Still plan to play a fair bit more with friends, but so far my experience has been extremely rough. The networking issues on the first night were disappointing but perhaps understandable, but this game feels buggy as hell in general. It's such a shitty experience for the gamers dedicated enough to pay extra for the sake of playing early.
In MP, I'm being matchmade with people on the West Coast despite being in the UK in MP (meaning that I'm experiencing far higher pings than I enjoy) and the skill based matchmaking seems completely worthless so far (early days sure, but it's pretty disturbing that I'm regularly playing against people who have XP levels >50 while mine is under 10). Ranking system itself seems to be broken, at least from an interface point of view, so no information whatsoever on whether my rank is improving or falling. Perhaps related to the apparent lack of tight region matchmaking, but had some extremely dubious hit detection instances over the last couple of days too.
I think I'm over this franchise, having adored it last generation. It feels like a relic. The juxtaposition of the legitimised glitch wall bouncing with the rest of the game which feels slow and weighty and unresponsive is fucking bizarre and it is by far the biggest mistake that was made with this franchise. Either make a considered, deliberately paced game or don't. Don't do half and half. It's a huge turn off for me and I'm sure it is for a lot of new and returning players when compared to what else is out there.
I'll give the game some more time once I have people to play with, but I don't see this having legs for us at all.