the thing you aren't really going to be able to recapture by playing the game 10 years later is that there was definitely a feeling of the God of War formula sort of growing stale. The thing I remember is this and Gears of War Judgement coming out around the same time and both inspiring that same sort of middling reaction. It was a perfectly fine game but it was coming off of the heels of 3 with a story that didn't feel as epic or great. People were ready to move on to something new and Ascension was probably the thing that had to happen to really cement that and inspire Santa Monica to really change things up
Well said. I felt the same.
The most memborable part of the experience for me, was how spectacular the final battle looked. Other than that...it was a middling experience overall.