Remarkable game, I'm still in love with Chloe and Nadine as a duo and want more of them.
Only two negatives for me, but they're a bit spoiler-heavy:
I really wish the series went back to supernatural elements. I don't know why Naughty Dog feels like they've grown out of this when The Last of Us was more mature than Uncharted in its story and had a bunch of super zombies in it. The enemy variety in Uncharted was never that big in the first place, but the supernatural enemies kept things fresh, especially nearing the final stretch of the games.
Uncharted 2 gets bonus points because the blue dudes and the fur dudes are the same thing plot-wise, but they still behave differently in gameplay, increasing enemy variety without having to shove in more supernatural threats in the story.
The other negative was that the final setpiece was so reminiscent of Uncharted 2. And it's all brand new assets, so they didn't really save any time, nothing was reused, it was merely a creative decision. It still feels fresh, and I love how they combined the final boss fight with the setpiece, but I still wish we had a more original idea to close the game.
Other than that, it's just spectacular. Not only the pacing is substantially improved from 4, but to my surprise I also thought the story was more successful in hitting some of the similar emotional notes 4 was going for. Chloe's relationship to her father was beautifully explored in this game, and made me care deeply about her.
I always loved Chloe since her introduction, but it was mostly her design, her personality and the fantastic voice acting. She didn't really have much depth to her, she was more of a fun companion than a fleshed out character that I love, but after The Lost Legacy she's the one carrying the torch, as far as I'm concerned. I think the series continuing with her would feel completely natural.
Please please please don't let Chloe's adventures die with one single game, Naughty Dog. :(
I know you guys probably want to make a new IP after an entire generation with nothing but sequels, but consider a new Chloe game in the future.
Wrote my thoughts a little more extensively
here, if anyone cares.