• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

lorddarkflare

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,254
I'm using the term fanservice correctly as it is mostly male titillation as you call it. Which again, there is nothing wrong with it. And it may not be 1960 but to give you an example, Game of Thrones was the most popular show of the last decade and had gratutious nudity every other episode. I guess you were also against it and if they remade it you'll want all those scenes removed?

Holy shit, yes?

A lot of the sex in GOT was super sus not simply because after a time they became unnecessary, but because many of them had some fucked up dynamics, but were played for titillation.

Fanservice is fine, but in non-pornographic media some restraint is important.
 

Rover_

Member
Jun 2, 2020
5,189
BoTh SiDeS.

tumblr_m0sej1IQe41qkhjsco1_500.png

the amount of people who must have took to

1 think this
2 do this
3 test this
4 approve and ship this

is beyond embarrassing and cringe.
 

Garlador

Banned
Oct 30, 2017
14,131
I only used Basic Instinct to make a point that there are movies where the gratuitous shots are the point. That's how I remember Mass Effect.

I want to make it clear that you're last point is absolutely correct. I am accustomed to the male gaze as the default and it certainly adds a layer of bias. Perhaps it is wrong of me to think there is a place in gaming for that ridiculous kind of shot just like there is a place in film and music. In those mediums people write it off whereas in gaming it's not acceptable, I find that interesting.

Also, that shot is pointless and it really doesn't change the game, I agree.
I'll say that this is not exclusive to games. The world is changing, especially as more women are lent the directorial reigns in projects.

So, yes, stuff like this isn't "written off" as often these days, nor should it be.
_49d0b35a-c03a-11ea-8992-80e4e5da9aac.jpg
 

Son of Sparda

The Wise Ones
Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,608
I always thought they did a pretty good job recreating Yvonne Strahovski's likeness. Certainly better than some other contemporary examples... like Jessica Chobot in ME3.
Idk, to me she feels a bit fake/doll like (and I know her backstory, but instead of looking "perfect" she felt unnatural). Same with Jessica Chobot in ME3, but obviously she looked worse in comparison.
 

Beth Cyra

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
2,903
This is an awful post. I genuinely thought Resetera was beyond this.
Friend their are people who try to justify the CDPR's treatment of Women and Trans people on this site.

This thread is sadly no where near as bad as it is.

Let alone when our Black or Asian Community try to speak out about objectification/harmful imagery.
 

EvilBoris

Prophet of Truth - HDTVtest
Verified
Oct 29, 2017
16,683
I'm using the term fanservice correctly as it is mostly male titillation as you call it. Which again, there is nothing wrong with it. And it may not be 1960 but to give you an example, Game of Thrones was the most popular show of the last decade and had gratutious nudity every other episode. I guess you were also against it and if they remade it you'll want all those scenes removed?
I'd be quite happy , I thought it was unnecessary and added nothing to the show at all.

Also , something being popular doesn't meant it's a good thing.
 

rras1994

Member
Nov 4, 2017
5,742
I'll be honest, if you really can't remember how this series is treating it's Minorities (hell not even just women, there are plenty of PoC that have issues with how their characters are written, and everyone of those critiques are valid) then maybe you shouldn't be trying to defend this shit.

Especially when BioWare wouldn't even bring themselves to say FemShep and Liara where a LBGT ship, FemShep was totally straight and fell for a non gendered Alien remember and your argument was they had *gay* relationships.
Honestly Mass Effect is mainly seen as a progressive series because it was one of the few gaming series that actually let you play as a woman and have some content made for it and even have some minorities too. It always had issues it needed to improve and was behind in some areas compared to another series by the same company , Dragon Age which had LGBT romances in the first game and said they were unlike Mass Effect 1 (still had issues needed improving as well which they are getting better at and I hope the criticism makes it even better for DA4). Honestly Mass Effect was only seen as progressive not because it actually was that progressive but that the normal in the game industry was so god damn low , it was an easy bar to clear.

And I'm saying this as someone who is a big fan of BioWare games
 

vastick

Banned
May 4, 2019
132
"In spite of" or "because of"?

Because something can be a hit in spite of many problematic areas.

A vast number of women said they were fans of the show and requested the titillation be turned down. That INCLUDES the actual actresses who were in the show and who were very uncomfortable with a lot of what was being asked of them.
Neither in spite or because of. Most people including women have no issue with nudity. Mass effect is a ten year old series with a big fanbase of both men and women and Miranda is a fan favorite. She has never been seen as a lesser character because of a couple of gratuitous ass shots. There was never an outcry for this to be removed at all.
 

Kinthey

Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
22,310
The issue was this WASN'T "the point". Many of those shots were there during moments of a character talking about her trauma or pleading with you to save someone's life. The game's script and character were at odds with what the camera was focusing on.

It's all about context. If you romance her, guess what? She'll drag you to the maintenance deck and start getting freaky, because that's sort of presentation makes sense for the context of the scenario that's being presented to you... not during a key point of a character expressing her vulnerabilities or talking about her abuse.

So if instead of removing the shots they moved them to the romance path, would that be a way to make everyone happy?
 

gig

Prophet of Regret
Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,273
Also to the folks going "there's nothing wrong with it!!!" -- are we forgetting what video game culture has been for the past, what, two decades? Come on. This type of shit plays into the shittiness in some people (or attracts those susceptible to sexism) and brings out awful things over time.
 
Neither in spite or because of. Most people including women have no issue with nudity. Mass effect is a ten year old series with a big fanbase of both men and women and Miranda is a fan favorite. She has never been seen as a lesser character because of a couple of gratuitous ass shots. There was never an outcry for this to be removed at all.
This post is soo full of shit
 

Garlador

Banned
Oct 30, 2017
14,131
Neither in spite or because of. Most people including women have no issue with nudity. Mass effect is a ten year old series with a big fanbase of both men and women and Miranda is a fan favorite. She has never been seen as a lesser character because of a couple of gratuitous ass shots. There was never an outcry for this to be removed at all.
This is revisionist history, because I was there on the Bioware Social Network, talking with the female players, and 1) there were complaints at the time that the shots were denigrating to her character and 2) there absolutely were criticisms of it and requests to fix it.

Fans literally uploaded mods to fix it.

So if instead of removing the shots they moved them to the romance path, would that be a way to make everyone happy?
There's no need to do that because they ALREADY DO THIS if once you get her romance scene. But that's because it's the appropriate context and not, you know, when she's talking to you about her past abuse and her fears for her sister's life.
 

L Thammy

Spacenoid
Member
Oct 25, 2017
50,018
I'm pretty sure that 90% of the screenshots of Mass Effect I've seen were of Miranda's ass. I don't think I've ever actively searched for pictures of Miranda's ass.
 

Deleted member 90924

User requested account closure
Banned
Jan 29, 2021
821
People are so purposefully obtuse about shit like this. "It didn't bother me bc I like dem cheeks, therefore you're a prude."
 

rras1994

Member
Nov 4, 2017
5,742
Neither in spite or because of. Most people including women have no issue with nudity. Mass effect is a ten year old series with a big fanbase of both men and women and Miranda is a fan favorite. She has never been seen as a lesser character because of a couple of gratuitous ass shots. There was never an outcry for this to be removed at all.
And you know this cus you've talked to every woman in the fandom??? Cus I've been asking this to be removed for a long time on this forum and I'm not the only woman that's mentioned it here either, and it's not exactly an unpopular suggestion I've seen around the fandom circle from female players. So maybe don't speak for us at all?
 

Beth Cyra

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
2,903
Neither in spite or because of. Most people including women have no issue with nudity. Mass effect is a ten year old series with a big fanbase of both men and women and Miranda is a fan favorite. She has never been seen as a lesser character because of a couple of gratuitous ass shots. There was never an outcry for this to be removed at all.
Do you identify as a woman?

I ask because your statement no one ever cared is factually wrong.

Hell I love Miranda, love sexy women, and I love Mass Effect.

From day 1 I've never been okay with an abuse victim being ogled thanks, and there are many women just like me on this.
 

Biestmann

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,412
This forum is mostly progressive towards certain parties more than others. Want proof? See how long a POC or black-centric gaming thread lasts outside the month of February. Way less long than troll threads. Also think about how long it took mods to finally realize that people saying "who?"in every black musical artist thread is a little fucked up.

What you're dealing with here is a game that's a rare time capsule to an age where marketing thought white dudes with guns and sex sells. It should be insulting to you that they're pandering for easy brownie points by changing a few camera angles because it's a remaster instead of doing an overhaul of most of all of the sexist stuff in the game. I could bring up the fact that there's only about 5 negroes in the entire galaxy of Mass Effect(and one of them is modeled after fucking Kanye West) and be upset about it, but I understand the fact that this game is a time capsule to a weirder, more marketed time.

I don't want to play the game of "who has it worse" with you.

The horse in the race I have is for the next title, not this old set of titles that have been slightly altered to win some points with certain parties.

You're doing a weird back-pedal and muddying the waters here. RecLib wasn't playing "who has it worse" with you, she rightfully pointed our you downplaying the objectifying portrayal of women in this series. You can bet your ass she wouldn't come into a thread about shit black representation in a game to tell everyone she can find bad portrayal of white people in that same game too. It's possible to be respectful about the want for better representation of women and people of color both.
 

mentallyinept

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,403
So, if I'm reading this right, they cut out scenes that focused on girls asses for seemingly no reason, but left the sex scenes for when you get together with another character?

Which... sounds completely fair?
 

Deleted member 3208

Oct 25, 2017
11,934
Good; those shots shouldn't have been there. Now, can we change the outfits of many characters like Miranda or ME3 Ashley?
 

FormatCompatible

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
12,071
Neither in spite or because of. Most people including women have no issue with nudity. Mass effect is a ten year old series with a big fanbase of both men and women and Miranda is a fan favorite. She has never been seen as a lesser character because of a couple of gratuitous ass shots. There was never an outcry for this to be removed at all.
"Trust me I know females."
 

HStallion

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
62,262
Neither in spite or because of. Most people including women have no issue with nudity. Mass effect is a ten year old series with a big fanbase of both men and women and Miranda is a fan favorite. She has never been seen as a lesser character because of a couple of gratuitous ass shots. There was never an outcry for this to be removed at all.

A lot of women have complained about this since the games released. It's nothing new and you acting like it is, it's just revisionist history.
 

take_marsh

Member
Oct 27, 2017
7,267
It will certainly help mature the presentation of the game. There's a time and place to acknowledge the butts.

This change is great. I look forward to reflecting on some dialogue choices after many years too.
 

SnazzyNaz

The Wise Ones
Member
Nov 11, 2019
1,874
I'm using the term fanservice correctly as it is mostly male titillation as you call it. Which again, there is nothing wrong with it. And it may not be 1960 but to give you an example, Game of Thrones was the most popular show of the last decade and had gratutious nudity every other episode. I guess you were also against it and if they remade it you'll want all those scenes removed?
That's not a great example. I wasn't even really tuned in to GoT and I was well aware of that horrendous and gratuitous Sansa Stark scene.
 
Oct 30, 2017
15,278
It is a gratuitous shot and doesn't serve the plot. Glad it was removed.

All you nerds thirsting for some virtual nudity can easily Rule34 this shit. No need to harp on about it.
 

MilkBeard

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,780
Seems silly to be mad about this. Useless, juvenile, male-gazy type of shit like this is eye-rolling.