Most games have felt underwhelming to me since I had my first VR experience. I was at my buddy's house and he had a roomscale setup with an oculus and two controllers. He popped me into a game called Lone Echo, and I thought "yeah, cool, it's 3D and all around me", but then I looked down and saw my arms, and they were robot arms. The fingers moved when I moved them, and the mechanical bits beneath the surface pulled and stretched as I held my arms out. That's when I lost my shit. I was a fucking robot inside of a video game.
My friend says he barely uses his headset these days, so I dunno if the magic wears off over time, or if there just aren't enough games yet, but man... ever since then I've been holding out for a PSVR2, or something. That jump into VR was drastic and thrilling, and that's how I want games to feel again.