I want to talk about that scene in The Last Jedi ... *Spoilers*

[Midramble]

OP, this is your second "I don't like TLJ" thread in a week. I've come to hate the discourse around TLJ. Couldn't you just, ya know, bump your own thread? Are you going to talk about another thing you don't like about it next week? Was hoping this forum would someday get this movie out of their system.

 

[AnansiThePersona]

oh look another TLJ thread on era

Click to shrink...

*checks calendar*

...yep. It's a day ending in "y" alright

 

[matrix-cat]

When I sit down to watch a film the two questions at the top of my mind at all times are "Is this the most logical and efficient thing for the characters to do in this scene?" and "Would this actually work as depicted if performed in real life?".

I have never enjoyed a film.

 

[El Bombastico]

OP, this is your second "I don't like TLJ" thread in a week. I've come to hate the discourse around TLJ. Couldn't you just, ya know, bump your own thread? Are you going to talk about another thing you don't like about it next week? Was hoping this forum would someday get this movie out of their system.

Click to shrink...

Its been 20 years since the Prequels and people still haven't moved on. TLJ is, somehow, even MORE divisive, so don't expect anyone to get it out of their system any time soon.

 

[Bishop89]

 

[J2C]

Was weird af. Didn't feel it, didn't make sense physically, didn't believe the character would even do such a thing. Nevermind the lack of romantic build or chemistry, and the forced upon kiss.

 

[OneTrueJack]

Dude, it's a movie.

That's like asking if it's smart to blow up the Death Star when some rebel ships might still be in range.

This is why no one likes talking to Star Wars fans.

 

[Morrigan]

You literally already made a thread about TLJ a few days ago. We don't need a second one just for one scene.