involving the modifiers and one just 'happened' to not follow the thematic precedent set by the others? It sticks out like a sore thumb.
On the one hand, this is a great point.why would scum!brazil try and save fando by trying to be lynched first and then with that weak ass claim
Tbf I wouldn't say I have "pre-info on modifiers", unless knowing that I'll exit the game counts. I have no idea what that modifier actually entails.
Ppl weren't going for a brazil lynchwhy would scum!brazil try and save fando by trying to be lynched first and then with that weak ass claim
You really can't help but try to link people together, can you? That's how you've played all game. You're always leaving some trail in your EoD posts so that you can just jump back at it without having to reassess your reads.I mean I can if things keep staying this close as Day End approaches but I'd really rather not. :x
Let me jump to the tallest mountain and proclaim the name Brazil to all the land. His role is completely different from the other 2 that have claimed and I will stand by that I believe he is lying about it in order to cover himself. He has tried to save or help 2 scum players in different situations. Hes who I want lynched today.
I'm still unsure on Malus but I'm leaning town moreso than not. His vote for Bae gives me pause and the reasons people are giving to justify it as Scum aren't staying me. I'll also say that I don't think Malus and Brazil and both be Scum, I think it would be one or the other. If it's not clear I think the scum is Brazil lol. If Malus does end up scum then I'm probably way off on Brazil...
I will move my vote if I need to in order to save myself.
I guess the point there would be that you knew that Love Boat was part of your win-con, and also knew what it did. Fireblend knew that Pineapple Pizza was his win-con, but didn't know what it did. But then Brazil doesn't know what any of the post restriction modifiers are, just that they don't count for him. It's still less specific than both, but yeah FB's is definitely still less specific than yours.(Pretend I quoted Fanto's post too)
That's kind of why the nebulous vs. specific info doesn't exactly work. I'd argue Fireblend seems to have about as much info about a modifier as Brazil does. I'm the only one so far that had actual concrete info.
I guess the point there would be that you knew that Love Boat was part of your win-con, and also knew what it did. Fireblend knew that Pineapple Pizza was his win-con, but didn't know what it did. But then Brazil doesn't know what any of the post restriction modifiers are, just that they don't count for him. It's still less specific than both, but yeah FB's is definitely still less specific than yours.
Either way, I feel like it's kind of a shitty argument anyways lol. It was just something that stuck out to me back when FB first claimed so I made a note of it.
Yeah, that was one point I brought up to Natiko when we were talking about it as well. We could just be lucky and haven't hit any others like Cthulhu yet, but the fact that he didn't even breadcrumb it as far as I'm aware when he had the chance on a post restriction day is a point against the claim I think.Sure, I'm more of the mind that the real issue is we've seen one modifier with a post restriction and we've gone through a decent number of them (also not just proving it when you could which was a Brazil choice) but I saw a lot of people side eye the connection when Fireblend claimed, I think you may have too.
Hmm. I don't know if I scumread this particularly. We're kinda doing the same thing right now by speculating on the neutrals and the game design as a whole. It's a thing that happens in the moment that later looks real bad and at the time, poor ol' Chuggs had made some not-great plays and a commuter, doctor, and BP does seem like a lot of protection in this game. It still does. I'm guessing there are more kills hidden in some modifiers for those things to exist but I'm iffy on this being a huge thing. As part of a bigger picture, maybe, and it could be scummy, sure, but I find it indeterminate as a factor unto itself.What comes to mind for me is when Brazil tried to divert focus to Chuggernaut as a potential lynch target in D3 when Faddy's claim was made.
Yeah, apparently the only breadcrumb was not counting the posts.Yeah, that was one point I brought up to Natiko when we were talking about it as well. We could just be lucky and haven't hit any others like Cthulhu yet, but the fact that he didn't even breadcrumb it as far as I'm aware when he had the chance on a post restriction day is a point against the claim I think.
They do if you do it the right way. You have to right click the post number in the top right corner of a post and then hit "copy link location" or whatever. That gives the non-page specific perma-link to the post.(also though the page links don't work for people on different ppp, just fyi to everyone)