Think about what features a new F-Zero game would need to have, Nintendo is not making that game .
Whatever aesthetic fits the Melee version of Mute City is what I want
Best track and best rendition of an F-Zero track PERIOD
I wouldnt call it colourful nor girtty, but I would go with the artsyle used in the SNES F-Zero manual
But of course, with all the new characters the rest of the series added on.
What we really need to get rid of GX, and the only thing i really didnt like from that game, is the electro music.
X and Climax style, or super eurobeat with Takenobu adding some crazy lyrics to each of the cups final track.
I suppose the OP means by gritty the darker palette used in most of the racetracks and charater styles (going for realistic depictions, and things like Deathborn denitetly looks gritty and edgy). Its not gritty in themes or characters behaviour at all lolThis right here.
Also while X is gritty GX is far from it. GX is uncompromised DC era Sega weirdness.
This is me. I loved GX but not to the same standard as the SNES or in particular X on N64.I think both looks are valid evolutions of the F-Zero X artstyle but I vastly prefer how the tracks look in MK8DX. I really only like the gameplay in GX, both the artstyle and the music were not what I personally wanted from a follow up to X.
I'm cool with either but I've always wanted them to double down on the comic book aesthetic of X's art work.
Ignoring that not making a fully new F-ZERO game after this is lowkey anti-consumer,
I never once thought of GX as gritty. Heck, it's one of the campiest games I've ever played. Look up some of the post race interviews or endings for the racers.