Yeah, but having to rely on you to kill an old comrade, not a happy ending. But yeah, I did forget she survives.
Was gonna say, this is the best outcome. Also, doesn't Alfred's quest in Bloodborne have a happy, but gruesome ending?
lol
Last edited:
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Is there a single NPC quest in Souls games that has a happy ending?
- Thread starter Astral
- Start date
Yeah, but having to rely on you to kill an old comrade, not a happy ending. But yeah, I did forget she survives.
lol
Nothing implies she lives.
It doesn't. It's left ambiguous, but I'd lean more towards that she dies of her injuries going by what she says.
Sounds like that's exactly what you've done, but "you do you" *shrug*
Eileen.
Patches (DS3), in a way.
Aria (unofficial name for the painting girl in DS3).
I'd also consider Seigward's ending satisfactory to him.
Patches (DS3), in a way.
Aria (unofficial name for the painting girl in DS3).
I'd also consider Seigward's ending satisfactory to him.
It's not. Though she's in bad shape, she assures the hunter that she's taken blood. It's just her age catching up with her.
What about giving the hairpin to Stockpile Thomas? He calls you a saint, gives you stuff and it helps him move on with his life.
It's just a joke fan theory because of the maggot helm transformation and the worm drops some lightning miracle lol
You are completely right, my b
I blame it being very late when I wrote that. But anyway, good for him haha
OP
OP
She could just be saying that. Biorr in Demon's Souls says he just needs a nap. That was his last nap I'm pretty sure. Siegward does the same thing and then dies. So I think she's dead.
Edit: Actually according to the wiki Biorr returns to his cell if he survives the Blue Dragon and Penetrator. Kinda weird but can't confirm. Siegward ded though.
Nah. That's not Solaire. If you read the description of the Yellow Bug Pullet, it tells you what that is.
"Medicinal pellet made from crushed insects. The yellow type temporarily boosts lightning damage absorption. The grave wardens of Carthus used these to repel a great sand worm. The worm tumbled into the catacombs, and proceeded to dominate its new home in the Smoldering Lake."
It's a joke but that doesn't say the great sand worm isn't Solaire ~
eh, the only one you can actually see die is Siegward. If she were to die, we would've seen it happen after her dialogue. Still don't think her ending is happy. She survived the hunt, but had to kill so many of her fellow hunters turned mad.
You might want to sit down for this.
he dies in two of the three of his endings, and in the other gets depressed
We might just have a different interpretation, imo, it clearly implies that she stays alive.
I think we just have to agree that dying happy and satisfied in souls games is still a happy ending
OP
OP
I actually just fucked up Siegward's quest and killed Yhorm without freeing him. Oops. Does that mean he at least gets to live or does he off himself or something? Somehow fucked up Greirat's too. I was gonna stop him from going to Lothric but he died in Irithyll somehow despite Siegward being there. Convoluted ass shit.
It was so sad and funny at the same time when the Onion Knight try to save me, just for me to jump with him and both of us die at the same spot.
Really? I beat the game, I just honestly don't remember almost anything story-wise at the end of the game. I don't even remember why that happens.
I'm pretty sure she's being dismissive to waylay the Hunter's fears. It seems pretty obvious to me that she's dying.
Yes.
There's no "quest log" or anything, just like there's no map in the game. It's all ambient, and you have to remember who you've talked to, where you talked to them, and agree to carry out (or deny) their requests, at whatever part of their storyline you're at.
It's not for everyone.
What would she gain from being dismissive, her dying and the bloody crow living ? I don't see it.
But hey to each their own interpretation.
We saved her life, as she said, doesn't make a bit of narrative sense if she dies just after it imo. If she were to die why not make us witness her death ?
benhart and lucatiel have really happy implied endings, esp. benhart. dude is literally the only char who is storywise able to keep up w the player char with 0 intervention from the player
he is hella unique for a souls char in that he is literally the only one who doesn't have a generic And Then They Died or Fulfilled Their Mistaken Goal ending more or less - dude came to fight monsters and ended up dethroning god just to prove how sicknasty he is
he is hella unique for a souls char in that he is literally the only one who doesn't have a generic And Then They Died or Fulfilled Their Mistaken Goal ending more or less - dude came to fight monsters and ended up dethroning god just to prove how sicknasty he is
note benhart isn't undead either like most dark souls npcs so he doesn't have immortality going for him
he is literally just a dude, from a land where ants are the size of tanks coming to fuck up even stronger monsters who managed to somehow wander into the ds2 world
I don't think it's confirmed either way that Benhart (or Rosabeth, for that matter) isn't undead.
Might be remembering wrong, but doesn't Lucatiel hollow just before her bro?
she leaves all her junk for ya with the impression of "oh her hollowing reached its final stages after she her goal classic souls style" but she's summonable in the final DLC final boss and the summon only appears if youve completed her questline unlike benhart who always shows up for elana and the watchers so the implication becomes quite different
implication
iirc all the stuff that affects undeads only accurately works in ds2 vs undead npcs and he isn't on the list but that's minutiae so yeah who knows