Finally watched UPF and got to the borderlands segment. Brad and Jeff are straight up delusional.
holy shit
Destiny has poisoned their minds
I feel like there's just a part of being a video game critic that makes it so you can just never reject an industry trend outright. You have to just accept the terms of the industry set by studios and even if you're disappointed with it, that's just-the-way-things-are so you start judging everything on these utterly weird standards and having expectations that push everything toward being the same, even if you complain all the time that everything is the same. It's some sort of bizarro video-game Stockholm Syndrome. "Sure, this sucks, but that's The Future and we have to work within its parameters anyway." I felt like this back in 2013 (which I've been thinking about more as the generation is coming to an end) and how it was just accepted common knowledge that the next consoles from everyone were going to be always-online anti-used game hardware, and well, that's just the world we live in now, gotta deal with it, sure it sucks but oh well, everything's just like this now, overnight we just have to accept those terms and move on. It's weird.
Borderlands being more Borderlands is super cool - I don't want more pseudo-MMOs with half-baked progression systems and tons of re-used content that is somehow supposed to be more innovative and cool than just being a cool, complete offline package you sell DLC for instead. I don't need to just accept that things like Destiny/The Division/Anthem are just-the-way-everything-is-now and get used to it even if it sucks and is continuously disappointing.
Oddly though, even after saying this, I have vague memories of Jeff always having utterly bizarre expectations for what he keeps thinking Borderlands is supposed to be, going all the way back to the first game which were more or less this sort of thing - complaints of no online shared spaces, no "proper trading system", etc. I don't know why in Jeff's mind Borderlands needs to be hamstrung as some sort of half-assed MMO, or why that's "new" or "innovative" in any way, but that's different opinions.