My immediate reaction (after I'm done DANCING ON SORIAN'S GRAVE; I LOVE YOU, SCUM, WILL NEVER SAY THIS AGAIN, ENJOY IT) is Febe and Kyanrute, or Febe and rac.
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
MafiEra Mafia |OT| The Day of the Blargonauts
- Thread starter The Bear
- Start date
BUT I don't want to go with immediate gut reaction. I want to hear from folks and study that role PM and look at the game state. We can solve this. I believe we can solve it today.
Febe for sure, though, almost certainly.
Febe for sure, though, almost certainly.
You think he's cult?
I'm going back and digging through all the modifier votes, too. HvV was probably a shot.
How big is cult vs how many scum are left vs deciding if PPM votes were just nice or cult.
How big is cult vs how many scum are left vs deciding if PPM votes were just nice or cult.
His vote switch calls the most attention.
fake edit: oh wait no I noticed Kyan did, too. hmm. It was right after and I didn't even see it.
Well that's fun. How do I convince you guys I'm not cult? I still exposed the cult and killed sawneeks. Which such difficult recruitment mechanics, sacrificing Sneeks just wouldn't have been worth it. Either way, I still want Pineapple Pizza to be chosen (even though that seems close to impossible now).
Thoughts?
Thoughts?
errbody is a suspect
so we gotta look at Sneeks-Sorian-Febe and figure how who they were most likely to recruit and how many shots they had.
Oh boy, so Fire is definitely cult. Need to dig through and see who all voted with Sorian consistently. People that were looking to vote Love Boat probably look good too as he clearly wasn't getting a shot from that. No hint as to how many total possible members though so that's not great news. At least we know they are 4 or less currently. No limit on the recruit either so that makes this all a shit show. At least we get two shots at hitting them today, bless RNG.
I'm not cult. Explain why I would've exposed it in the first place and killed Sawneeks. I'm a neutral that just wants some damn pizza.
Not sure why I'm even fighting anymore since the next modifier is locked in but eh.
I want someone to make a bet with me: if you think I'm cult, please bet one month of what it costs to keep the vote tool server up and running. It's around $9. Who's up for taking that bet?
Not even surprised. The kill itself is more interesting; I figured Kyanrute (high suspicion for cult) or Fantomas ("confirmed town") would have been killed this time.
I like that what Natiko said is what RNG ended up being: randomly picking a modifier. lol if it had ended up being Pineapple Pizza.
So, considering Sorian's flip compared to Sawneeks', I guess he was the leader. This would also explain some weird, sudden obsessions behind certain modifiers in the past, like Heroes vs. Villains or Cthulhu.
And, now, Pineapple Pizza. It's possible that cult hasn't been able to recruit for some time or they've had some kind of trouble, and they know that Pineapple Pizza will give them a shot. Perhaps they'd be ready to sacrifice Fireblend for that purpose, and that it would get them closer to being a majority?
I was about to vote for Fireblend, but it does seem like we're at the endgame now. And with today's modifier, it seems we'll need to be a bit more careful.
I like that what Natiko said is what RNG ended up being: randomly picking a modifier. lol if it had ended up being Pineapple Pizza.
So, considering Sorian's flip compared to Sawneeks', I guess he was the leader. This would also explain some weird, sudden obsessions behind certain modifiers in the past, like Heroes vs. Villains or Cthulhu.
And, now, Pineapple Pizza. It's possible that cult hasn't been able to recruit for some time or they've had some kind of trouble, and they know that Pineapple Pizza will give them a shot. Perhaps they'd be ready to sacrifice Fireblend for that purpose, and that it would get them closer to being a majority?
I was about to vote for Fireblend, but it does seem like we're at the endgame now. And with today's modifier, it seems we'll need to be a bit more careful.
yeah, this is a problem.
but it's really, really hard to believe. I'm gonna go back over all Sorian's posts to you very carefully.
Also if I had people I wanted to protect why would I have given my vote to Fanto yesterday. I'm still up for lynching Kyan btw, or whoever. Monkey, Fanto, direct my vote.
There have to be some limitations, or else cult would be able to recruit scum and... huh. Maybe that's a thing?
So there is at least one scum who's not cult, because Sorian is dead. This is fact.
Scum is invested in removing cult. This is fact. These facts will help today.
Only certain modifiers gave shots. We don't know how many shots. That needs to be a focus.
We may well be at endgame and without knowing numbers, we need to be super careful about votes.
Scum is invested in removing cult. This is fact. These facts will help today.
Only certain modifiers gave shots. We don't know how many shots. That needs to be a focus.
We may well be at endgame and without knowing numbers, we need to be super careful about votes.
Also for all I know, Pineapple Pizza *was* a recruiting spot for cult. Who knows. My win condition was to get people to vote for it.
I'm willing to consider the deal with you if we hit cult with the lynch and if you help us figure this out. But we have to determine if Sorian was riding your pizzatails or if you are cult. And that's gonna depend on figuring out the rest. Sorry, Febe, them's the pizza crusts.
I have to go make dinner. I'm gonna break out my spreadsheet too and parse modifier votes on it later. BUT HEY GUYS PERK UP WE HAVE A NEW PUZZLE AND MORE CLUES AND WE CAN DO THIS
People were inclined to believe Sorian, too. All of that Love Boat stuff ended up being made up. He probably wanted to avoid Love Boat because it wouldn't give him a recruitment shot for cult, and then retrofitted it into a claim once AbsolutBro's investigation results came out.
Both cult and scum (and town, I guess, with the Brazil/Fandoring/malus stuff) have been erratic this game. The plans are on layer 20, and I think things go beyond "what would make sense."
I mean, fair. I can see how this looks from town's perspective. But the facts are there and I my actions would make 0 sense if I was cult, I'm willing to try and hit cult tonight to at least clear my name.
This is stupid. If evidence doesn't matter you can justify any lynch. Plus, Sorian's claim was a work of art. If I was allied with him what would've been the point of adding a stupid pineapple pizza gambit on top of that, let alone kill sawneeks and reveal the cult's existence? I've not lied once this game.
Why not? It's all misdirection that obviously obscured the cult's nature (while exposing it that day through your shot, for whatever reason), and Pineapple Pizza is a modifier that will give you guys a recruitment shot, which might be worth a sacrifice of yours for whatever reason. We're approaching the end game. If they've had trouble getting recruitment shots because of the modifiers that have been picked, it might have been worth pulling a "Vote for Pineapple Pizza and, if I'm still alive, lynch me next phase."
It'd explain why you hadn't mentioned Pineapple Pizza until late in the game. Sawneeks' lynch after malus was shot was clearly calculated to unveil the cult, it wasn't an accident. The reactions from us avoiding Pineapple Pizza completely once we saw her flip might not have been planned, or it might have been and that was also a beneficial result for you guys, keeping yourself protected from the possibility of a lynch until we reach the end game.
Actually...
Man, that RNG choice really screwed me over. The next modifier is set and we're lynching 2 people today?
Might as well lynch me now, surely there is no way this game lasts 2 more night phases? :(
What am I fighting for D:
Man, that RNG choice really screwed me over. The next modifier is set and we're lynching 2 people today?
Might as well lynch me now, surely there is no way this game lasts 2 more night phases? :(
What am I fighting for D:
How could cult not have seen the reaction to Sneeks flip coming. Your reasoning makes 0 sense holy shit. That's a lot of "for whatever reason"s in your post.
You up for that bet then?
What do you mean when you say this? I don't think the next day's modifier has been set. You just mean today?
Again, people have avoided lynching you while also avoiding voting for Pineapple Pizza. Losing the possibility of getting that recruitment shot, but ensuring that no one thinks of lynching you because "the plan won't make sense" would be exactly what you were going for.
And you mean the cash bet? Nope, not touching that in a game like this. But nice try.
I would lynch Kyan and L_P, although flux's insistence on my actions somehow making sense for a cult member is really making me doubt what he is.
Oh wow, I totally misread that. I thought today was still RNG and tomorrow's would be Bar 2. Ok cool, I have a reason to continue fighting then.
that's funny considering i wanted to kill sorian for days
So instead of voting for the people you think should be lynched, you prefer to vote for who everyone else is voting for instead.
Saying that you wanted him killed for days is meaningless if you didn't put to use the only power we have to put that into motion.
Kyanrute, LP, Fireblend, Blargonaut.
I think these are my suspects for today.
Worst case for us I think is a Cult that is currently at 4 members and a Scum team that still has 2 members left, leaving Town with just 4 today.
For now, I'm trying to think of things as not being quite that desperate though, because if that is the case, then I would probably guess that I have not listed the 4 remaining cult members above, and that we are going to have to go a lot deeper than that to find out who is Cult outside of that group.
I think these are my suspects for today.
Worst case for us I think is a Cult that is currently at 4 members and a Scum team that still has 2 members left, leaving Town with just 4 today.
For now, I'm trying to think of things as not being quite that desperate though, because if that is the case, then I would probably guess that I have not listed the 4 remaining cult members above, and that we are going to have to go a lot deeper than that to find out who is Cult outside of that group.
thats rich considering youve been on every bus in the game
and actually one day telling town to turbo
Other than the times he voted for PAP, I voted with Sorian for Cthulhu because it was my first game in this community, and The Price is Right, for no particular reason other than it was a landslide vote when I checked the status of the vote and my vote wouldn't have done anything at that point.
Lynch-wise, we both voted for Stan for mayor during D1, and... That's it.
Here's something I noticed while checking the votes though, both Sorian and Sawneeks voted for Bar 2 on night 5, along with Fantomas and Flux. Fantomas FluxWaveZ why Bar 2?
Anyway, it might be the case that cult got a recruit shot today.
Lynch-wise, we both voted for Stan for mayor during D1, and... That's it.
Here's something I noticed while checking the votes though, both Sorian and Sawneeks voted for Bar 2 on night 5, along with Fantomas and Flux. Fantomas FluxWaveZ why Bar 2?
Anyway, it might be the case that cult got a recruit shot today.