I wish character creation in games also allowed you to demo in sample cutscenes and gameplay situations.

[Arta]

Isn't it annoying to make a character in a creator, look at closeups against a white void or blank grid, maybe spin them around, then go into the gameplay and they look like horrible mannequins and you have to go back to redo them.

With the SSD speeds of modern consoles (minus the Switch), it would be cool if you could actually demo the character in gameplay environments and mock cutscenes before finalizing.

 

[Dice]

This would be cool. ....Or just make it easy to customize your face, i hate when stuff gets locked in.

 

[IronFalcon1997]

Isn't it annoying to make a character in a creator, look at closeups against a white void or blank grid, maybe spin them around, then go into the gameplay and they look like horrible mannequins and you have to go back to redo them.

With the SSD speeds of modern consoles (minus the Switch), it would be cool if you could actually demo the character in gameplay environments and mock cutscenes before finalizing.

Click to shrink...

Considering Xenoblade Chronicles X did this on the Wii U, I think it's something that's pretty achievable today lol

 

[TissueBox]

It's always funny how even with all the lighting options, posing options, and expression samples, the minute you chara gets thrown into action in-game, you can hear Frankenstein foaming in the background.

Been askin' for this for a while now from games but yeah, this actually being integrated would be an extreme QOL assist! ;)

 

[Gold Arsene]

Soooo many times I think I found a character I like just to hate them in cutscenes. I 'd love a feature like this.

 

[Viale]

In Ff14, I made a character that I absolutely loved. Booted into the game and only then realized how short they were compared to everyone else. Considering editing a characters appearence costs $10 each time, I was not happy. Would definitely have appreciated more instances to see the character in first.



.... Or just an easier way of editing the dang character. Locked in character appearence suuuucks.

 

[s y]

Off the top of my head, you can change the background/lighting setup during the character creation in Demons Souls, Monster Hunter World and Code Vein.

 

[Silvergun-Blue]

Cyberpunk was bad for this, the background and lighting for the creator was really dark so you didn't get a decent impression of how your character would look.

 

[Diabolique Veridis]

The new Demon's Souls remake's character creation looks quite authentic in-game for me although you don't really see your character's face that much in the game (I toggled helmets off though so I see him all the time). I think better-looking character creator is definitely on the card this gen. One possible alternative is to have the character creation happen in-game like in Greedfall (edit: and Fallout 4?) as the game starts with a cutscene of your character being painted by someone. Although the character creator in that game is not extensive at all, what you see is what you'll get if you have the character creation inside the game/cutscene itself instead of a separate blank background instance.

 

[Astral]

In Ff14, I made a character that I absolutely loved. Booted into the game and only then realized how short they were compared to everyone else. Considering editing a characters appearence costs $10 each time, I was not happy. Would definitely have appreciated more instances to see the character in first.



.... Or just an easier way of editing the dang character. Locked in character appearence suuuucks.

Click to shrink...

My character ended up being taller than every other female Hyur in the game lol. I'm pretty sure I made her like 5'6". I'm kinda cool with it though. Some characters are at least as tall.

I also remember making my Inquisitor in Dragon Age Inquisition and then realizing he had bigass cheekbones in cutscenes.

 

[Arta]

One possible alternative is to have the character creation happen in-game like in Greedfall (edit: and Fallout 4?) as the game starts with a cutscene of your character being painted by someone. Although the character creator in that game is not extensive at all, what you see is what you'll get if you have the character creation inside the game/cutscene itself instead of a separate blank background instance.

Click to shrink...

It was using the character creation in Greedfall 20 minutes ago that inspired this thread actually. Yes it's cool to see the character in the game world but here it's still in the character creation angle in an enclosed space. My player looked good in CC and then suddenly odd and stiff once we got to cutscenes and gameplay.

Once the game starts, you can't just simply go back and edit anything that looks bad.

 

[Mirage]

This would be cool. ....Or just make it easy to customize your face, i hate when stuff gets locked in.

Click to shrink...

More games need to be like Nioh 2 that just let you access the character creator whenever.

 

[Rats]

Just let me change anything about my appearance after initial creation is over, don't just limit it to hairstyles or whatever like some games do. I don't understand why facial structure is sacred. Let me worry about the immersion, game.

 

[Deleted member 33533]

Considering Xenoblade Chronicles X did this on the Wii U, I think it's something that's pretty achievable today lol

Click to shrink...

I did like how that character creator let you change the lighting between a couple of settings that you'd encounter in the game world so you could see what the character looks like in each setting. It was especially helpful when making a character with dark skin because sometimes in character creators, you think you've picked a certain skin tone but the lighting in game makes it look way lighter.

Also the game just straight up lets you change your avatar later on and no one ever questions it.

 

[Crushed]

I think I must have walked through the half destroyed Normandy at the start of ME2 at least 5 times trying to tweak my imported Shepard's face to look like they weren't a Neanderthal in game

 

[Diabolique Veridis]

It was using the character creation in Greedfall 20 minutes ago that inspired this thread actually. Yes it's cool to see the character in the game world but here it's still in the character creation angle in an enclosed space. My player looked good in CC and then suddenly odd and stiff once we got to cutscenes and gameplay.

Once the game starts, you can't just simply go back and edit anything that looks bad.

Click to shrink...

Yep true I think your point should still be the next step in character creation. Hopefully it'll be a thing somehow.

 

[Richietto]

At least they should include lighting presets. There are so many games that have the cc in lighting conditions that don't exist at all in game so you never have a clear picture of how they look until it's too late.

I don't understand why developers even insist on only being able to change the way your cc looks at the time of creation. Like who cares if I want to change them 5 minutes or 20 hours into the game? Worst yet is making you pay for it. Still can't believe Monster Hunter world made it a micro transaction. Like what is this an MMO???

I think I must have walked through the half destroyed Normandy at the start of ME2 at least 5 times trying to tweak my imported Shepard's face to look like they weren't a Neanderthal in game

Click to shrink...

fuckin for real. Was so frustrating.

 

[Zaied]

As long as I can customize my character after starting the game (Fallout 4, Skyrim, Dragon's Dogma, Andromeda, etc.) it's not a dealbreaker for me. But when that option doesn't exist like in Cyberpunk 2077 recently, it really does become an annoyance, so this would definitely be a helpful addition to games like that.

 

[Cerulean_skylark]

ffxiv benchmarks let you create a character which is then inserted into the benchmarking cutscene. It can be a bit tough to get the best picture but it certainly helps.

 

[More_Badass]

Also letting you preview how helmets and face coverings will look on your created character. Really annoying to make a character with beards or long hair and the hair is clipping through your armor and masks

 

[SunKing]

Agreed.

I can't tell you how many times I replayed the prologue of Dragon Age: Inquisition because I finally saw my character in cutscenes and everything was off.

 

[hwalker84]

I hate my character in Cyberpunk but I thought (Oh well I'll change the character later because a game like this you'll definitely be able to later)..... sigh

 

[KORNdog]

And here's me just wanting to be able to make my character fat. Lol.

 

[Richietto]

I hate my character in Cyberpunk but I thought (Oh well I'll change the character later because a game like this you'll definitely be able to later)..... sigh

Click to shrink...

I still can't believe the game doesn't have a plastic surgery vendor. Like I thought we would be able to fully cyberize our characters but nope. Can't change your face and all you get is some mantis blades or gorilla arms. Laaame.

 

[Deleted member 59126]

I couldn't agree with you more.

 

[Spring-Loaded]

ffxiv benchmarks let you create a character which is then inserted into the benchmarking cutscene. It can be a bit tough to get the best picture but it certainly helps.

Click to shrink...

I was about to say, this thread concept sounds like benchmarks. sounds like a great idea

 

[Urishizu]

My Mass Effect 1 character with a somehow incredibly long neck that only shows in cutscenes agrees with you.

 

[dancingphlower]

Absolutely. Just recently I made a character in Cyberpunk and started over after about 15 minutes because I just didn't like how my character looked in Photo Mode.

 

[Magog]

And here's me just wanting to be able to make my character fat. Lol.

Click to shrink...

Much more challenging from a technical standpoint as then the clothing all has to be able to change too.

 

[batfax]

PSO2's character creation demo did exactly this back in 2012. Also served as a benchmark test.

No idea why it's not more common.

 

[Phellps]

Yeah, at least have a few different background and lighting options during creation to allow you to test the character in various environments.

Or, the bare minimum, allow us to edit the character mid-game. At least that way we can try to fix it.

 

[KORNdog]

Much more challenging from a technical standpoint as then the clothing all has to be able to change too.

Click to shrink...

I'm sure it is. But dragon's dogma and saints row managed it. I'm sure most other Devs could too.

 

[Magog]

I'm sure it is. But dragon's dogma and saints row managed it. I'm sure most other Devs could too.

Click to shrink...

Two great games. Allowing you to create not only your main character but also your sidekicks was a great part of Dragon's Dogma along with the rather epic battle system. Saint's Row for me was great because it emphasized fun while GTA was going for Eastern European cousin simulator and midlife crisis misery simulator.

 

[JumbiePrime]

Nothing like spending a ridiculous amount of time making a character just for them to start speaking and it's like

 

[Chance_Boudreaux]

The amount of times I've started over immediately upon entering the game is ridiculous at this point. I hate spending hours making the perfect character only to find the nose suddenly looks massive due to in-game lighting.

I think a little demo area with proper lighting/shadows and basic enemies to attack would be perfect. It would also be beneficial for those of us who spend hours obsessively tweaking options like brightness, controller sensitivity, etc. Typically the first few hours of every game I'm constantly going into settings to change things as I enter new areas with different lighting or come across new enemies. If I could do that in a little tutorial area, boy that would be lovely!

 

[Jiraiya]

Not gonna lie...i rarely make bad looking characters even on the first try. I'll still take the options to do them anytime after or use in game environments.

 

[Deleted member 37928]

To take this a step even further I would like to look at combat animations in the creation menu also. My dream feature would be a button press that got rid of the menu and then gave you direct control over the character, kind of like the loading screens in Bayonetta.

 

[IronFalcon1997]

I did like how that character creator let you change the lighting between a couple of settings that you'd encounter in the game world so you could see what the character looks like in each setting. It was especially helpful when making a character with dark skin because sometimes in character creators, you think you've picked a certain skin tone but the lighting in game makes it look way lighter.

Also the game just straight up lets you change your avatar later on and no one ever questions it.

Click to shrink...

They even have a lore reason for why you can do this and it makes perfect sense! I love the amount of thought that Monolithsoft puts into their games

 

[AndyD]

I wonder if it's because cut scenes and live action sometimes uses different resolutions or mesh maps.

 

[Man Called Aerodynamics]

I can't tell you how many times I replayed the prologue of Dragon Age: Inquisition because I finally saw my character in cutscenes and everything was off.

Click to shrink...

Dragon Age Inquisition is the all time worst offender because character creation takes place in the Fade which is dim and tinted green.

All games should let you re-customize your appearance at any time. No excuse.

 

[Deleted member 864]

I love when games (like Code Vein and Xenoblade Chronicles X) give you different lighting samples to test what your character will look like in them during the CC process.

Any other options like this would be great.

 

[hwalker84]

I still can't believe the game doesn't have a plastic surgery vendor. Like I thought we would be able to fully cyberize our characters but nope. Can't change your face and all you get is some mantis blades or gorilla arms. Laaame.

Click to shrink...

I couldn't even fathom that this type of game wouldn't have a plastic surgery vendor. The thought never crossed my mind or i would've spent another hour.

 

[Morrigan]

Off the top of my head, you can change the background/lighting setup during the character creation in Demons Souls, Monster Hunter World and Code Vein.

Click to shrink...

Nioh 2 as well

 

[Flandy]

Would be nice if games just let you change character appearance at any time

I think I must have walked through the half destroyed Normandy at the start of ME2 at least 5 times trying to tweak my imported Shepard's face to look like they weren't a Neanderthal in game

Click to shrink...

This is why I just settled on default Shepard. My original shepard was horrific. Honestly tempted to dig out my PS3 to see how bad he looks