Takeovers back in the day were fantastic, but the weekly shows were only ok. And the best of those weekly shows were during the one hour pre-taped era. When NXT went live and extended to two hours, those shows were not very good (extremely hit and miss). Now HHH is being asked to run five hours of weekly live television
I'd agree that weekly shows were kinda whatever back in the one hour era, I never kept the network going for them but I would happily watch them when I did my usual sign up for the takeover, the one hour format was snappy if nothing else.
Meanwhile I'd argue that two hour NXT was actually pretty good and only really stalled out towards the end with the Kross era.
I thought it followed a similar format to AEW where each week at least aimed to have one or two notable matches, while sprinkling in the odd PPV/takeover lite episode.
Arguably its biggest issue was just that Dynamite offered something similar but more compelling, fresher and ultimately more purposeful