I really liked it, but the best comparison I can draw is that it's the Force Awakens of the Terminator franchise. How much you like it is going to depend on how okay you are with "Lets do what the old movies did, but here and now and with more wokeness". And I do not mean that entirely disparagingly, I think on some level it's good that Hollywood is recreating beloved stories with representation that wasn't there before, but if your gonna make a Terminator version of TFA, you need to then atleast follow it up with the Terminator version of The Last Jedi for innovation purposes.
I think the action in this film, particularly the factory fight scene (which I immediately rewound and watched 2 more times when I rented this on VOD), is the best action since T2, easily. Mostly because it rides on the intensity and power of Mackenzie Davis, who is a *powerhouse* in this movie.
I watched it this past week. It's very flawed. The writing is, at times, cringey, and Linda Hamilton unfortunately gets some clunkers. There are some really contrived plot developments that make you scratch your head and keep the film from being great.
Having said that, like I said, it's *easily* better than any of the post T2 sequels and introduces some fun, if not "out there", ideas.
-I don't know why the John Connor twist was so reviled. It reminded me of one of my favorite aspects of T3, actually: that a certain fate was inevitable, inescapable, or at least unable to be foreseen by humanity. It makes complete sense that Skynet would send multiple Terminators back at multiple points in time as a failsafe. It's heartbreaking, but fits completely with the world that T1/T2 established. I'm not surprised it was Cameron's idea, TBH.
-Having a Mexican lead/hero, set against the backdrop of immigration, sanctuaries, etc. was a great way to evolve the story. I teared up when they realized that she "is" John. Really, a fantastic, modern progression of a story that has been retold over and over again.
-I love Carl. Maybe it seems silly in context of the Terminator series, but it's a fascinating bit of sci-fi to wonder what a sentient(?) machine would do after it performs its mission.
-Mackenzie Davis--fucking wow. I'm almost okay with this movie bombing, because I don't think there would be any way to continue the story without her. She gave this movie the energy it needed and really made the action scenes feel important and *real*. She had a physicality that perfectly hit all the notes it needed to.
The movie has lots of issues. Aside from those I mentioned, the CG is occasionally pretty dodgy, Diego Luna is just fine as a boring assassin Rev whatever terminator, etc. But, I still really enjoyed it.