this is deeply embarrassing behavior and y'all need to rethink your priorities
have some compassion, numbers on a website are the last thing to be holding up as important at the moment
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Half-Life: Alyx - Review Thread
- Thread starter vestan
- Start date
this is deeply embarrassing behavior and y'all need to rethink your priorities
have some compassion, numbers on a website are the last thing to be holding up as important at the moment
User Banned (5 Days): Antagonizing other members
I just died laughing at the mental image of a man crying while wearing a VR headset. Thank you
If there wasn't a score, I doubt many of the people here would have a problem with the reviewer bringing up Covid-19.
Also, who cares about the score anyway? It's not as if it's drastically lower than the rest - 8/10 is still very good - and the reviewer had other issues which people seem to be disregarding.
I'm getting shades of when Eurogamer gave Uncharted 3 an 8/10 and some people went spare because of it...
I would be fired if I take my personal feelings into reviews. I want to know what is good about the product and not what is currently happening too. If someone is unable to review it currently they should be honest and just not do it. Ugh. I don't care about this review and haven't read one yet and surely won't, but it's not a great look for me in this case. Products are reviewed on the product alone.
Right that's what others were reporting. The person said that someone indicated it was 60hertz. Which it is not locked at and my testing software that checks that was not indicating it.
Contagion is a film from 2011. If Contagion released today, there would be plenty of VentureBeat-esque reviews for it.
It's a tricky needle to thread, how much of our real-life issues we bring in. For example, my review is already freakishly long, so I removed an anecdote about the game being a respite from the pandemic news swirl in my home city of Seattle. HL:A is so immersive that I could strap in, play for 2-3 hour chunks, and let go. My anxiety manifests in physical symptoms (chest pressure, coughing), and going into HL:A made those go away. I felt like I'd made that kind of point with other anecdotes and praise, so I cut it.
Ah the old personal bias debate for reviews. A tale as old as time. I don't think there's a right or wrong answer to this one personally, it's just a matter of what you want out of a review. Do you want a straight up analysis of a game in a vacuum unclouded by personal biases beyond maybe comparisons to other games, or do you want to hear the emotional response the game elicited that will be influenced by their personal experiences? I can see a case for both and I can see how both could go wrong (or right). In the end, you should just pay attention to the reviewers or outlets that align with your tastes and not worry about the rest because they're more or less irrelevant to you.
Anyone legit giving you grief for that is an idiot.
Last edited:
A post-apocalyptic world with an alien race of super-soldiers and mutant aliens is barely related to a real world pandemic. Mention it if you truly want to as a passing remark, but it just doesn't make sense to say the game is worsened (at this time) because of said pandemic, and your own playthrough will be worsened as well.
I don't think that people is complaining about the score, but instead about the comparison to the current day situation, which feels unwarranted.
Well, the pandemic isn't the only reason it got marked down if any. Seems like its just a mention in the review and the reviewer stated the other issues they found with the game.
Its funny because people were saying earlier that the "bad" reviews are going to dock it for VR legs - like reviewers aren't allowed to. The reality is, its clearly an issue with a sizeable population of people that want/will play the game and should continue to be mentioned accordingly.
The responses to that post from this community are fucking disgusting. This is now the second journalist who is a community member here who has been dog piled for sharing their opinion in less than a week. Idk why they even post here with shit like this.
That isn't my point. It is the fact people are home due to this virus and watching a movie about one that is even worse.
People want to be entertained now more than ever and a movie about a virus is what people want to see on Netflix right now in an entire Nation.
High tier stupid comment tbh
---
I'm glad gamers just refuse to grow up and have a fundamental disconnect with what media critique is.
If the review text were exactly the same but they had given it a 9, I kinda doubt it would be a very contentious issue at all.
Exactly. You can't review cultural products in a vacuum. Also, he made it clear that he isn't very much into horror games to begin with and he said the game is too grim and scary to be as fun as HL2 for him. The pandemic is just an aggravating factor.
That sounds absolutely fair, not every element will be able to be explored without the need for clarity, editing and the like.
I just bristle at the idea that there are some saying that it's completely the wrong approach to do so when biases are inevitable
Go call and check in on your parents and grandparents.
Its absolutely embarrassing.
Nice reviews.... wish I had someway to play though....only have a ps vr... Plus my current pc is shit
Yeah but it's the current low score, so people are going to find their reasons to invalidate the review itself.
That's because those reviews affected the Metacritic score for Animal Crossing positively whereas this one review is having a negative affect on Alyx's MC score. No one would care about this review if not for the Metacritic score being so "important".
This is why I dislike aggregate review sites.
Sorry Patrick. People are being assholes in this thread. The reason you became emotional is completely understandable to any reasonable person with the capacity for empathy.
Videogames aren't a "product", they are a work of art that makes you have feelings.
Not at all. We are saying that Valve made the decision to release this game in this climate, and this can be the result. Someone played the game and had a negative (I don't think it impacted the score) experience because of the health crisis ongoing. Should Valve delayed it because of this? Are there really themes in this game related enough to warrant that? Or did you not enjoy it cause it was scary and sad and you don't want to be scary and sad when gaming right now?
If it's the second, I don't think it has a place in the review. If it's a thematic, story, or character relation issue, I think that's important to include and consider.
Oh if I'm tracing the convo back right, they were specifically talking about RE7 on PSVR which I believe runs at 60hz and interpolates up to 120. Though if you're saying that runs unlocked I'll defer to you.
The real joke is.. those posts i'm talking about were made before the reviews even came out. lol
Game looks incredible from watching my friend play it. Will play once I have a spare 1k bucks I guess
lol. No, it's always about the score and searching for some way to conjure up a reason to discount it.
I really don't have a dog in this fight, but the review starts out specifically stating they wished they didn't have to play the game right now, as it seemed unimportant at this time. This would imply the only reason they posted this review right here and now is for numbers on a website (in this case hits). They could have easily postponed the review so the reviewer could handle their personal issues.
This comes down to this being a job, simple as that. I wish I could be quarantined like the a large portion of the country, but I sill have to come into work and I can't really afford to half ass my job simply because I don't want to be here.
All that being said, this is just a game review, so who cares. The arguments for both sides just seem silly. People defending it are just as yawn inducing as the people crying that it got an 8 over a 9. Move on, get your reviews from elsewhere if you don't like it. Start clicking on them more if you do.
I do, I make sure there safe and and my brother who is immunocompromised. I'm an EMT and the pandemic is making every job in the medical field 10 times harder
It really is incredibly how people can't see themes unless it's literally taking a baseball to the back of their heads.
Headcrabs and zombies aren't analogous to a pandemic. The Combine aren't stand-ins for totalitarian fascism. They're just, duuuuhhhh....bad aliens.
What am I reading in here?
Leave your humanity at the door while playing games during a pandemic?
Don't write about being human while reviewing a game during a pandemic?
Don't have emotions while holding/wearing gaming gear because it would be too funny to imagine, no matter how the reviewer is feeling or the state of the world?
Disgusting, all of it.
Leave your humanity at the door while playing games during a pandemic?
Don't write about being human while reviewing a game during a pandemic?
Don't have emotions while holding/wearing gaming gear because it would be too funny to imagine, no matter how the reviewer is feeling or the state of the world?
Disgusting, all of it.
That's simply an assumption on your side. Personally speaking, the score doesn't bother me at all, but I do have qualms with a game depicting a fictional world being compared to our present day life.
I don't know what reviews threads have that turn some people into assholes.
The funny thing, is that if the personal experience of the reviewer had prompted him to put a higher score, the same people mocking him now, will be more than OK with his personally opinion being reflected on the score.
As someone that has only experienced VR with move controllers and a dualshock, how exactly does PC VR handle controls for a game like this? Does it have motion controllers that also have analog sticks on them? I can't imagine it's difficult to have motion controllers that are better than the terrible Moves, but exactly how much better are they?
I don't like using this GIF but you just earned yourself the grandaddy of 'em
In what way does coronavirus affect the craftsmanship of HL: Alyx?
"What an amazing game made even more visceral and emotionally affecting given the current situation in the world - 10/10"
Nobody would give a shit.