I was briefly a moderator for a big Minecraft YouTuber. It was all right, but there was a lot of drama over a new server being made when I joined.
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Have you ever been a moderator of a community?
- Thread starter SolVanderlyn
- Start date
Yeah, long time ago.
Then they brought in some guy named Sean, iirc, and was pretty clueless. He wanted the boards to be liked Reddit - whatever that meant.
Then since he didn't want much to do with the boards, he elevated some mods to a type of council and he called the whole thing a "beerocracy". And that didn't sit right with me. It used to be that all mods were equal. And then they weren't.
The boards were never that important to IGN. They kept making it harder and harder to access the boards from the front page. And they rarely had engineers assigned to fixing or improving the boards.
I was an admin for TheForce.Net forums during a time long ago, when the ancient mods were petty and cruel, and plagued their users with suffering.
This was a time before best practices and when everyone was trying to figure out how to moderate large forums. Everyone was jumping from newsgroups and CompuServe/Prodigy/AOL to the web, and the forum layout that everyone takes for granted now was still new.
We were on one of the earliest versions of UBB, which ran on Perl, making the technical side as difficult as the social side of administrating a community.
It was difficult. Cliques formed, sides were chosen, favorites were protected and moderation was often up to the whims of the individual mods. There was no appeal, no reconsideration, and no real mercy. The mods hung together like cops and protected their own.
Overall, it was a pretty educational experience. We were probably one of the first communities to experience forum drama in all of its nascent and myriad forms, especially as the user base grew and changed, which presented a real challenge to those who'd been there since the beginning and who used their mod privileges to try and forcibly keep the forum from evolving and changing.
And then Episode I was released...
This was a time before best practices and when everyone was trying to figure out how to moderate large forums. Everyone was jumping from newsgroups and CompuServe/Prodigy/AOL to the web, and the forum layout that everyone takes for granted now was still new.
We were on one of the earliest versions of UBB, which ran on Perl, making the technical side as difficult as the social side of administrating a community.
It was difficult. Cliques formed, sides were chosen, favorites were protected and moderation was often up to the whims of the individual mods. There was no appeal, no reconsideration, and no real mercy. The mods hung together like cops and protected their own.
Overall, it was a pretty educational experience. We were probably one of the first communities to experience forum drama in all of its nascent and myriad forms, especially as the user base grew and changed, which presented a real challenge to those who'd been there since the beginning and who used their mod privileges to try and forcibly keep the forum from evolving and changing.
And then Episode I was released...
I did on a THQ/EA forum for many years. I liked it when I was still passionate about the game, after that I quit. They both had outdated boards so when some troll ran some porn spam bot, I had to deleted everything manually for hours. And he could get around their bans in minutes. It was pretty terrible.
EA didn't upgrade shit until I threatened to quit, then they finally put up some new boards.
EA didn't upgrade shit until I threatened to quit, then they finally put up some new boards.
I've been a moderator of a bunch of subreddits for years, some big, some small. I think I'm really good at what I do, I def feel like if it were the right fit with my experience in challenging spaces I could mod anywhere reasonably well with a bit of an adjustment period, it's a fun hobby most of the time. It's kind of like how people say everyone should have to work retail for a while to understand what it's like on that end, I feel like it would be cool if people who used forums understood all that goes into keeping a community active and monitored. From a user perspective sometimes things can seem really simple when that isn't always the case!
I spent a depressing amount of time in IGN Chat back in the day.
The day Metal Gear Solid 2 was announced for the Xbox was a shitstorm of fanboys screaming at each other.
Heck, I had an IGN email.
I had the same thing at one point. We ended up disabling the ability to add images across the network with a hot fix. The shit I saw in the live feed before it hit the site. Fuck, that shit stays with you.
I really get this because I have no idea how to handle stuff like this either.
I was a mod and administrator at a little comic book forum in spanish years ago, till life, work etc got in the way. It was fun, but a lot of work
Hey, man! Was a mod around the same time you were on Gamespot...mostly OT, 311Music was my username. Nice to see an old face!
I was a mod for a pretty popular twitch channel for a couple of years.
And it honestly wasn't that bad since the streamer was cool with straight up permabanning assholes.
This ended up creating a great culture where modding was hardly needed, usually just spam links and backseating.
It did make me paranoid that people only thought my jokes were funny because I was a mod though lol
And it honestly wasn't that bad since the streamer was cool with straight up permabanning assholes.
This ended up creating a great culture where modding was hardly needed, usually just spam links and backseating.
It did make me paranoid that people only thought my jokes were funny because I was a mod though lol
in the mid-2000s, I was very active on a Star Wars forum while in my early teens. At some point, I decided I was going to pretend to be 30 years old when speaking to other users on MSN and struck up a friendship with the forum owner who eventually made me a mod. I wasn't rumbled until about 2010 when someone discovered my FB but by that point I was completely inactive on the forum.
That's definitely the thing about twitch chats is they can be really good as long as they're handled well like that.
When I was a 90s kid I was on an email list, and ended up being one of the main posters and took over the admin of it. I think I might have been kind of a dick, but I don't think I banned anyone too unfairly.
Having been on the inside of several mod group chats without ever actually being one myself, I've seen first hand the mental toll it causes and how it basically forces you to become a horrible person. It's not for me.
I was a moderator on the electric playground forums way back but it wasn't super active and thus very chill.
I was a mod in a couple of private groups on bungie.net back in the day. Nothing terribly special there though. Whole place was a meme!
Right now I'm again a forum mod on finalfantasyforums.net and while activity isn't what it used to be, the rest of staff and the regulars are great people and I very rarely have to do anything beyond the occasional spam clean / tidy up.
Right now I'm again a forum mod on finalfantasyforums.net and while activity isn't what it used to be, the rest of staff and the regulars are great people and I very rarely have to do anything beyond the occasional spam clean / tidy up.
I was a moderator for many years at IGN until I realized I was a moderator for many years at IGN then I wasn't anymore.
Several times. It left me a jaded cynical bitter person for the longest time. Dealing with cliques, groups or people who didn't like you based on who you interacted with, shit gets thrown around. It's crazy. These days I don't give a fuck much. I just post and that's about it.
I was a gamespot moderator for a short time. It was somewhat fun, but I felt isolated from the community.
I am an admin for a horror group on Facebook. It used to be pretty crazy, but the group has mellowed out over the years and it's really just a core group of people now.
Yes. I used to be a moderator back in the days of the PSP home brew scene for a no longer active site called Quickjump. One of my favorite time periods for gaming. I used to enjoy being knee deep in conversations involving home brew and enjoyed even more when I maintained threads with tons of homebrew applications for PSP where I would customize majority of it myself.
Beyond that I was also a moderator on a few message boards and at once point I was also an administrator on a Kingdom Hearts fan board during the KH2 days.
Now I feel old.
Beyond that I was also a moderator on a few message boards and at once point I was also an administrator on a Kingdom Hearts fan board during the KH2 days.
Now I feel old.
Yes.
I moderated in one of the most vile and infamous Spanish-speaking dens of gaming of all time: Atomix Forums.
If you guys think gamefaqs and all that are bad, you'd no idea then.
And I'd so much fun with the community back then lol
I moderated in one of the most vile and infamous Spanish-speaking dens of gaming of all time: Atomix Forums.
If you guys think gamefaqs and all that are bad, you'd no idea then.
And I'd so much fun with the community back then lol
Last edited:
Yeah, the old place from somewhere around 2012-2013 until the collapse.
There was a lot of bullshit we had to deal with but I made a lot of friends in the staff I still keep in touch with.
There was a lot of bullshit we had to deal with but I made a lot of friends in the staff I still keep in touch with.
Yes. An Official MMO forum 16-17 years ago
I mostly just clean up the swearing, Illegal links and spams.
I mostly just clean up the swearing, Illegal links and spams.
I was a moderator a couple of times, all of which were in the Godzilla/tokusatsu/kaiju community.
I was a mod for Gojistomp for many years before also becoming a mod over at Tokyo Monsters for a handful of years as well.
I eventually moved on post Godzilla Final Wars when the series "ended."
I was a mod for Gojistomp for many years before also becoming a mod over at Tokyo Monsters for a handful of years as well.
I eventually moved on post Godzilla Final Wars when the series "ended."
