• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Fushichou187

Member
Nov 1, 2017
3,309
Sonoma County, California.
Most of the podcasts I listen to are in the realm of current events, geopolitics, IS, etc.. with a smattering of games-related podcasts-- mostly just Waypoint these days-- but I do love me some well-produced horror or strange fiction podcasts as they are excellent for long drives or commutes.

I used to listen to a bunch of different ones but have since been whittling down the list simply because either the production (mainly audio quality) or vocal talent is grating; I've also started to veer away from podcasts that are faux documentary in form since they tend to be way too earnest in trying to create a sense that their podcast is "real" e.g. badly done listener voicemail, stilted on-air exchanges with their "producer", etc.. terribly read ads or repeated patreon begs are a big turnoff as well.

Because of how much is out there these days I'd like to hear of any recommendations you might have on ones you personally like, or perhaps ones you think I might enjoy.

To give you an idea of podcasts I've listened to and really enjoyed, or still am listening to, here's a short list:

  • Tanis Season 1 (the other seasons devolve into convoluted gobbledygook)
  • The Black Tapes Season 1 (subsequent seasons have the same problem as Tanis)
  • Rabbits
  • Limetown
  • The Last Movie; still has some of the same irks as Tanis (for obvious reasons) but the 6-episode format keeps things tight enough that it doesn't go off the rails and up into its own ass.
  • The White Vault; I'm really enjoying the production, story, and acting in this one. Reminds me of Dark Adventure Radio Theatre.
  • Darkest Night
  • Welcome to Night Vale; Haven't listened to it in a long time but the first 40 episodes or so fueled some particularly long drives. I have listened to the first few episodes of Alice Isn't Dead and it didn't grab me unfortunately.
  • Wolverine: The Long Night; not horror but damn if it isn't well done.
  • Knifepoint Horror; The only one on here where there is a single narrator. I don't really listen to audiobooks because it's jarring for me to hear one person do several different voices, but since the stories here are usually read by the author himself, there is an evenness and confidence in their delivery that I really appreciate.
Honorable mention to Dark Adventure Radio Theatre that, while not a podcast, has produced some of the best radio dramas I've listened to hands down. It's all Lovecraft so if that's not your thing, I understand. Their voice talent and production is top tier in my opinion though.
 
Most of the podcasts I listen to are in the realm of current events, geopolitics, IS, etc.. with a smattering of games-related podcasts-- mostly just Waypoint these days-- but I do love me some well-produced horror or strange fiction podcasts as they are excellent for long drives or commutes.

I used to listen to a bunch of different ones but have since been whittling down the list simply because either the production (mainly audio quality) or vocal talent is grating; I've also started to veer away from podcasts that are faux documentary in form since they tend to be way too earnest in trying to create a sense that their podcast is "real" e.g. badly done listener voicemail, stilted on-air exchanges with their "producer", etc.. terribly read ads or repeated patreon begs are a big turnoff as well.

Because of how much is out there these days I'd like to hear of any recommendations you might have on ones you personally like, or perhaps ones you think I might enjoy.

To give you an idea of podcasts I've listened to and really enjoyed, or still am listening to, here's a short list:

  • Tanis Season 1 (the other seasons devolve into convoluted gobbledygook)
  • The Black Tapes Season 1 (subsequent seasons have the same problem as Tanis)
  • Rabbits
  • Limetown
  • The Last Movie; still has some of the same irks as Tanis (for obvious reasons) but the 6-episode format keeps things tight enough that it doesn't go off the rails and up into its own ass.
  • The White Vault; I'm really enjoying the production, story, and acting in this one. Reminds me of Dark Adventure Radio Theatre.
  • Darkest Night
  • Welcome to Night Vale; Haven't listened to it in a long time but the first 40 episodes or so fueled some particularly long drives. I have listened to the first few episodes of Alice Isn't Dead and it didn't grab me unfortunately.
  • Wolverine: The Long Night; not horror but damn if it isn't well done.
  • Knifepoint Horror; The only one on here where there is a single narrator. I don't really listen to audiobooks because it's jarring for me to hear one person do several different voices, but since the stories here are usually read by the author himself, there is an evenness and confidence in their delivery that I really appreciate.
Honorable mention to Dark Adventure Radio Theatre that, while not a podcast, has produced some of the best radio dramas I've listened to hands down. It's all Lovecraft so if that's not your thing, I understand. Their voice talent and production is top tier in my opinion though.

Bizarre several months bump because I was searching for the exact same thing you are here and your thread popped up. I noticed that you didn't get any recommendations and haven't got a certain gem on your list, so here's one for you: while the chance is small that you haven't since been recommended it, I highly suggest the Magnus Archives. Fantastic stuff, right up your alley.

The No Sleep podcast is also good for standalone stuff. Loved the White Vault, btw!
 

Rivenblade

Member
Nov 1, 2017
37,116
I just finished Tanis season 1. I'm going to continue listening. I liked Nick's interview and how they described everything after he got out. I think I mostly enjoy the tone and mystery of the thing.
 

Fat4all

Woke up, got a money tag, swears a lot
Member
Oct 25, 2017
92,528
here
im more into true crime podcasts, tho the two often intersect
 

BWoog

Member
Oct 27, 2017
38,246
I'll second Wolverine: The Long Night. Listened to it on a long car trip all in one go and it was fantastic.
 

Harp

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,206
For true crime stuff, I can't recommend enough Crimetown and In the Dark. For slightly less quality, but still engrossing, check out Dr. Death and Dirty John.

For an intersection of true crime, occult, horror, and conspiracy, definitely The Last Podcast on the Left, but they're ultra popular now so you've all likely heard of them.

For weird fiction, Conversations from the Abyss is great. It's not always the highest quality, but it's consistently entertaining, and they're deep into their second season now.

But the two I absolutely must recommend you all check out:

King Falls AM - Styled as a late night/early morning talk show in a sleepy, weird, creepy PNW town. It's more fun and entertaining than it is creepy or horror, but it definitely fills that Twin Peaks niche. It's also conversational, with two hosts and a massive cast of fun side characters, so I generally enjoy it a lot more than Welcome to Nightvale, which I bounced off of hard. There are definitely elements of Nightvale I enjoy, but as a whole, I find the production to be rather messy and difficult to listen to on any sort of regular basis. King Falls AM, meanwhile, is always a delight. Half-hour episodes every two weeks, and they just started a new season.

As I said, it's more fun than it is scary, but it defniitely still has the horror flavor. The town has a local rich aristocrat that's actually a vampire, there are mysterious rainbow lights in the sky, abductions, clones, shadow organizations, corrupt leaders, ghosts, and werewolves. But at the end of the day, it's also two dudes talking shit while all this goes on around them and affects their lives and relationships. Also, the local high school football team is the King Falls Lumberjacks, and their colors are plaid. How can you not love that?

The Magnus Archives - This podcast has just blown me away with it's quality. It's sort of like a podcast version of The Laundry Files novels, or the SCP wiki, but it takes itself very seriously. Styled as the taped recordings of old written archives of a shadowy British government organization that investigates the occult, it features the new director of The Magnus Institute reading transcripts of old cases. The cases are weird, creepy, Lovecraftian, and as time goes on they begin to intersect in ways that I'm legit impressed the creators are able to weave and manage so delicately.

It's very, VERY good, has a great subreddit, and even a wiki with handy synopses of the episodes. Most episodes are independent unless otherwise noted (there are a handful of part 1 and part 2 episodes), and I will say the first ten episodes are obviously the show finding ground and setting up a lot, but once you get past that first patch, I'd say the episodes are good probably 90% of the time, if not more. Well written, well acted, the asides that give the listener glimpses into the organization, the ways they weave together. It's fucking GREAT, and if you donate to their patreon, you get PDF transcripts of the stories, which can be read as if they were just short stories (because that's what they effectively are).

Go listen to The Magnus Archives right now if you're interested in occult, horror, and lovecraftian shit. There's over a hundred episodes, and I'm only in the 30's. It's so so good.
 

Dervius

Member
Oct 28, 2017
4,892
UK
I finished Limetown a couple weeks ago and bounced off of Alice Isn't Dead, but I'm liking the looks of The White Vault and The Magnus Archives.

Great thread.
 
I finished Limetown a couple weeks ago and bounced off of Alice Isn't Dead, but I'm liking the looks of The White Vault and The Magnus Archives.

Great thread.

Yep yep yep yep yep. Magnus is especially great because there are so damn many. I almost wept for joy when I found out how many episodes there were. When you find something that good, you don't want it to end.
 

Mars People

Comics Council 2020
Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,178
I was listening to a good one called Horroretc for a while.
But one day it just vanished :(
 

Dervius

Member
Oct 28, 2017
4,892
UK
Yep yep yep yep yep. Magnus is especially great because there are so damn many. I almost wept for joy when I found out how many episodes there were. When you find something that good, you don't want it to end.

Started Magnus on the drive home today. I have a 90 min or so commute each way so it's great for podcasts. Starting strong. Couldn't believe how many episodes there were. I'm from the UK so it's cool getting a home-based one too.

Great suggestion.
 

Truant

Member
Oct 28, 2017
6,757
I liked Magnus Archives more when there was no overarching mythology. The stand-alone stories with no "explanation" are much scarier.
 

Rodan

Member
Nov 3, 2017
634
If you haven't yet, try The Dark Verse. I recommend listening to Episode 1 and see if it tickles your fancy. It's a strange narrator, reading cosmic horror/fantasy/occult stories. Something about it is somehow satisfying to listen to
 

Rassilon

Member
Oct 27, 2017
10,583
UK
Magnus Archives is the best for sure.

  • Incredibly rewarding to listen to repeatedly
  • Great meta plot that increases naturally over time
  • Excellent writing
  • Great characters
  • Well produced
  • Fab research
  • There's over 100 episodes
  • Truly horrifying
  • Dark humour
  • British
 
Last edited:

NTGYK

Attempted to circumvent ban with an alt-account
Banned
Oct 29, 2017
3,470
MAGNUS ARCHIVES IS THE BEST FOR SURE
 

poptire

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
9,970
I HIGHLY recommend a now-defunct podcast called Hometown Tales.

There are 300 episodes to go through, and they're all about regional ghost stories/superstitions from around the country.

The show itself has a very folksy feel that kinda adds to the creep factor, and you genuinely learn about American regional culture.
 
Hometown Tales sounds like it might be up my alley. Thanks, poptire.

Also, to get the most out of these horror podcasts, I highly recommend to everyone to take a genre breather every few episodes and listen to "My Dad Wrote a Porno." The absurd comedy of it is just the thing to really highlight the dread, I promise. You might pee yourself laughing, though. Fair warning.


Started Magnus on the drive home today. I have a 90 min or so commute each way so it's great for podcasts. Starting strong. Couldn't believe how many episodes there were. I'm from the UK so it's cool getting a home-based one too.

Great suggestion.

Huzzah! Can't wait to hear what you think as you get deeper in. It's a really rewarding series. Afterwards, The White Vault should definitely be next.

Wow this looks great, sounds like an SCP podcast!

I've heard about the SCP stuff, but never listened. It's definitely in that vein, though. Well worth your time (and Patreon-age).

Holy shit 130 episodes.

Right? 153 now! :D
 

Kurdel

Member
Nov 7, 2017
12,157
I've heard about the SCP stuff, but never listened. It's definitely in that vein, though. Well worth your time (and Patreon-age).

SCP is a website that is like a catalogue of the things in that Indiana Jones Warehouse. But then I googled to see if they have a podcast, and they literally started one this week, first episode was out Monday!!!

So, thank you for making me google that, incredible timing!! 😂
 

studyguy

Member
Oct 26, 2017
11,282
The Magnus Archives
The story arc they eventually introduced was sorta w/e... it was interesting when it was really esoteric, but as things get explained it gets less interesting. Thankfully that arc takes a backseat to the horror one shots.
 

apocat

Member
Oct 27, 2017
10,039
I don't really care for fiction in podcasts. However, I do like podcasts about real myths, horror tales and the like. I've listened to and enjoyed quite a few episodes of Lore.
 

Zeusy

Avenger
Oct 30, 2017
1,814
WA
So because of this thread I started the white vault today and I'm on episode 8, I'm hooked. Starting the Magnus archives next. Thanks era
 

sapien85

Banned
Nov 8, 2017
5,427
Always looking for new podcasts so I'll check these recommendations. I liked Night Vale theoretically but bounced off after a dozen episodes.
 

Dervius

Member
Oct 28, 2017
4,892
UK
Huzzah! Can't wait to hear what you think as you get deeper in. It's a really rewarding series. Afterwards, The White Vault should definitely be next.

10 Episodes in. I see what OP was saying about a single narrator, but I think it's simplicity is its strength. The writing is good and the production is simple but solid. Very much enjoying it as a subtly interweaved anthology.
 
Tried Hometown Tales, poptire , but only got 20 mins into one episode and couldn't keep going. The two hosts just amble about in circles like they only skimmed the titles of tabloid mags and can't even remember any of the details. They couldn't even keep the details straight of what they were discussing 10 secs earlier in the episode. Does it get any better?

Had better luck with King Falls AM, Harp. It's not scary, but it is charming and pretty funny in places. Wasn't sure if I'd enjoy the format, but Sammy has a really nice voice and the content is so wacky. Thanks~

SCP is a website that is like a catalogue of the things in that Indiana Jones Warehouse. But then I googled to see if they have a podcast, and they literally started one this week, first episode was out Monday!!!

So, thank you for making me google that, incredible timing!! 😂

Oh, perfect! I'll check it out too!

So because of this thread I started the white vault today and I'm on episode 8, I'm hooked. Starting the Magnus archives next. Thanks era

tenor.gif


10 Episodes in. I see what OP was saying about a single narrator, but I think it's simplicity is its strength. The writing is good and the production is simple but solid. Very much enjoying it as a subtly interweaved anthology.

Keep a close 'ear' on the details. The story was very, very well planned, and so many things are connected. It's really fun to go back and re-listen and suddenly realize that the throwaway flavor text from ep. 000 relates to the fate of Bob in ep. xxx. Keep throwing out your thoughts too!
 

Azolith

Member
Oct 25, 2017
67
If you want some weird horror I'd suggest checking out SPINES.

Two months ago, Wren woke up covered in blood, suffering from memory loss, and surrounded by the remnants of some strange cult ritual. SPINES is the story of her search for answers, and the deadly, powerful people she encounters along the way.
 

poptire

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
9,970
Tried Hometown Tales, poptire , but only got 20 mins into one episode and couldn't keep going. The two hosts just amble about in circles like they only skimmed the titles of tabloid mags and can't even remember any of the details. They couldn't even keep the details straight of what they were discussing 10 secs earlier in the episode. Does it get any better?

Had better luck with King Falls AM, Harp. It's not scary, but it is charming and pretty funny in places. Wasn't sure if I'd enjoy the format, but Sammy has a really nice voice and the content is so wacky. Thanks~



Oh, perfect! I'll check it out too!



tenor.gif




Keep a close 'ear' on the details. The story was very, very well planned, and so many things are connected. It's really fun to go back and re-listen and suddenly realize that the throwaway flavor text from ep. 000 relates to the fate of Bob in ep. xxx. Keep throwing out your thoughts too!

Which episode of Hometown Tales did you hit? I mostly listened to dedicated episodes, like the one a out the Bell Witch.
 
Which episode of Hometown Tales did you hit? I mostly listened to dedicated episodes, like the one a out the Bell Witch.

It was #2 about the dead Japanese dad and headless chicken, etc. It felt so aimless and seemed like they constantly corrected each other or contradicted themselves as if they'd barely looked at the material right before they sat down. I'm sure they get better as the podcast series continues, but it wasn't a great start.
 

Telecinision

Member
Aug 22, 2018
132

corasaur

Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,988
I'm really really glad that this turned into a magnus archives thread.

My other top tier spooky podcasts are the already-mentioned Knifepoint horror and I am in Eskew.

Eskew is about a british expat making his way in the perpetually-rainy city-state of eskew where reality is 15 seconds from falling apart into nightmares at all times.

King falls AM is fantastic and on their level but I sort it in a different category because it doesn't always go for scares.
 

Harp

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,206
The Amazon Originals adaptation of the podcast made a big misstep by not including Mahnke's narration, in my opinion.
I hate to be a contrarian, but his narration was the primary reason I couldn't keep listening. I felt like he kept poising way too many beats of each story as stunning twists, and punctuated it each time wit the phrase "you see" and it became really noticeable, and really annoying.

Ex.: "The problem, you see, was that the woman never died. It was, in fact, her husband's memory, you see, that kept her very much alive."

I made the sentence up, so apologies if it reads too silly. I just felt like every other sentence in Lore sounded like that.
 

Bulletzen

Member
Oct 30, 2017
554
Shadows at the Door has some good tales. It's drama that focuses more on creepy ghost stories with some classics from the likes of Charles Dickens and M.R. James mixed in with new stories. The first half is the tale itself and the second half is the writer/producer and actor shooting the breeze about the story, writers, films etc
https://www.shadowsatthedoor.com/the-podcast